Naturalistic intuitionism for physics

Bruno Bentzen, Flavio Del Santo, Nicolas Gisin · 2025

Read Naturalistic intuitionism for physics by Bruno Bentzen, Flavio Del Santo, Nicolas Gisin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-22528.txt.

Introduction

Bruno Bentzen, Flavio Del Santo, and Nicolas Gisin examine the philosophy behind a new take on physics foundations. Gisin and Del Santo have rebuilt parts of physics on intuitionistic logic, guided by naturalism. Intuitionism treats truth as tied to what can be constructed or known in time. The authors ask how this stance differs from Brouwer's original defense of intuitionistic mathematics.

They recast Brouwer's two acts of intuitionism as a self-contained frame for the physics version. The paper then traces how the naturalistic view handles logic, language, time, ontology, meaning, and truth. Each topic gets a treatment that sets it apart from the classical picture.

Catalog record

CREATORBruno Bentzen, Flavio Del Santo, Nicolas Gisin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-22528

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Naturalistic intuitionism for physics Bruno Bentzen, Flavio Del Santo, Nicolas Gisin Abstract Recently, a novel intuitionistic reconstruction of the foundations of physics has been primarily developed by Nicolas Gisin and Flavio Del Santo drawing on naturalism. Our goal in this paper is to examine and develop the philosophical background of their naturalistic intuitionism for physics in contrast with Brouwer’s defense of his intuitionistic mathematics. To be exact, we propose a systematic rearticulation of Brouwer’s so-called two acts of intuitionism to serve as the self-contained philosophical framework justifying naturalistic intuitionism in physics. This revision is accompanied by an investigation of the distinctive naturalistic treatment of some central intuitionistic topics, including logic, language, time, ontology, meaning, and truth. I Introduction Over the last decades, there has been much discussion about whether constructive mathematics can provide the mathematical background necessary to do physics Hellman 1993a ; Hellman 1993b ; Bridges 1995 ; Billinge 1997 ; Richman 2000 ; Fletcher 2002 . But it was not until the intuitionistic program put forward by Nicolas Gisin Gisin 2021a in recent years that a form of constructivism began to be seriously advocated by physicists themselves. Motivated by the intrinsic randomness of quantum mechanics, its point of departure is the acceptance that physics need not presuppose a deterministic worldview. It therefore appears promising to abandon classical mathematics — due to its inherently timeless nature — in favor of intuitionistic mathematics, which provides a non-deterministic and temporal framework more suited to the foundations of physics. More precisely, the idea is to model indeterminism employing the intuitionistic notion of a choice sequence, namely, a potentially infinite sequence whose elements may be chosen freely or according to a law (algorithm). This novel intuitionistic program for physics has been developed by Nicolas Gisin and Flavio Del Santo mostly jointly in a sequence of papers ( Del Santo 2018 ; Del Santo and Gisin 2019 ; Gisin 2020a ; Gisin 2021b ; Del Santo and Gisin 2021 ; Gisin 2021a ; Del Santo 2021 ; Del Santo and Gisin 2023a ; Del Santo and Gisin 2023b ; Del Santo and Gisin 2024 ; Del Santo and Gisin 2025 ) . 1 1 1 See also ( Eyink and Bandak 2020 ; Ben-Yami 2020 ; Dolev 2024 ) for further attempts in this direction. In this paper, we develop the philosophical background that underlies this new program and examine it against the original defense of intuitionism by L. E. J. Brouwer Brouwer 1975 ; Brouwer 1981 , thereby unveiling some crucial differences that until now have not been explicitly acknowledged in print. The main reason this is a valuable investigation to undertake is that the new intuitionism they advanced for physics is the product of a distinctive combination of naturalism and ontological realism, as opposed to the thorough idealism advocated by Brouwer without physical applications in mind. Indeed, as already admitted by Heyting, “introspection is useless in physics” ( Heyting 1974 , p. 90) . Yet, this naturalization of intuitionism shows that we can regardless retain some parts of intuitionistic mathematics and its philosophy that are useful in physics. It is therefore crucial that we identify the basic philosophical presuppositions that support this naturalization and how they differ from Brouwer’s own intuitionistic views. To be exact, our goal here is to develop the philosophy of “naturalistic intuitionism” by means of a systematic revision of Brouwer’s so-called two acts of intuitionism so as to serve as an autonomous naturalistic philosophical framework for physics. This development is then accompanied by an investigation of the distinctive naturalistic treatment of some central intuitionistic topics, including logic, language, time, ontology, meaning, and truth, that differ from Brouwer’s understanding of these themes. All this is done in Section IV . The remaining sections of this paper are structured as follows. First, in Section II , we motivate and sketch the basic elements of naturalistic intuitionism in a self-contained way mainly targeted at physicists and philosophers of science as our intended audience, without assuming any previous familiarity with Brouwer’s intuitionistic mathematics. Then, in Section III , we overview intuitionism as the original philosophy of mathematics put forward by Brouwer through his so-called two acts of intuitionism. Section V provides some concluding remarks. II Naturalistic intuitionism Time is essential for physics because “to be an event is to be in time” ( Dolev 2018 ) . Without time we cannot tell stories and provide scientific explanations. Despite this, today’s physics relegates time to a rather subaltern role. In most established physical theories, indeed, time is a mere parameter that labels a given succession of necessary events. And the situation is even more crystallized by a widespread relativistic worldview where time is geometrized to be just another coordinate, akin to space. Quantum theory, in its standard interpretation, is an exception and, actually, is part of our motivation. With such a lean concept of time, physicists cannot speak of real evolutions nor surprises. More precisely, all apparent “surprises” are merely explained away by our ignorance: Turn a card face up, and we may be surprised by the figure that appears. The figure, however, has always been there, and the surprise is thus only due to a subjective lack of knowledge. But real surprises, that is, events that are really — in an ontological sense — creating new information in the universe are hard or even impossible to describe with such a lean “geometric” view of time. In short, the current fundamental understanding of time in physics makes it hard to incorporate randomness, indeterminacy and creative evolutions. However, what quantum theory strongly suggests is that some new events truly obtain: they happen although they were not predetermined. Such events are genuinely random; they involve the creation of new information—not by an agent, but existing in the universe, encoded in some physical medium—that did not exist prior to the occurrence of the event. One can, in fact, consider the fundamental distinction between “before” and “after” as a consequence of the emergence of novel information, thereby enabling the very notion of true becoming. We will return to this alternative conception of time later in Section IV.1 . Quantum physics supports the above-mentioned idea of indeterminism due to two main results: (i) Heisenberg uncertainty relations (better-named indeterminacy relations); (ii) the violation of Bell inequalities. Heisenberg relations impose an absolute minimal value (quantified by \hbar ) to the smallest volume that a physical state can occupy, i.e., fundamental indeterminacy. 2 2 2 Note that indeterminacy is a kinematical feature, meaning that the pure state of a system does not determine all measurement outcomes. By contrast, indeterminism is a property of the dynamics: given the pure state (possibly of the universe) and the laws of physics, there need not be a unique continuation of the state into the future (nor into the past). Yet if measurements yield only a single outcome, indeterminacy leads to indeterminism, since a pure state leaves several outcomes open. From the same initial state, multiple future continuations are possible. However, this indeterminacy may exist only at the level of the theory and could, in principle, be resolved by introducing additional “hidden” variables that complete the description and eliminate the indeterminacy. Still, the device-independent violation of

Read the complete text