PhishLumos: An Adaptive Multi-Agent System for Proactive Phishing Campaign Mitigation
Daiki Chiba, Hiroki Nakano, and Takashi Koide · 2025
Read PhishLumos: An Adaptive Multi-Agent System for Proactive Phishing Campaign Mitigation by Daiki Chiba, Hiroki Nakano, and Takashi Koide (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-21772.txt.
Introduction
Daiki Chiba, Hiroki Nakano, and Takashi Koide write about phishing, the fake messages and sites that steal people's data. Defenses today mostly react after an attack is already running. Modern attackers also cloak their sites, hiding the harmful content from scanners. This paper offers a system that hunts whole attack campaigns instead of single bad links.
PhishLumos treats cloaking itself as a clue worth chasing. Its language-model agents dig into the shared hosting, certificates, and domain records behind suspicious sites. On real-world data, the system found every campaign in the typical case. It did so over a week before human experts confirmed them. That shifts defense from blocking links one by one to stopping campaigns early, before users get hurt.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daiki Chiba, Hiroki Nakano, and Takashi Koide |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-21772
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
PhishLumos: An Adaptive Multi-Agent System for Proactive Phishing Campaign Mitigation Daiki Chiba, Hiroki Nakano, and Takashi Koide Abstract Phishing attacks are a significant societal threat, disproportionately harming vulnerable populations and eroding trust in essential digital services. Current defenses are often reactive, failing against modern evasive tactics like cloaking that conceal malicious content. To address this, we introduce PhishLumos, an adaptive multi-agent system that proactively mitigates entire attack campaigns. It confronts a core cybersecurity imbalance: attackers can easily scale operations, while defense remains an intensive expert task. Instead of being blocked by evasion, PhishLumos treats it as a critical signal to investigate the underlying infrastructure. Its Large Language Model (LLM)-powered agents uncover shared hosting, certificates, and domain registration patterns. On real-world data, our system identified 100% of campaigns in the median case, over a week before their confirmation by cybersecurity experts. PhishLumos demonstrates a practical shift from reactive URL blocking to proactive campaign mitigation, protecting users before they are harmed and making the digital world safer for all. I Introduction Phishing attacks, which use social engineering to steal confidential data, represent a persistent and adaptable security threat. The impact is substantial: total losses from cybercrime in the U.S. exceeded $12.5 billion in 2023 alone. Within this landscape, phishing stands out as the most frequently reported type of crime, highlighting its central role as a societal threat [ 1 ] . These attacks deepen the digital divide by disproportionately harming vulnerable populations, including older adults and those with less technical expertise [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] . Critically, this erosion of trust in essential digital services—from banking to healthcare—threatens not just economic stability but also digital equity in our increasingly online society. Defensive strategies have long relied on tools like blocklists, which are typically populated based on data from automated security scanners. However, today’s attackers employ sophisticated evasive tactics, such as cloaking (delivering different content to scanners versus users), which makes these established methods less effective. This situation demands more advanced, proactive, and resilient solutions to counter these modern threats. The limitations of standard detection are particularly clear with content-based techniques, which become ineffective when webpages offer little inspectable data. Attackers exploit this weakness through evasive strategies that minimize analyzable content, from hiding pages behind CAPTCHAs to returning benign 404 errors to scanners [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . The widespread availability of phishing kits intensifies this struggle, ensuring defenses remain reactive. This dependency on content is a core issue that persists even with modern approaches. The application of powerful Large Language Models (LLMs) to phishing detection, for example, often presumes the availability of rich content for analysis [ 9 ] . Consequently, their performance degrades in content-inaccessible scenarios. When faced with a cloaked page, an LLM cannot function as intended because there is no meaningful content from which to reason about the page’s purpose or identify targeted brands. This reveals a critical need for new methods that can uncover entire malicious campaigns from incomplete