HEART: Emotionally-driven test-time scaling of Language Models
Gabriela Pinto, Palash Goyal, Yiwen Song, Souradip Chakraborty, Zifeng Wang, Tomas Pfister, Hamid Palangi · 2025
Read HEART: Emotionally-driven test-time scaling of Language Models by Gabriela Pinto, Palash Goyal, Yiwen Song, Souradip Chakraborty, Zifeng Wang, Tomas Pfister, Hamid Palangi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-22876.txt.
Introduction
Emotional cues can steer a language model out of stuck, wrong lines of thought. Gabriela Pinto and 8 co-authors build HEART, a test-time method that needs no new training. It swaps between a sharp, critical tone and a warm, supportive tone. The critical tone helps the model spot errors, and the warm tone helps it try fresh ideas.
The team tested HEART on seven hard benchmarks, among them Humanity's Last Exam and GPQA Diamond. It also faced LiveCodeBench, a coding test. Across varied models, HEART beat plain, emotion-free baselines on accuracy. The authors argue that guiding feelings may be a next step for machine reasoning.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gabriela Pinto, Palash Goyal, Yiwen Song, Souradip Chakraborty, Zifeng Wang, Tomas Pfister, Hamid Palangi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-22876
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
HEART: Emotionally-driven test-time scaling of Language Models Gabriela Pinto, Palash Goyal, Yiwen Song, Souradip Chakraborty, Zifeng Wang, Tomas Pfister, Hamid Palangi Abstract Test-time scaling has shown considerable success in improving the performance of language models on complex reasoning tasks without requiring fine-tuning. However, current strategies such as self-reflection primarily focus on logical or structural refinement. They do not leverage the guiding potential of affective feedback. Inspired by psychological research showing that emotions can modulate cognitive performance, we introduce HEART –a novel framework that uses emotionally-driven prompts for iterative self-correction. HEART provides feedback on a model’s incorrect response using a curated set of concise, emotionally charged phrases based on the six universal emotions categorized by Dr. Paul Ekman. By systematically varying the emotional tone of the feedback across iterations, our method guides the model to escape flawed reasoning paths and explore more promising alternatives. We evaluate our framework on challenging reasoning benchmarks including OlympiadBench, Humanity’s Last Exam, and SimpleQA. Our results reveal a significant new phenomenon: when guided by an oracle verifier, this affective iteration protocol unlocks significantly deeper reasoning, leading to consistent and substantial increases in accuracy over state-of-the-art baselines with the same verifier. However, we also identify a critical bottleneck for practical deployment. In a verifier-free setting, it struggles to harness these gains consistently, highlighting as a key challenge for future work. Our findings suggest that the next frontier in machine reasoning may lie not just in refining logic, but also in understanding and leveraging the ‘ HEART ’ of the models. \uselogo \reportnumber 0001 1 Introduction Large language models have demonstrated remarkable capabilities, yet eliciting reliable, complex reasoning remains a fundamental challenge. As models have scaled, research has moved beyond simple instruction-following to explore more methods of guidance. Structured reasoning techniques, such as Chain-of-Thought (CoT) ( Wei et al. 2022 ) and its variants ( Wang et al. 2022 ; Yao et al. 2023 ) , impose a logical scaffold on the model’s output, enhancing procedural correctness by externalizing the reasoning process. In parallel, initial explorations leveraging affective prompting, such as EmotionPrompt ( Li et al. 2023 ) , have shown that emotional cues can boost performance by igniting the model’s “cognitive state” and guiding its focus. Despite their successes, these two approaches suffer from a critical, complementary limitation. Structured methods are procedurally robust but affectively sterile; they provide a logical path but fail to leverage the motivational contexts that drive high-quality human reasoning. This sterility can lead to brittle performance, where models correctly execute a known algorithm but fail on novel problems requiring creative error recovery. Conversely, existing affective prompts are motivationally potent but structurally imprecise. They typically act as a “one-shot” global stimulus, which lacks the targeted guidance necessary to steer a model through a multi-step self-correction process. Consequently, a significant gap exists in the literature: there is no established method that unifies the systematic control of structured reasoning with the targeted application of affective cues for iterative