Baryons as linked vortices in QCD matter with isospin asymmetry

Yu Hamada, Muneto Nitta, and Zebin Qiu · 2025

Read Baryons as linked vortices in QCD matter with isospin asymmetry by Yu Hamada, Muneto Nitta, and Zebin Qiu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-20844.txt.

Introduction

Inside dense quark matter, protons and neutrons may dissolve into swirling patterned structures. Yu Hamada, Muneto Nitta, and Zebin Qiu study one such structure in a 2025 theoretical physics paper. They consider QCD matter with an imbalance between isospin types, plus baryon and electric effects.

Using chiral perturbation theory, the authors examine vortices formed by pion fields. With a pion mass included, charged and neutral pions alike form condensates throughout the bulk. Two vortex kinds then appear: a local vortex of charged pions and a global vortex of neutral pions. The baryon appears as a linked structure of these vortices. The work offers a model-independent view of how baryons might be built inside extreme matter.

Catalog record

CREATORYu Hamada, Muneto Nitta, and Zebin Qiu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-20844

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Baryons as linked vortices in QCD matter with isospin asymmetry Preprint: DESY-25-129 Yu Hamada, Muneto Nitta, and Zebin Qiu Abstract We investigate a baryonic structure in low-energy QCD via a model-independent way using the chiral perturbation theory at the leading order, in the presence of the baryon chemical potential μ B \mu_{B} , the isospin chemical potential μ I \mu_{I} , and the electromagnetic coupling. For such a scenario in the chiral limit, it has been known that the neutral pion winds like in the chiral soliton lattice, confined within an Abrikosov-Nielsen-Olesen (ANO) vortex of the charged pions. This structure undergoes a drastic transformation when the pion mass is introduced, i.e., both charged and neutral pions condense in the bulk, allowing two distinct types of vortices: the charged pions constitute a local ANO-like vortex, while the neutral pion configures a global vortex which is further attached to a domain wall also known as the chiral soliton. Remarkably, the ANO vortex forms a topological linking with the closed global vortex line, when μ B \mu_{B} exceeds its critical value as a function of μ I \mu_{I} . The linking number has the physical meaning of the baryon number in view of the Wess-Zumino-Witten term. In this sense, the linked configuration realizes a stable Skyrmion-type solution, but innovatively without the Skyrme term. We therefore propose a novel phase of dense baryonic matter comprised of such vortices, which shall play a role in the low-energy QCD phase diagram. 1 Introduction The phase structure of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) at finite density remains a central but unresolved issue in nuclear physics Eichmann:2016yit ; Schmidt:2017bjt ; Fischer:2018sdj ; Rothkopf:2019ipj ; Guenther:2020jwe ; Braguta:2023yhd ; Adam:2023cee , largely due to the challenge of dealing with strongly correlated systems and the sign problem in Lattice QCD (LQCD). At low energies, effective field theories Holt:2014hma ; Hammer:2019poc ; Drischler:2021kxf such as chiral perturbation theory (ChPT) Gasser:1983yg ; Scherer:2002tk provide useful tools. ChPT is constructed in terms of pions as Nambu–Goldstone bosons based on the chiral symmetry breaking. Topological aspects of ChPT are incorporated in the conserved Goldstone–Wilczek (GW) current Goldstone:1981kk , which couples the baryon current to gauge fields via the Wess–Zumino–Witten (WZW) term Witten:1983tw . The density effects in the hadronic sector is captured by the baryon chemical potential \mu_{B} as the temporal component of a fictitious U(1)_{B} baryon gauge field, encoded in the WZW term. Another relevant gauge field is the electromagnetic U(1)_{\rm EM} gauge field. Especially, in the presence of a magnetic field, the QCD phase diagram exhibits richer structure Kharzeev:2015kna ; Miransky:2015ava ; Andersen:2014xxa ; Yamamoto:2021oys ; Cao:2021rwx ; Iwasaki:2021nrz . For example, the magnetic catalysis enhances quark condensates at zero temperature Klimenko:1990rh , while inverse magnetic catalysis occurs near the crossover temperature Bruckmann:2013oba ; Aoki:2006we . Moreover, there are novel phases induced by magnetic fields, such as the chiral magnetic spiral Basar:2010zd and dual density wave Nakano:2004cd . Regarding phenomenology, magnetic fields at considerable strength do exist in physical contexts like magnetars Duncan:1992hi ; Turolla:2015mwa ; Kaspi:2017fwg and the quark-gluon plasma Shuryak:1978ij ; Skokov:2009qp ; McLerran:2013hla . Also, the presence of a magnetic field may alleviate the sign problem in LQCD Fukuda:2013ada ; Brauner:2019rjg . Particularly concerned with the hadronic sector are the proposed \pi^{0} (neutral pion) domain wall Son:2007ny and its stacking outcome: the chiral soliton lattice (CSL) Eto:2012qd ; Brauner:2016pko . The conserved topological charge reduces the free energy via the WZW term and triggers a phase transition from vacuum to CSL when there is an external magnetic field exceeding the critical value B_{\text{CSL}}=16\pi m_{\pi}f_{\pi}^{2}/(e\mu_{B}) , with m_{\pi} the effective pion mass and f_{\pi} the pion decay constant. Each chiral soliton carries a baryon number as the conserved charge of the GW current Son:2007ny . These studies have inspired the thread that, under a strong magnetic field, the ground state of dense QCD matter may be pure pionic Brauner:2018mpn , contrary to the traditional baryonic picture. Analogous CSL phases composed of \eta^{\prime} mesons (or \eta mesons in the two-flavor case) Huang:2017pqe ; Nishimura:2020odq ; Chen:2021aiq , and their non-Abelian generalizations involving pion degrees of freedom Eto:2021gyy ; Eto:2023rzd , have also been proposed in rapidly rotating systems. Furthermore, when \eta mesons become physically relevant at high density in a magnetic field, two of the present authors have proposed a mixed soliton lattice comprised of both \pi^{0} and \eta mesons Qiu:2023guy , which features lower energy than their separated lattices, suggesting the novel possibility of a QCD quasicrystal. In order to clarify the stability of CSLs in the non-perturbative regime, CSL ground states have been investigated in QCD-like theories such as two-color ( N_{c}=2 ) QCD and vector-like gauge theories Brauner:2019rjg ; Brauner:2019aid , where the sign problem could be circumvented in lattice gauge theory at finite baryon density. Also of interest are the CSL counterparts in supersymmetric QCD Nitta:2024xcu and holographic QCD Amano:2025iwi . At high density and magnetic field, there appears an intriguing phase that consists of the hybrid baryonic structure, domain-wall Skyrmions Eto:2023lyo ; Eto:2023wul ; Amari:2024fbo ; Eto:2023tuu , which is characterized by \pi_{2}(S^{2})\simeq\mathbb{Z} and lodged on chiral solitons Nitta:2012wi ; Nitta:2012rq ; Gudnason:2014nba ; Gudnason:2014hsa . The domain-wall Skyrmion has baryon number two and hence a bosonic nature Amari:2024mip . At low magnetic field and high chemical potential, a Skyrmion crystal Klebanov:1985qi derived from the Skyrme model Skyrme:1961vq ; Zahed:1986qz readily describe dense baryonic matter in the large N_{c} limit. On top of ChPT, the Skyrme model incorporates an additional quartic term, namely the Skyrme term, for the stability of the Skyrmion solution, according to Derrick’s theorem Derrick:1964ww . In contrast to the domain-wall Skyrmions, a Skyrmion is a single baryon with the GW current charge representing the baryon number one Adkins:1983ya . Effects of magnetic fields have been incorporated in the Skyrme model innovatively in refs. Chen:2021vou ; Chen:2023jbq , indicating that the \pi^{0} CSL and related configurations occupy the region of lower density and higher magnetic field in the phase diagram. However, exactly how CSL, domain-wall Skyrmion, and Skyrmion crystal transit to each other is still an open question. Approaching this issue, a pancake structure of the baryon in a magnetic field has been conjectured Son:2007ny and under examination Amari:2025twm . In realistic physical contexts, the isospin chemical potential \mu_{I} often needs to be taken into account; for two-flavor ( N_{f}=2 ) QCD with u and d quarks, the isospin chemical potential is given by the difference between chemical potentials of u and d , i.e., \mu_{I}=(\mu_{u}-\mu_{d})/2 . Meanwhile the baryon chemical potential is defined as \mu_{B}=(\mu_{u}+\mu_{d})/2 . Finite \mu_{I,B} are pertinent in the early universe with lepton flavor asymmetry, in astrophysical objects such as neutron stars, and, of course, in heavy-ion collisions. It has long been known that the Bose–Einstein condensation of charged pions \pi^{\pm} occurs when \mu_{I}\geq m_{\pi} Ruck:1976zt ; Migdal:1978az . At higher \mu_{I} , a deconfined superconducting phase has been hypothesized Son:2000xc . Unlike \mu_{B} , finite \mu_{I} does not introduce a sign problem, enabling significant progress in LQCD studies Kogut:2002tm ; Kogut:2002zg ; Kogut:2004zg ; Brandt:2017oyy ; Brandt:2022hwy ; Abbott:2023coj . These developments have astrophysical implications, including pion stars Brandt:2018bwq ; Stashko:2023gnn ; Kirichenkov:2023omy and gravitational wave signals from pion condensates

Read the complete text