latin quandles of size 16 ​ p 16p

Marco Bonatto and Filippo Spaggiari · 2025

Read latin quandles of size 16 ​ p 16p by Marco Bonatto and Filippo Spaggiari (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-22145.txt.

Introduction

Marco Bonatto and Filippo Spaggiari classify Latin quandles in this 2025 paper. A quandle is a set with an operation that mimics the moves of knot theory. A Latin quandle is one whose operation table is a Latin square. Each element appears once in every row and column. The authors settle the classification for quandles whose size is sixteen times an odd prime.

Their result is that such quandles are almost always built from smaller pieces, in the sense called subdirectly reducible. When the prime leaves remainder one on division by three, exactly two exceptional quandles of this size appear for each such prime, reducible but not directly decomposable. For the two smallest primes, three and five, a single subdirectly irreducible example exists. The quandles turn out to be affine for most primes. The authors give explicit constructions of every case as coset quandles.

Catalog record

CREATORMarco Bonatto and Filippo Spaggiari
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE84 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-22145

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

latin quandles of size 16 ​ p 16p Marco Bonatto and Filippo Spaggiari Abstract . In this paper we obtain the classification of latin quandles of size 16 ​ p 16p where p p is an odd prime. In particular we have that such quandles are always subdirectly reducible but in some cases for small primes. Specifically, we have that latin quandles of size 16 ​ p 16p are affine if p ≠ 1 ( mod 3 ) p\neq 1\pmod{3} or p ≠ 3 , 5 p\neq 3,5 . If p = 1 ( mod 3 ) p=1\pmod{3} there are 2 2 subdirectly reducible non directly decomposable latin quandles of size 16 ​ p 16p for every prime with p = 1 ( mod 3 ) p=1\pmod{3} and there are one subdirectly irreducible latin quandle of size 16 ​ p 16p for p = 3 , 5 p=3,5 . We provide explicit constructions as coset quandles for all the quandles mentioned above. Introduction Quandles are binary algebras introduced in the framework of knot theory to construct knot invariants [ Joy82 , Mat82 ] . Beyond their origins, they have proven to be deeply connected to various other mathematical structures, such as solutions to the set-theoretical quantum Yang-Baxter equation [ ESG01a , ESS99a ] and pointed Hopf algebras [ AG03 ] . These connections underline the importance of quandles as versatile and foundational objects in both algebra and topology. Quandles have been extensively studied through both group and module theory. In addition, universal algebra offers an important framework for investigating the complex relationship between properties of the congruence lattice and those of the so-called displacement group, which encodes many properties of the quandle itself. Indeed, there are two Galois connections between the congruence lattice of a quandle and the lattice of normal subgroups of the left multiplication group contained in the displacement group. This rich interplay between the two lattices has proven crucial in addressing classification problems for finite quandles, facilitating a deeper understanding of their structure and properties. Moreover, it has also been fundamental in developing commutator theory for quandles. Commutator theory, initially developed for general algebraic structures in [ FM87 ] , has been specialized for quandles in [ BS21 ] . In this paper, we use this set of tools to obtain the classification of latin quandles of size 16p , where p is a prime, taking advantage of the classification of latin quandles of size 4,16,p , and 4p already available [ ESS99b , Bon22a , RIG ] , as well as the homogeneous representation of connected quandles over the displacement group [ Joy82 ] . Using this machinery, we can translate the classification problem into a purely group-theoretical one. Universal algebraic techniques are primarily used to identify the groups of interest for obtaining a homogeneous representation, assuming that the congruence lattice of the structure is known. The core of the paper lies in Section 3 , where we also collect existing results on the classification of small latin quandles and prove the main classification results for latin quandles of size 16p (completed in Section 3.5 with some computational