The First 4 Years of SN 1993J Revisited: Geometric m m -ring Modeling of the Radio Shell with Closure Quantities Only
Joseph R. Farah, Logan J. Prust, Giacomo Terreran, D. Andrew Howell, Michael Bietenholz, Norbert Bartel, Curtis McCully, Michael D. Johnson · 2025
Read The First 4 Years of SN 1993J Revisited: Geometric m m -ring Modeling of the Radio Shell with Closure Quantities Only by Joseph R. Farah, Logan J. Prust, Giacomo Terreran, D. Andrew Howell, Michael Bietenholz, Norbert Bartel, Curtis McCully, Michael D. Johnson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-20601.txt.
Introduction
The radio shell of supernova 1993J, the best-studied explosion of its kind, gets a fresh measurement by Joseph Farah and seven co-authors in a 2025 arXiv paper. Decades of interferometry tracked its expanding ejecta from weeks after the blast. Earlier analyses fit a physical spherical shell model to the data. This re-analysis uses a geometric ring model and closure quantities only, which sidesteps calibration errors.
The first seventeen hundred days were remodeled. Expansion followed the same power law that shell fitting had found, confirming the older result independently. For the first time, the shell's width was measured before day one thousand, as early as day two hundred sixty-four. The width held steady at about a quarter of the radius. Brightness around the ring rotated and then grew more complex, quantifying patterns earlier seen only in images.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joseph R. Farah, Logan J. Prust, Giacomo Terreran, D. Andrew Howell, Michael Bietenholz, Norbert Bartel, Curtis McCully, Michael D. Johnson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-20601
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The First 4 Years of SN 1993J Revisited: Geometric m m -ring Modeling of the Radio Shell with Closure Quantities Only Joseph R. Farah, Logan J. Prust, Giacomo Terreran, D. Andrew Howell, Michael Bietenholz, Norbert Bartel, Curtis McCully, Michael D. Johnson Abstract SN 1993J is the best-studied radio supernova, with observations using very-long-baseline interferometry (VLBI) spanning from within weeks of explosion through nearly three decades of ejecta evolution. Imaging and modeling techniques have revealed an expanding shell-like ejecta structure, with a width well-constrained after ∼ 1000 \sim 1000 days. In this work, we present a re-analysis of a portion of the first ∼ 1700 \sim 1700 days of SN 1993J evolution, using a new VLBI analysis technique with somewhat intrinsically higher angular resolution and compare our results with those from previous conventional techniques. We adopt the m m -ring model, with potentially somewhat higher angular resolution but only as a phenomenological alternative to the physically-motivated spherical shell model used in past analyses and shape the profile to approximately match that of the shell. The m m -ring model allows us to fit the ejecta diameter, width, central opacity, and azimuthal brightness modulation simultaneously. Additionally, we use closure quantities only, providing calibration insensitive constraints on ejecta geometry and largely independent comparisons with previous results from the same data sets. Using this approach we find the ejecta expanding with a power-law exponent ω = 0.80 ± 0.01 \omega=0.80\pm 0.01 averaged for the time from 175 to 1693 days, consistent with shell-fitting analyses. For the first time, we report estimates of the width of the ejecta at t ≲ 1000 t\lesssim 1000 days—as early as 264 days post-explosion—finding a mean fractional width with standard deviation of 0.24 ± 0.04 0.24\pm 0.04 (of the radius) with no significant evolution. Further, we present a fit of the azimuthal brightness modulation over time with the maximum of an apparent horseshoe pattern rotating from east to south-southwest from 175 to 1000 d and then evolving to a more complex behavior, quantifying previous results from images only. The constraints on the angular brightness modulation and width over time and ∼ 700 \sim 700 days earlier than existing analyses provide an avenue to test more advanced simulations of the explosion and interaction mechanisms. I Introduction Supernova (SN) 1993J was discovered in March 1993 in the spiral galaxy M81 ( Ripero et al. 1993 ) . As the prototypical Type IIb supernova ( Filippenko et al. 1993 ) , it was intensely studied across a variety of wavelengths, substantially facilitated by its proximity ( Freedman et al. 1994 ; 3.6 Mpc;) and peak brightness ( Weiler et al. 2007 ) . In particular, the radio-bright nature of the explosion led to a decade-long follow-up radio campaign using