Harnessing optical disorder for Bell inequalities violation
Baptiste Courme, Malo Joly, Adrian Makowski, Sylvain Gigan, Hugo Defienne · 2025
Read Harnessing optical disorder for Bell inequalities violation by Baptiste Courme, Malo Joly, Adrian Makowski, Sylvain Gigan, Hugo Defienne (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-21052.txt.
Introduction
Entanglement tests usually demand pristine optics, and any scrambling in the light path ruins them. Baptiste Courme and four co-authors turn that scrambling into the tool itself in a 2025 quantum optics paper. They violate a Bell inequality by harnessing optical disorder.
One photon of an entangled pair travels through a commercial multimode fiber that mixes its spatial and polarization modes, emerging as a speckle pattern. The other photon stays with the sender. By resolving the speckle pattern spatially, the team extracts measurement settings from the disorder itself. The Bell test then certifies entanglement despite, indeed through, the scrambling. The result suggests quantum certification can survive in messy real-world channels, and even exploit them.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Baptiste Courme, Malo Joly, Adrian Makowski, Sylvain Gigan, Hugo Defienne |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-21052
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Harnessing optical disorder for Bell inequalities violation Preprint: APS/123-QED Baptiste Courme, Malo Joly, Adrian Makowski, Sylvain Gigan, Hugo Defienne Abstract Bell inequalities are a cornerstone of quantum physics. By carefully selecting measurement bases (typically polarization), their violation certifies quantum entanglement. Such measurements are disrupted by the presence of optical disorder in propagation paths, including polarization or spatial mode mixing in fibers and through free-space turbulence. Here, we demonstrate that disorder can instead be exploited as a resource to certify entanglement via a Bell inequality test. In our experiment, one photon of a polarization-entangled pair propagates through a commercial multimode fiber that scrambles spatial and polarization modes, producing a speckle pattern, while the other photon remains with the sender. By spatially resolving the speckle intensity pattern, we naturally access a large set of random and unknown polarization projections. We show that this set is statistically sufficient to violate a Bell inequality, thereby certifying entanglement without requiring active correction techniques. Our approach provides a fundamentally new way to test Bell inequalities, eliminating the need for an explicit choice of measurement basis, and offering a practical solution for entanglement certification in real-world quantum communication channels where disorder is unavoidable. I Introduction From the fundamental demonstrations of non-locality Einstein et al. 1935 ; Aspect et al. 1982 to practical applications in imaging Defienne et al. 2024 , computation Jozsa and Linden 2003 , and communication Gisin and Thew 2007 , quantum entanglement lies at the heart of modern quantum technologies. A major challenge across all these applications is preserving the fragile quantum correlations that underpin entanglement during transmission through a real-world channel. In particular, the presence of heterogeneous structures along the photon’s propagation paths, such as atmospheric turbulence, scattering, or mode mixing in optical fibers, can severely degrade performance or even prevent the proper functioning of these systems. This limitation is present for example in current quantum key distribution (QKD) systems involving satellite-to-earth links Yin et al. 2017 ; Liao et al. 2017 or those relying on fiber-optic networks Inagaki et al. 2013 ; Wengerowsky et al. 2019 ; Neumann et al. 2022 . Figure 1: Experimental setup. a. Source: A collimated continuous-wavelength (CW) laser at 405 nm pumps a 1cm-long type-II periodically-poled crystal potassium titanyl phosphate (ppKTP) crystal. After the crystal, residual pump light is blocked with a low-pass filter (LPF), and the SPDC photons are spectrally selected using a 810\pm 1 nm band-pass filter (BPF). Photons are rendered indistinguishable by adjusting the path delay \delta and are spatially filtered using a polarization-maintaining single-mode fiber (PMSMF). Using half-wave plates (HWPs), the photon polarizations in each spatial path are set orthogonal to each other before being recombined at a beam splitter (BS) to create a polarization-entangled state. This arrangement is called a Shih-Alley configuration Shih and Alley 1988 . The output modes of the source are labeled a and b . Alice: On Alice’s side, photons