results concerning the cases p=3,5 ). This classification, achieved through a detailed case analysis, demonstrates the power of the aforementioned techniques. Specifically, the classification strategy proceeds as follows: (i) Determine the structure of the congruence lattice; (ii) Use the Galois correspondence between the congruence lattice and the lattice of normal subgroups of the left multiplication group to identify the displacement group; (iii) Establish whether the groups satisfying the required properties exist and, if they do, whether their automorphisms give rise to coset quandles with the desired properties (in this case, being latin of size 16p ). In the paper, we take advantage of the fact that finite latin quandles are solvable (in the sense of [ FM87 ] ) and so the description of finite simple latin quandles is completely understood. In particular, such quandles are affine over elementary abelian p -groups. The algorithm for classification is used to investigate directly indecomposable quandles. On the other hand, directly decomposable latin quandles of size 16p are known since the quandles of size 4,16,p and 4p are classified. If p\neq 1\pmod{3} the directly decomposable latin quandles of size 16p are affine, as they are the direct product of the 9 latin quandles of size 16 and one of the p-2 latin quandles of size p and such quandles are affine. If p=1\pmod{3} we also have the direct product of the unique latin quandle of size 4 and one of the two non-affine latin quandles of size 4p described in [ Bon22a ] . Combining the computational results from Section 3.5 , Proposition 3.8 , and Theorem 3.9 (in which we also provide an explicit coset representation for the quandles obtained) with the enumeration mentioned above, we achieve our main classification results, summarized in Table ( 1 ). p Subdirectly irreducible Directly decomposable (DD) Subdirectly reducible (not DD) p=1\pmod{3} 0 9(p-2)+2 2 p\neq 1\pmod{3},\,p\neq 3,5 0 9(p-2) 0 3 1 9 0 5 1 27 0 Table 1. Enumeration of latin quandles of size 16p . In detail, the structure of the paper is as follows. Section 1 collects foundational concepts from group theory and universal algebra. These preliminaries establish the necessary background for subsequent sections and include results concerning the congruence lattice of specific structures. For additional information on universal algebra, the reader may refer to [ Ber11 ] , which provides an accessible introduction to the subject. Section 2 introduces essential notations and concepts from quandle theory, including related groups of automorphisms. This section also presents key theorems addressing isomorphism problems and connections between the normal subgroups of the displacement group and the congruences of the quandle, laying the groundwork for the main results of the paper. Section 3 contains all the classification results, including the computational ones. Finally, Section 4 presents the purely group-theoretical results used throughout the paper. 1. Preliminary results 1.1. Group Theory We denote by \mathrm{Sym}_{Q} the symmetric group over a non-empty set Q . An action of a group G on a set Q is a group homomorphism \rho:G\longrightarrow\mathrm{Sym}_{Q},\quad g\mapsto\rho_{g}. We say that an action is faithful if the map \rho is injective, i.e. \mathrm{ker}(\rho)=1 . For x\in Q , we denote by G_{x}=\{g\in G\,\colon\,\rho_{g}(x)=x\} the stabilizer of x in G , and by x^{G}=\{\rho_{g}(x)\,\colon\ g\in G\} the orbit of x with respect to the action of G . We denote by \mathrm{Aut}(G) the group of automorphisms of a group G . The inner automorphism with respect to g\in G is the automorphism \widehat{g} defined by setting \widehat{g}(x)=gxg^{-1},\quad\text{for every }x\in G. If h\in\mathrm{Aut}(G) and N is a h -invariant normal subgroup of G (i.e. h(N)=N ) then h induces an automorphism on the factor G/N . Lemma 1.1 . Let N be a normal subgroup of a group G , and let f\in\mathrm{Aut}(G) be such that f(N)=N . Then the map f_{N}:G/N\longrightarrow G/N,\quad xN\mapsto f(x)N is a well defined automorphism of G/N . Proof. The map xN\mapsto f(x)N is well defined. In fact, if x^{-1}y\in N then f(x^{-1}y)=f(x)^{-1}f(y)\in N . Clearly f is onto. Moreover \displaystyle f_{N}((xN)^{-1}yN) \displaystyle=f_{N}(x^{-1}yN)=f(x^{-1}y)N=f(x^{-1})f(y)N \displaystyle=f(x)^{-1}Nf(y)N=f_{N}(xN)^{-1}f_{N}(yN). Therefore f_{N}\in\mathrm{End}(G/N) . If f_{N}(xN)=f(x)N=N

Read the complete text