Two times or none?
Michael Ridley, Eliahu Cohen · 2025
Read Two times or none? by Michael Ridley, Eliahu Cohen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-22264.txt.
Introduction
Michael Ridley and Eliahu Cohen review two rival ways of treating time in quantum mechanics. Most quantum theory gives time a special role: it is a background parameter, not a quantity the theory measures. One family of approaches, called timeless, removes the background clock and recovers time from correlations inside the system, in the style of Page and Wootters. Their 2025 paper weighs that family against a less studied alternative due to Bauer.
Bauer's two-time approach enlarges the state space with an extra degree of freedom, pictured as a pseudospin, which effectively adds a backward-running time direction. That addition allows a genuine time operator to be defined. It also links up with other time-symmetric formulations of quantum mechanics. They close by sketching a framework in which the timeless philosophy and two-time mechanics can be combined.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael Ridley, Eliahu Cohen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 97 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-22264
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Two times or none? Michael Ridley, Eliahu Cohen Abstract Attempts to treat time on an equivalent footing with space in quantum mechanics have been apparently dominated by ‘timeless’ approaches, such as the one of Page and Wootters, which allow meaningful discussion of a ‘time operator’. However, there is an alternative, and significantly less studied approach, due to Bauer, which makes use of the ‘pseudospin’ extension of the state space, effectively adding a backwards-time degree of freedom. This two-time approach allows definition of a ‘time operator’ and moreover bears interesting relations with other time-symmetric formulations of quantum mechanics. We review and compare these approaches to quantum time, emphasizing that there is a subtle choice between the timeless framework and the two-time approach. Finally, we sketch a framework in which the timeless philosophy can be combined with two-time quantum mechanics. I Introduction In the standard approach to quantum mechanics, time is not a dynamical variable. Rather, it is treated as a Newtonian ‘background’ parameter of the theory. In contrast with the dynamical treatment of spatial coordinates, no Hermitian operator is assigned to time. Indeed, introducing an ideal time operator canonically conjugate to the Hamiltonian would render the latter unbounded from below. This objection to the existence of a time operator is attributed to Pauli Pauli 1933 , and was later strengthened by Unruh and Wald Unruh and Wald 1989 . This way of viewing time as a background parameter stands in stark contrast with the picture of relativistic spacetime theories, in which time is treated as one of the dimensions in a unified spacetime geometry Horwitz et al. 1988 . The geometric concept of time includes all moments, or spacetime events, in all relativistic reference frames, within a 4-dimensional block-universe picture Reichenbach 2012 ; Vaccaro 2018 ; Silberstein et al. 2018 . The block universe view is usually married with an eternalist theory of time, in which past, present and future are taken to be equally real Isham and Linden 1995 . This tension between the two pictures of time has been allowed to remain in place, at the foundations of the two most successful theories in physics – general relativity and quantum mechanics. This is the so-called ‘problem of time’ Anderson 2012 ; Altaie et al. 2022 . Recent work suggests that, rather than building a general-relativistic theory of quantum mechanics in the usual language of quantum systems, efforts should be refocused on a quantum theory which retains the event-based ontology of general relativity Gambini and Pullin 2018 ; Maccone 2019 . In one theory resulting from this program – geometric event-based (GEB) quantum mechanics – spacetime operators are introduced which are conjugate to the 4-momentum, thereby describing space and time with formal similarity Giovannetti et al. 2023 . Another approach is provided by Vaccaro, who shows that time-symmetry violation leads to the picture of states as