pass through a quarter-wave plate (QWP) and a HWP before being coupled into a PMSMF connected to a fiber-based polarization beam splitter (FPBS). The two FPBS outputs are directed to avalanche photodiodes (APDs) labeled A^{(1)} and A^{(2)} . Bob: On Bob’s side, photons are first injected into a 50 cm long graded-index multimode fiber (MMF) with a 50\,\mu\text{m} core diameter. At the output, photons are collected either with an electron-multiplied charge-coupled device (EMCCD) camera or with a PMSMF mounted on an XY translation stage. The fiber and the camera are positioned in planes conjugate to the fiber output facet. A calcite beam displacer (BD) produces two intensity images, one for each polarization, on the camera. The PMSMF is connected to a FPBS, whose outputs are coupled to two APDs labeled B^{(1)} and B^{(2)} . b. Intensity images for both polarization at the output of the MMF recorded with the EMCCD camera. All lenses f_{1} – f_{12} are used either for coupling light into fibers or in telescope configurations: f_{1}=50 mm; f_{2}=10 mm; f_{3}=10 mm; f_{4}=25 mm; f_{5}=25 mm; f_{6}=25 mm; f_{7}=150 mm; f_{8}=150 mm; f_{9}=5 mm; f_{10}=10 mm; f_{11}=25 mm; f_{12}=400 mm. To mitigate these effects, numerous active correction techniques have been developed. For instance, adaptive optics approaches have been implemented to compensate for turbulence in real time, thereby extending the distance over which quantum-secure communication is possible Gruneisen et al. 2021 ; Scarfe et al. 2025 ; Pugh et al. 2020 ; Liu et al. 2019 . Similarly, wavefront shaping techniques have enabled the distribution of entangled photons through multimode fibers Valencia et al. 2020 ; Valencia et al. 2025 and scattering layers Defienne et al. 2018 ; Lib et al. 2020 ; Courme et al. 2023a ; Courme et al. 2025 ; Shekel et al. 2024 . However, these active methods allow only partial correction of the disorder, being limited both by the complexity of the medium and its temporal dynamics, which makes them difficult to use in real-world applications. Interestingly, since light scattering in most practical scenarios can be considered a linear process, the action of disorder is a unitary operation and can therefore be interpreted as an optical change of basis Kim et al. 2015 . Even in the presence of losses, the random mode mixing process induced by optical disorder can be exploited for many applications, including speckle-based interferometers Chakrabarti et al. 2015 , optical simulators Rafayelyan et al. 2020 ; Wetzstein et al. 2020 , and the implementation of reconfigurable linear quantum circuits Defienne et al. 2016 ; Wolterink et al. 2016 ; Leedumrongwatthanakun et al. 2020 ; Makowski et al. 2024 ; Goel et al. 2024 ; Joly et al. 2025 . Here, we harness the optical disorder induced by a commercial multimode optical fiber to certify entanglement without the need for active correction methods. One photon from a polarization-entangled pair is sent through the fiber, which forms a speckle on the other side, i.e. it redistributes its intensity and polarization across more than 400 spatial and polarization modes, each corresponding to a random rotation on the Poincaré sphere. By detecting coincidences between the fiber’s spatial output modes and the polarization of the photon retained by the sender, we demonstrate on a significant fraction of the modes a violation of a Bell inequality, thereby certifying entanglement in the two-photon state. In our experiment, the fiber thus serves both as the propagation channel for transmitting entanglement and as a passive tool for its certification. II Experiment The experimental setup is illustrated in Figure 1 . A polarization-entangled two-photon state with wavelength 810\pm 1\,\text{nm} is generated using a Shih-Alley configuration Shih and Alley 1988 (red-shaded area). When the optical delay \delta\approx 0 , the state post-selected by a coincidence measurement between the detectors positioned in spatial modes a and b can be written as \ket{\Psi}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[a^{\dagger}_{aH}a^{\dagger}_{bV}-a^{\dagger}_{aV}a^{\dagger}_{bH}\right]\ket{0}, (1) where a^{\dagger}_{mp} is the creation operator for a photon in spatial mode m\in\{a,b\} with polarization p\in\{H,V\} (see Methods for more details). The output modes a and b are connected to Alice’s arm (blue-shaded area) and Bob’s arm (yellow-shaded area), respectively. On Alice’s arm, the photon propagates through polarization-control optics consisting of a quarter-wave plate (QWP) and a half-wave plate (HWP) before being injected into a polarization-maintaining single-mode fiber (PMSMF). The fiber is connected to a fiber-based polarization