or deliberately obscured data. Fig. 1: The core concept of PhishLumos. While conventional security scanners fail when faced with cloaking, PhishLumos treats such evasion as a key signal to pivot its investigation toward peripheral infrastructure footprints, allowing it to uncover the entire malicious campaign. We introduce PhishLumos, a multi-agent system that confronts a core cybersecurity asymmetry: easy attack scaling versus resource-heavy defense. Attackers often deploy coordinated campaigns—launching numerous similar phishing sites simultaneously to maximize impact. PhishLumos automates the expert-level investigation of these entire campaigns from a single URL. As shown in Figure 1 , our system treats evasion not as an obstacle but as a key signal to investigate the attacker’s infrastructure. This pivot allows it to uncover campaigns from minimal clues using LLM-powered agents that verify threats, characterize campaigns, and generate validated detection rules. Our contribution is providing actionable intelligence for campaign mitigation. This work represents a shift towards proactive defense, aiming to protect vulnerable users by mitigating campaigns before they cause significant harm. II Related Work Detecting advanced phishing campaigns remains a significant challenge, especially when attackers use evasive tactics that limit available data. Previous research has explored several methods, including content-based analysis, countermeasures for cloaking, and the use of LLMs. However, these approaches generally assume that enough webpage content is available for analysis. They also typically focus on identifying individual malicious URLs. They do not specialize in uncovering entire campaigns or creating detection rules from limited initial clues. PhishLumos addresses this specific gap. This section reviews prior work and explains how PhishLumos provides adaptive, campaign-level detection, which is effective even when starting with minimal information. Content-Based Phishing Detection. Content-based detection is a common defense against phishing, but it becomes less effective when content is hidden or minimal. PhishLumos is designed specifically for this scenario. Methods like VisualPhishNet [ 10 ] (visual similarity), Phishpedia [ 11 ] (logo detection), and PhishIntention [ 12 ] (intent identification) are powerful. However, their success depends on having rich and analyzable webpage data. Consequently, they struggle in content-inaccessible environments featuring cloaking or minimal content. PhishLumos is specifically designed to work effectively in these scenarios. It uses peripheral infrastructure data to uncover entire campaigns, a capability that goes beyond direct content inspection. Evasion Techniques and Countermeasures. Prior research has thoroughly documented evasion techniques and the efforts to counter them. Early work by Invernizzi et al. explored web cloaking [ 13 ] , and CrawlPhish detailed client-side evasions [ 6 ] . Studies like PhishFarm [ 7 ] and PhishTime [ 14 ] confirmed that cloaking is effective. Countermeasures include PhishDecloaker [ 5 ] for bypassing CAPTCHAs, PhishPrint [ 8 ] for analyzing how scanners are exploited, and even offensive systems like Spartacus [ 15 ] . While these approaches focus on bypassing or understanding evasion, PhishLumos uniquely uses the inability to access content as the primary signal to initiate its infrastructure investigation. This signal becomes the starting point for generating campaign-level detection rules. Multimodal Approaches and LLM Utilization. The use of LLMs and multimodal data has led to powerful new methods for phishing detection. However, most of these systems still rely on having accessible webpage information. For instance, KnowPhish [ 16 ] employs LLMs to improve detection based on reference pages. PhishLLM [ 9 ] and ChatPhishDetector [ 17 ] use the reasoning capabilities of LLMs to analyze crawled web data, such as HTML, text, and screenshots, to find malicious intent. Other systems, like ScamNet [ 18 ] and PhishAgent [ 19 ] , use specialized LLMs for fraud detection. The primary difference from these approaches, which excel with rich content, is that PhishLumos is optimized for content-inaccessible scenarios. Instead of simply analyzing given content, its LLM agents are designed to initiate and direct an investigation using minimal data. PhishLumos uses LLMs to dynamically search external data sources, connect separate clues to build a campaign profile, and create practical detection rules. This focus on adaptive, LLM-driven investigation from scarce information sets it apart from previous work. III Proposed System TABLE I: PhishLumos agent roles and responsibilities. Agent Primary Goal Key Inputs & Outputs Supervisor Orchestrate overall analysis flow. Input: URL. Output: Final Report. Specialized Agents URL Analysis Get historical scan data for a URL.