On the mechanism of Pedestal Relaxation Events - Insights gained by turbulence simulations with GRILLIX

Christoph Pitzal, Andreas Stegmeir, Tim Happel, Kaiyu Zhang, Konrad Eder, Wladimir Zholobenko, Philipp Ulbl, Manuel Herschel, Frank Jenko, The ASDEX Upgrade Team · 2025

Read On the mechanism of Pedestal Relaxation Events - Insights gained by turbulence simulations with GRILLIX by Christoph Pitzal, Andreas Stegmeir, Tim Happel, Kaiyu Zhang, Konrad Eder, Wladimir Zholobenko, Philipp Ulbl, Manuel Herschel, Frank Jenko, The ASDEX Upgrade Team (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-22948.txt.

Introduction

Christoph Pitzal and co-authors, with the ASDEX Upgrade Team, simulate bursts at the edge of a fusion plasma. These bursts, called pedestal relaxation events, eject energy in I-mode discharges. They look like a better known burst type but seem to work in a distinct way. The team ran global fluid simulations with the GRILLIX code.

The runs produced bursts that matched many traits seen in the real device. Close study of mode traits pointed to micro-tearing modes as the trigger. Paths in gradient space matched growth rates from simple linear theory. The authors sketch a full burst cycle from these clues. They also note hard parts of modeling low-collision plasmas.

Catalog record

CREATORChristoph Pitzal, Andreas Stegmeir, Tim Happel, Kaiyu Zhang, Konrad Eder, Wladimir Zholobenko, Philipp Ulbl, Manuel Herschel, Frank Jenko, The ASDEX Upgrade Team
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-22948

