Temporal Generalization: A Reality Check

Divyam Madaan, Sumit Chopra, Kyunghyun Cho · 2025

Read Temporal Generalization: A Reality Check by Divyam Madaan, Sumit Chopra, Kyunghyun Cho (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-23487.txt.

Introduction

Models trained on past data often fade when the future looks different. Divyam Madaan, Sumit Chopra, and Kyunghyun Cho ask whether clever use of old model weights can beat that fade. They test two families of tricks: blending past weights in weighted mixes, and pushing beyond those mixes by extrapolation. Tasks range from language modeling and news work to land-use maps from satellite images and gender calls on old yearbook photos.

No method in either family beat one plain baseline across the board: just use the newest model's weights. Without future data or strong assumptions about how data are made, the authors warn, claims of reaching into the future deserve doubt.

Catalog record

CREATORDivyam Madaan, Sumit Chopra, Kyunghyun Cho
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-23487

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Temporal Generalization: A Reality Check Divyam Madaan, Sumit Chopra, Kyunghyun Cho Abstract Machine learning (ML) models often struggle to maintain performance under distribution shifts, leading to inaccurate predictions on unseen future data. In this work, we investigate whether and under what conditions models can achieve such a generalization when relying solely on past data. We explore two primary approaches: convex combinations of past model parameters ( parameter interpolation ) and explicit extrapolation beyond the convex hull of past parameters ( parameter extrapolation ). We benchmark several methods within these categories on a diverse set of temporal tasks, including language modeling, news summarization, news tag prediction, academic paper categorization, satellite image-based land use classification over time, and historical yearbook photo gender prediction. Our empirical findings show that none of the evaluated methods consistently outperforms the simple baseline of using the latest available model parameters in all scenarios. In the absence of access to future data or robust assumptions about the underlying data-generating process, these results underscore the inherent difficulties of generalizing and extrapolating to future data and warrant caution when evaluating claims of such generalization. 1 Introduction “Prediction is very difficult, especially about the future.” – Niels Bohr Temporal generalization of machine learning (ML) models is challenging, but critically important. After being trained on retrospective data, these models are deployed in real-world applications, particularly in high-stake domains such as finance, healthcare, and autonomous systems, where the distribution of the data the model sees could drift over time. Failures in these contexts can lead to severe financial losses or pose significant risks to human safety. It is therefore crucial to develop and evaluate models under deployment scenarios that accurately reflect temporal evolution. Yet, despite significant progress and widespread adoption, ML models suffer from performance degradation on data collected after the training period ( Jaidka et al. 2018 ; Luu et al. 2021 ; Nylund et al. 2024 ) . This issue of temporal performance degradation is widespread, affecting even large-scale state-of-the-art models such as GPT-4 ( Achiam et al. 2023 ) and Gemini ( Team et al. 2023 ) . Figure 1 (left) shows this challenge, illustrating a 30% increase in perplexity when a model trained on past news summarization data is evaluated on future months, compared to a model adapted with more recent data. Such degradation in temporal generalization can lead to real-world consequences. The substantial financial and computational costs associated with training these foundation models ( Cottier et al. 2024 ) make frequent retraining economically impractical. This necessitates alternative strategies for maintaining model utility over time. With complete knowledge of the underlying data-generating process, it would, in principle, be possible to construct a model that generalizes effectively to future data. However, in most practical settings, this assumption is overly idealized and rarely holds. Motivated by this limitation, this paper addresses the following central question: Can we build a model generalizable to the future without any access to future data and imperfect knowledge of the data-generating process? We adopt a stringent yet realistic setting to evaluate temporal generalization, as illustrated in Figure 1 (right). At a given time t , we have access to a sequence of model parameters (or checkpoints) \{\theta_{1},\dots,\theta_{t}\} which resulted from training on historical data. Our objective is to leverage this sequence of checkpoints to estimate a new set of parameters, denoted \widetilde{\theta}_{t+\delta} , that will exhibit temporal generalization on unseen data \mathcal{D}_{t+\delta} at a specific time into the future t+\delta (where \delta>0 ). In addressing this question, we posit that any approach that only leverages retrospective data can be grouped into two categories: Parameter interpolation ( Ilharco et al. 2022 ; Yadav et al. 2024 ; Davari and Belilovsky 2024 ; Jang et al. 2024 ; Dziadzio et al. 2024 ) . This conservative yet intuitive approach restricts the search space for new parameters to the convex hull defined by past parameter checkpoints. We explore model merging ( Ilharco et al. 2022 ; Yadav et al. 2024 ; Davari and Belilovsky 2024 ) and a simple downscaling of the recent model parameters. The underlying intuition is twofold: parameters from the recent past might contain information relevant to the near future, and simple scaling might mitigate model overconfidence on unseen future data. Parameter extrapolation ( Nasery et al. 2021 ; Bai et al. 2023 ; Cai et al. 2024 ; Nylund et al. 2024 ) . A more ambitious approach involves explicitly estimating future model parameters by extrapolating beyond the convex hull defined by the trajectory of past parameter values. This method operates under the hypothesis that the temporal evolution of model parameters, observable from historical training dynamics ( Nylund et al. 2024 ) , can inform predictions about future parameters, even in the absence of future data access. In particular, we investigate whether a Taylor series-based approximation can facilitate effective extrapolation of model parameters into the future. Figure 1 : (Left) Performance degrades over time. The widening performance gap between a stale model trained once in January 2012 (red) and a monthly updated model (green) illustrates the decay in performance over time. The evaluation was conducted using data from March 2012 onward. (Right) Temporal generalization framework. Across sequential learning stages ( S_{t} on the y-axis), a model f_{\theta_{t}} is trained on data \mathcal{D}_{t} (orange) initialized with \theta_{t-1} from the previous stage. This generates a sequence of historical parameters. This sequence is used to estimate future parameters \widetilde{\theta}_{t+\delta} , which are used to evaluate future data (blue) \mathcal{D}_{t+\delta} for \delta>0 (x-axis). We conducted a comprehensive empirical study comparing several methods representative of these two categories. Our evaluation spans a diverse array of temporal datasets and tasks, such as language modeling on evolving news corpora, news summarization and tag prediction, categorization of academic papers, land use classification from satellite imagery reflecting changes over several years, and gender prediction from historical yearbook photos spanning multiple decades. There are significant challenges that complicate the rigorous evaluation of temporal generalization methods. Existing studies are limited to simplistic setups and lack real-world applicability due to high computational cost ( Nasery et al. 2021 ; Bai et al. 2023 ; Cai et al. 2024 ) , non-transparent hyperparameter selection ( Bai et al. 2023 ; Cai et al. 2024 ; Nylund et al. 2024 ) and the use of future data during model adaptation ( Nylund et al. 2024 ; Cha and Cho 2024 ) . Additionally, the inherent non-identifiability of deep neural networks ( Hecht-Nielsen 1990 ; Sussmann 1992 ; Phuong and Lampert 2020 ) yields non-linear parameter trajectories, which complicates both interpolation and extrapolation. Addressing these prevailing gaps, we provide the first holistic evaluation of these interpolation and extrapolation methods within large-scale settings. The findings of this study highlight the intrinsic challenges of forecasting future model parameters based solely on historical trajectories, particularly in the absence of access to future data distributions or validated assumptions about the underlying data-generating process. Among the evaluated methods, the only one that consistently avoided performance degradation across datasets was the downscaling of recent model parameters. To better understand these outcomes, we conduct a detailed temporal analysis of parameter dynamics and discuss the implications of key design choices. We hope these insights will inform future research

Read the complete text