self-improvement. We address this gap by drawing on a core finding from cognitive science: emotion is not an impediment to cognition but an integral component, shaping attention, motivation, and problem-solving. To operationalize this insight for LLMs, we introduce HEART as a means of increasing accuracy and performance improvement. This novel framework integrates controlled emotional stimuli within an iterative refinement loop. We investigate the following research question: To what extent, and under what conditions, can emotional prompting improve the self-correction ability of LLMs? Figure 1: An illustration of the HEART framework. The process begins when a task is sent to a large language model (LLM), which returns a response. An oracle then evaluates the response against the ground truth. If the response is incorrect, the HEART process begins, incorporating the original task, the LLM’s response, and selected affective cue prompts to generate a new, improved response. HEART operates as an iterative self-correction loop. After a model produces an initial, incorrect response, HEART provides feedback now as a logical critique, but as a concise, emotionally charged phrase. These phrases are drawn from a curated set based on Dr. Paul Ekman’s six basic emotions (e.g., happiness, sadness, surprise, anger, fear, disgust). Our central hypothesis, inspired by opponent-process theory of emotion ( Solomon and Corbit 1974 ) , is that targeted affective feedback can trigger a corrective cognitive state. For example, a prompt conveying “disappointment” in an answer can motivate the model to abandon its flawed reasoning, and attempt a new one, similar to how humans leverage dissatisfaction to renew a problem-solving effort. This process creates a form of affective metacognition, using emotion as a tool to scaffold the model’s ability to “re-think” and improve its outputs. We acknowledge the important ethical considerations regarding the use of harsh language in our prompts. These phrases were designed strictly as a diagnostic tool to probe the model’s response to a wide spectrum of affective stimuli, akin to adversarial testing. Our goal is to understand the model’s mechanisms, not to endorse or normalize harmful interaction patterns. We do not encourage such interactions with AI systems. Given that our method’s success relies on dynamic valence alternation, we propose that future work should leverage the constructive negative prompts used in our paper instead of harsher negative stimuli. We conduct experiments on a suite of challenging reasoning benchmarks– OlympiadBench, Humanity’s Last Exam and SimpleQA. We evaluate HEART under two distinct conditions. First, in an oracle-guided verifier setting (S1), we isolate the method’s potential. Second, in a verifier-free setting (S2), we test its practical viability for real-world deployment where no ground truth is available. Our S1 results show that the potential of affective iteration is substantial. When guided by an oracle, HEART consistently outperforms state-of-the-art self-correction baselines across all benchmarks and models which leverage the same oracle. This demonstrates that dynamic affective cues are highly effective at guiding the model to generate correct solutions that logical-only prompts fail to elicit. However, our S2 results reveal a critical challenge: in the verifier-free setting, our generative synthesis method fails to consistently capture these gains, often performing on-par with or worse than baselines. This provides a crucial insight: the practical bottleneck for this approach lies not in the model’s capacity for generation, but in its ability to select the correct reasoning path during the synthesis process. Our key contributions are: 1. A Novel Iterative Protocol for Affective Self-Correction. We propose a novel framework that uses targeted emotional cues in a multi-step refinement loop, a significant departure from existing one-shot psychological prompting methods. 2. An Empirical Demonstration of Affective Iteration’s Potential. We provide the first strong evidence that dynamic, iterative emotional cues can, when guided by an oracle, significantly and consistently improve reasoning and self-correction over affect-sterile baselines. 3. Identification of the Selection Mechanism as a Critical Bottleneck. By contrasting our strong S1 (oracle) results with our S2 (verifier-free) results, we identify a key gap between the potential of affective generation and the limitations of current autonomous selection methods, pinpointing this as a key challenge for future work. 4. Generalizability of Potential. We demonstrate that the performance gains in the S1 setting are robust across a diverse suite of challenging benchmarks, including OlympiadBench, Humanity’s Last Exam, and SimpleQA, and generalize across a wide