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the mechanism of Pedestal Relaxation Events - Insights gained by turbulence simulations with GRILLIX Preprint: AIP/123-QED Christoph Pitzal, Andreas Stegmeir, Tim Happel, Kaiyu Zhang, Konrad Eder, Wladimir Zholobenko, Philipp Ulbl, Manuel Herschel, Frank Jenko, The ASDEX Upgrade Team Abstract Pedestal Relaxation Events (PREs) appear in I-mode discharges close to the I-H transition. Although they show certain similarities with Edge Localised Modes (ELMs), i.e. periodic energy ejections, the underlying mechanism seems to be very different from the mechanism responsible for ELMs. In this manuscript, we present global trans-collisional fluid simulations of an I-mode discharge in ASDEX Upgrade using GRILLIX . We observe multiple PREs during the simulation, which reproduce a range of experimentally observed PRE characteristics. Furthermore, a detailed analysis of various mode properties in our simulation allows us to pinpoint the underlying mechanism responsible for triggering PREs to Micro-Tearing Modes (MTMs). The system is analysed dynamically by evaluating density and electron temperature gradient lengths at the OMP position, where the MTM is located and grows over time. The path taken by the system in gradient length space is compared to a growth-rate estimate calculated by linear theory in simplified slab geometry, providing excellent agreement. Building on these insights, we sketch a qualitative picture of a full PRE cycle. Finally, we discuss the influence of the recently implemented Landau-fluid closure and the challenges of simulating low collisionality regimes with trans-collisional fluid models, like the one employed by GRILLIX . I Introduction Operational regimes for future fusion reactors should provide high confinement, while not exceeding material limits at the wall of the device. Studying and gaining deeper insights into such reactor-relevant regimes is therefore a task of major importance on the way to the first fusion power plant. The improved energy confinement mode (I-mode) is such a reactor-relevant regime, which is characterised by elevated energy confinement time, low impurity content and the absence of Type-I Edge Localised Modes (ELMs) Whyte_2010 ; Happel_2017 . Although there are no Type-I ELMs present in I-mode, some discharges show Pedestal Relaxation Events (PREs), especially when the operating point is close to the I-H transition. PREs cause periodic energy ejections on significantly lower levels than ELMs, about 1% of the plasma stored energy Silvagni_2020 . In contrast to ELMs, which are triggered by Peeling-Ballooning modes that become unstable in the pedestal region huijsmans_2015 , PREs are expected to be caused by a different mechanism. PREs were observed and studied in ASDEX Upgrade and Alcator C-Mod Silvagni_2022 , a similar phenomenon was also observed in EAST Zhong_2022 . In experiments, PREs affect mainly the electron temperature profile and show magnetic activity during the event Silvagni_2020 ; Silvagni_2022 . Attempts to simulate PREs with a gyrofluid model have been performed Manz_PRE_2021 . The authors expected Micro-Tearing Modes (MTMs) as presumable candidates to cause PREs. However, within their qualitative simulations in simple geometry, they observed for the PRE a transition from drift-wave to interchange-like turbulence with no significant electromagnetic transport. Simulating edge conditions in I-mode with fluid models is rather challenging due to the low collisionality present in the edge region of a fusion device ( \rho_{\mathrm{pol}}>0.9 ). The edge turbulence fluid code GRILLIX stegmeir_grillix19 was recently extended in the direction of low collisionality by implementing a Landau-fluid closure for parallel conductive heat fluxes pitzal_landau_2023 . Figure 1 : Time traces of the input power and OMP profiles of electron temperature, density and perturbed radial magnetic field. The PREs are marked with grey dotted lines. Within this paper, GRILLIX is used for studying I-mode conditions, the relevant parameters and geometry are taken from the ASDEX Upgrade discharge # 37980, a steady I-mode discharge with no PREs present at the relevant time. We present a simulation spanning a physical time of more than 5\;\mathrm{ms} , where three intermittent bursts occur, that are identified as PREs. The focus of this work is on a qualitative picture of PREs. The characteristics of the PREs in the simulation are compared to experimental findings. A detailed analysis of the underlying microinstability reveals that the PREs in our simulation are caused by MTMs. The clearest fingerprints are the visible tearing parity, the radial electromagnetic electron heat transport and the dispersion relation computed from the simulation data, which matches nicely linear kinetic estimates for MTMs Hatch_2021 . A distinct difference is that the stored energy after a PRE in our simulation is increased, while in the experiment, it is decreased. However, we clarify that this originates in the way boundary conditions are applied in the simulation. Furthermore, we investigate the dynamic behaviour of the system by calculating the density and temperature gradient lengths at \rho_{\mathrm{pol}}=0.95 , where the MTM is centred. The path taken by the system is visualised in gradient-length space and agrees very well with an analytical estimate of the MTM growth rate. This linear estimate is calculated in the present article for our fluid plasma model, including the Landau-fluid closure, in simplified slab geometry following previous theoretical work Hassam_1980 , predicting positive linear growth rates for MTMs. We investigate the impact of the Landau-fluid closure by comparison to a simulation with the Braginskii closure, including heat-flux limiters, which does not show any PREs. The linear analysis is performed as well for the Braginskii closure, revealing that, in contrast to the Landau-fluid closure, MTMs are linearly stable in this case. Finally, we discuss why PREs are observed in our simulation even though they do not occur in the discharge under investigation, and what role is played by the parallel resistivity. This paper is organised as follows. In section II , a short introduction to MTMs is provided, section III explains the simulation setup in detail. In section IV we elaborate on the PREs present in our simulations and provide evidence that the presented PREs are caused by MTMs. In section V , we propose a global mechanism for the steps of a PRE cycle. The importance of the fluid closure used for the simulations is highlighted in section VI , including the linear analysis for the growth rate of our fluid model. Finally, in section VII a discussion and in section VIII a summary and outlook of this work are provided. II Microtearing Modes MTMs are electromagnetic micro-instabilities with high poloidal mode number m . For most experimentally relevant conditions, they are driven by the electron temperature gradient Hazeltine_1975 ; Gladd_1980 ; Hatch_2021 . The mechanism which increases the radial transport can be depicted as follows: MTMs form magnetic islands within the plasma. When the islands grow large enough, the magnetic field becomes stochastic, parallel and perpendicular transport couple and the radial transport is increased Guttenfelder_PRL_2011 ; Doerk_PRL_2011 . With this picture, it becomes evident that MTMs feature increased electromagnetic transport, due to the field stochastisation, and predominantly an increase in the radial electron heat transport, due to the rapid parallel electron heat conduction. A simple kinetic dispersion relation for the complex frequency \omega of an MTM can be found in Hatch_2021 ; Hazeltine_1975 and reads \left(\nu-0.51i\omega\right)\left(\omega-\omega_{p}^{\star}\right)-0.8\omega_{T}^{\star}\nu=0 (1) with \omega_{p}^{\star}=k_{y}\rho_{s}c_{s}\left(1/L_{n}+1/L_{Te}\right) and \omega_{T}^{\star}=k_{y}\rho_{s}c_{s}\left(1/L_{Te}\right) , \nu the electron collision frequency huba1998nrl , i the imaginary unit, k_{y} the binormal wavenumber, \rho_{s}=\sqrt{T_{e}M_{i}}/(eB) the sound Larmor radius, c_{s}=\sqrt{T_{e}/M_{i}} the ion sound velocity. The gradient lengths are defined as

Read the complete text