localized in space but spread out over all times, and therefore that the asymmetry between spatial and temporal coordinates underlying the problem of time might not be fundamental Vaccaro 2016 . In the non-relativistic case, time operators were introduced which make use of an external ‘clock’ system Maccone and Sacha 2020 , an idea which goes back to Page and Wooters (henceforth the PW approach) Page and Wootters 1983 . This is the so-called ‘timeless’ framework, as it starts from consideration of a closed universe, illustrated schematically in Fig. 1 , whose wavefunction cannot evolve in time in the usual way due to a Hamiltonian constraint. As such, it is currently an actively studied pathway Marletto and Vedral 2017 ; Foti et al. 2021 ; Baumann et al. 2022 ; Adlam 2022a ; Rijavec 2023 ; Stoica 2024 ; Kuypers and Rijavec 2024 for introducing a quantum theory of time. Some have raised questions regarding the validity of the decomposition into subsystems that is used by the PW approach Höhn et al. 2021a , as well as the correct interpretation of quantum mechanics which accompanies it Adlam 2022a . Moreover, Kuchař in Ref. Kuchař 2011 made a number of criticisms of the PW approach to quantum gravity. These centered around the probabilities derived from the PW formalism, which appear to violate the constraint equations, and to give inconsistent results for multiple time measurements. Efforts to overcome these criticisms have invoked the ‘evolving constants’ approach Rovelli 1991 parametrized such that correct propagators arise Gambini et al. 2009 or carefully formalized von Neumann measurements Giovannetti et al. 2015 , and are still ongoing Höhn et al. 2021b ; Hausmann et al. 2025 . An alternative, but much less-studied approach due to Bauer Bauer 1983 ; Bauer 2014 ; Bauer 2017 , suggests to enlarge the state space to include both forwards- and backwards-time processes, leading to a Hermitian time operator which is conjugate to the Hamiltonian. The inclusion of a past-oriented temporal degree of freedom either (i) explicitly, in the mathematical structure of the theory, or (ii) implicitly, in the interpretation of the theory, has a long history in quantum mechanics. There have been several explicitly retrocausal formulations of quantum mechanics which carry out (i), such as the two-state vector formalism (TSVF) Aharonov et al. 1964 ; Aharonov and Vaidman 2008 and its multiple-time extensions Aharonov et al. 2009 ; Aharonov et al. 2014a , or (ii), which include the transactional interpretation (TI) Cramer 1980 ; Cramer 1986 ; Cramer 1988 and its variants Kastner 2012 ; Kastner 2013 ; Kastner 2016 ; Kastner 2017 . Other explicitly retrocausal quantum theories can be found in Refs. Watanabe 1955 ; Davies 1970 ; Davies 1971 ; Davies 1972 ; Davidon 1976 ; Sutherland 1983 ; Reznik and Aharonov 1995 ; Wharton 2007 ; Pegg 2008 ; Price 2008 ; Sutherland 2008 ; Argaman 2010 ; Heaney 2013 ; Evans 2015 ; Price and Wharton 2015 ; Castagnoli 2016 ; Sutherland 2017 ; Wharton 2018 ; Bopp 2019 ; Sen 2019 ; Sen 2020 ; Cohen et al. 2020a ; Cohen et al. 2020b ; Bopp 2020 ; Drummond 2021 ; Ridley 2023 ; Wharton et al. 2024 ; Telali et al. 2025 ; Ho 2025 . In addition, recent work suggests that, even at the macroscopic level, two emergent opposing arrows of time can be derived from the underlying quantum dynamics (modelled as a Markovian open quantum system) Guff et al. 2025 . This is closely related to another work which models superpositions of thermodynamic arrows of time Rubino et al. 2021 or distinct causal orderings Oreshkov et al. 2012a ; Chiribella and Liu 2022a ; Cao et al. 2022 ; Mothe et al. 2024 using the process matrix formalism. Such superpositions were experimentally realized and studied in Refs. Guo et al. 2024 ; Rozema et al. 2024 ; Strömberg et al. 2024 . Some of these approaches, like the TI inherently rely on emission/absorption corresponding to retarded/advanced solutions of relativistic equations of motion, while others like the TSVF perfectly align with non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Finally, we note that within many-body quantum field theories, another time symmetric approach has been developed, which makes use of a doubled time axis, known as the Keldysh contour Keldysh 1964 ; Stefanucci and Van Leeuwen 2025 , for the propagation of