Dissecting Multi-Level Pricing Schemes in the Context of eCW Client Engagement
Paramahansa Pramanik, Joel Graff, Mike Decaro · 2025
Read Dissecting Multi-Level Pricing Schemes in the Context of eCW Client Engagement by Paramahansa Pramanik, Joel Graff, Mike Decaro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-22669.txt.
Introduction
Paramahansa Pramanik, Joel Graff, and Mike Decaro dissect a usage-based pricing scheme for a medical portal. The portal is the Intelligent Medical Objects ProblemIT service used by eClinicalWorks clients. Their framework first sets a stable monthly unit price per request. That price is the median from semi-parametric Bayesian smoothing spline analyses over a period spanning late 2015 to late 2016.
Clients then fall into eight volume-based tiers. Each client's charge is the unit price times its total request count. The data hold anomalies: hundreds of accounts with one or two registered users show disproportionately high request volumes. The proposed model builds in adjustments for those outlier accounts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paramahansa Pramanik, Joel Graff, Mike Decaro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-22669
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Dissecting Multi-Level Pricing Schemes in the Context of eCW Client Engagement Paramahansa Pramanik, Joel Graff, Mike Decaro Abstract This paper presents a usage-based pricing framework for the Intelligent Medical Objects’ ProblemIT™ Portal utilized by eClinicalWorks (eCW) clients. The approach begins by determining a stable monthly unit price per request, estimated as the median from semi-parametric Bayesian cubic smoothing spline analyses covering the period November 2015 to December 2016. Clients are subsequently segmented into eight volume-based tiers, with total charges computed by multiplying the derived median unit price by each client’s total request count. Examination of the dataset reveals that 806 accounts with a single registered user and 470 accounts with two registered users both exhibit disproportionately high request volumes. The proposed model incorporates adjustments to account for these anomalies. Key words: Business pipeline, logistic regression, Eclinical data, spline regression. 1 Introduction. eClinicalWorks (eCW) ( Edsall and Adler, 2008 ) is widely regarded as a leading provider of Electronic Health Record (EHR) systems, delivering integrated clinical and administrative solutions to a broad user base. Its technologies are adopted by more than 125,000 clinical specialists and approximately 850,000 additional healthcare professionals across diverse practice environments ( Evans, 2016 ) . The company’s platforms support a range of functions, including patient record management, clinical decision support, and revenue cycle optimization. Among these offerings, the Intelligent Medical Objects’ ProblemIT™ solution serves as a specialized portal that facilitates precise clinical terminology mapping, thereby enhancing documentation quality, billing accuracy, and interoperability between healthcare systems. This portal is central to the present study, which seeks to understand usage patterns and develop a robust pricing framework grounded in empirical data ( Dasgupta et al., 2023 ; Hertweck et al., 2023 ; Khan et al., 2024 ) . The analytical framework is constructed by first estimating the total volume of ProblemIT™ portal requests each month, then dividing this value by the monthly invoiced amount to derive a consistent unit price per request. November 2015 was selected as the baseline for the study, given that October 2015 marked the nationwide adoption of a new medical billing code system, an industry-wide transition that substantially altered how clients engaged with the ProblemIT™ solution ( Kakkat et al., 2023 ; Khan et al., 2023b ) . This transition, widely associated with the implementation of ICD-10 coding standards, represented a structural shift in documentation and coding behavior, potentially influencing both request frequency and billing dynamics ( Vikramdeo et al., 2023 ; Vikramdeo et al., 2024a ) . To ensure temporal consistency and avoid distortions from the immediate effects of this policy change, the dataset is confined to a 14-month period spanning November 2015 through December 2016. This post-transition interval provides a stable analytical window in which to observe typical client behavior, allowing the price-per-request metric to be evaluated under steady-state conditions rather than transitional anomalies ( Jackson et al., 2020 ; Pramanik, 2022a ) . The first stage of our analysis focuses on deriving a stable estimate of the monthly price per request. In this context, stability refers to a value that exhibits minimal variation over time, such that fluctuations, if present, are only detectable beyond the fourth decimal place ( Pramanik and Polansky, 2021 ) . Establishing this level of precision is essential to ensure that subsequent pricing calculations are not influenced by short-term volatility or transient anomalies. To formally evaluate the stability of the price-per-request series, we apply two widely used statistical tests for unit roots: the augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) test ( Dickey and Fuller, 1979 ) and the Phillips-Perron (PP) test ( Phillips and Perron, 1988 ) . The results from both procedures indicate that the series is stationary in its first-order difference, confirming that the underlying process meets the stability criteria outlined above ( Pramanik et al., 2024 ) . Having established stationarity, we proceed to identify the most appropriate time series model for capturing the observed dynamics. Competing models are compared using the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) ( Akaike, 2003 ) , with lower values indicating superior fit. This comparison reveals that a first-order moving average (MA) model yields the lowest AIC among the candidates considered. Nevertheless, while the MA(1) model provides a satisfactory baseline, our objective also includes minimizing the mean squared error (MSE) in the fitted values. To this end, we implement a semi-parametric Bayesian cubic smoothing spline approach ( Zhang et al., 1998 ) , which demonstrates a superior fit to the observed data ( Perou et al., 2000 ; Prat et al., 2010 ) . To guard against the undue influence of outliers and to reduce the risk of overfitting, both of which could distort cost estimates, we adopt the median of the spline’s predicted values as the representative monthly price per request. This approach combines statistical rigor with robustness, ensuring that the resulting price measure is both stable and reliable for downstream pricing model development ( Pramanik and Polansky, 2023b ) . Once the predicted monthly price per usage has been established through the preceding statistical procedures, the next stage of the analysis involves applying this value to the observed distribution of portal activity. Specifically, the total number of requests generated by all clients over the study period is organized into eight distinct volume-based tiers, as summarized in Table 1. For each tier, the total number of requests is multiplied by the estimated monthly price per request, yielding the corresponding cost for that usage category ( Pramanik, 2020 ; Pramanik and Polansky, 2023c ) . This tiered approach provides a structured framework for assessing how clients are distributed across varying levels of portal activity, thereby enabling the identification of patterns and anomalies in usage behavior. Of particular interest are instances where eCW customers maintain a relatively small number of user licenses, sometimes only one or two, yet generate a disproportionately high total volume of requests ( Pramanik, 2024b ; Vikramdeo et al., 2024b ) . Such cases, when contrasted with clients whose request volume more closely aligns with their reported license count, suggest potential inefficiencies or imbalances in the existing cost allocation structure. The identification of these outliers is made possible by direct comparison between the proposed usage-based pricing model and the current pricing framework, which determines charges primarily on the basis of the reported number of end users rather than actual system utilization ( Pramanik and Polansky, 2024 ) . This comparison not only highlights disparities in client usage patterns but also offers insight into how the adoption of a usage-driven tiered pricing model could address these discrepancies and promote a more equitable alignment between service consumption and cost ( Pramanik and Polansky, 2020 ) . The detection of accounts with minimal license counts but unusually high request volumes has important implications for both operational efficiency and revenue management within the eCW client base ( Pramanik and Maity, 2024 ; Bulls et al., 2025 ) . From a financial perspective, such usage patterns indicate that the current license-based pricing model may underrepresent the true level of system demand for these clients, resulting in a potential shortfall in revenue relative to actual resource utilization. From an equity standpoint, this misalignment can inadvertently lead to cross-subsidization, whereby low-usage clients effectively bear a proportion of the