VLBI (see e.g., Marcaide et al. 2009 ; for a review) , which resolved an expanding asymmetric quasi-spherical shell ( Bartel et al. 1994 ; Marcaide et al. 1995 ; Bietenholz et al. 2001 ) . The direct observation of the radio shell expansion provides a unique opportunity to probe high-energy supernova physics at all initial phases of the explosion. Previous works have characterized the behavior of the expanding shell using a variety of approaches. Both modeling and imaging approaches have constrained the apparent size and width of the shell-like structure, and observed a decelerating power-law expansion ( Marcaide et al. 1997 ; Bartel 2000 ; Bartel et al. 2002 ) with a fractional shell width of \approx 30\% ( Marcaide et al. 1995 ; Bartel 2000 ; Bietenholz et al. 2005 ; Marcaide et al. 2009 ) . In particular, the shell width at early epochs ( \lesssim 1000 days) has not been well-characterized. Images at these early epochs are beam-convolved and cannot be used to measure a shell width, while width-enabled model-fits either fixed the width prior to day 900 ( Bartel et al. 2002 ) or did not fit width and size independently ( Marcaide et al. 2009 ) . The reported shell width is consistent with previous simulations and theoretical predictions (see e.g., Chevalier & Klein 1978 ; Kundu et al. 2019 ; etc.) . However, existing simulations of the SN 1993J explosion have been too simplistic (i.e., not including the impact of Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities or the complex interaction with the circumstellar medium, abbr. CSM) to present a robust prediction for the width of the emission region. Multiple imaging investigations have attempted to characterize the degree and evolution of asymmetry present in the azimuthal brightness along the ridge of the shell, which report a spherically symmetric object with an azimuthal brightness modulation ( Bartel et al. 1994 ; Marcaide et al. 1995 ; Bietenholz et al. 2001 ; Bietenholz et al. 2003 ) . In particular, Bietenholz et al. 2003 found a horseshoe-like brightness pattern in the images with the maximum rotating from east to south south-west over the first 1000 d before dissolving into a more complex structure. Concerns have been raised that the reported asymmetry and subsequent evolution may be artifacts caused by uneven and evolving (u,v) coverage ( Heywood et al. 2009 ) . Existing models ( Bartel 2000 ; e.g., a spherical shell of uniform emissivity;) have been symmetric; a major limitation of such models are that they cannot characterize any asymmetry in intensity or shape present in the data. Recently, the m -ring model of Johnson et al. 2019 has been developed which varies the size, width, and brightness asymmetry of a ring. The m -ring model (an infinitesimally thin ring blurred with a Gaussian kernel) looks phenomenologically similar to the SN 1993J images, but is not as physically motivated as the spherical shell model of supernovae ejecta. However, it has the benefit of incorporating azimuthal brightness variations of arbitrary complexity while retaining an analytic Fourier transform. Such functionality allows for a more extensive investigation of the impact of arbitrary azimuthal brightness modulations on estimates of size and width, as well as novel estimates (with uncertainties) of the ejecta brightness asymmetry independent of imaging. A major challenge in the study of SN 1993J has been assessing the impact of calibration choices and other systematics on imaging and model inference. Previous works have investigated the impacts of model assumptions ( Bartel et al. 2002 ) and data processing ( Marcaide et al. 2009 ) . The effect on inferred parameters and reconstructed images is significant, resulting in conflicting measurements from different analyses. Previous analyses have attempted to address this issue, reanalyzing the full dataset and attempting more careful self-calibration ( Martí-Vidal et al. 2024 ) . Recently, Chael et al. 2018 and others explored imaging with so-called “closure” quantities, derived quantities which by construction are invariant to phase errors, complex gains, and several other systematic artifacts. Directly modeling the SN 1993J evolution using these quantities may sidestep particular calibration and systematic error concerns entirely, although the amount of independent information would decrease and the total flux density information would be lost. In this paper, we re-analyze selected data sets of the first four years of the evolution of the SN 1993J radio shell, using a new geometric model capable of measuring asymmetry and basing our inference solely on calibration-insensitive closure quantities. In Section II ,