A Unified Formal Theory on the Logical Limits of Symbol Grounding
Zhangchi Liu · 2025
Read A Unified Formal Theory on the Logical Limits of Symbol Grounding by Zhangchi Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-20409.txt.
Introduction
Can a purely symbolic system ever connect its symbols to the real world? Zhangchi Liu tackles that symbol grounding problem in a 2025 arXiv paper of formal philosophy and logic. He separates two notions: internal sense, which axioms can supply, and external reference, which ties a symbol to the world. His unified theory argues that genuine grounding must come from outside any fixed algorithm.
The argument proceeds in four stages. First, ungroundability for a purely symbolic system follows from its definition. Second, adding any finite static set of meanings does not help. Third, Godel-style reasoning shows such systems cannot fully define their own groundability. Fourth, new meanings require a meta-level update, which Liu identifies with physical transduction, following Turing's oracle machines. The paper concludes that embodied interaction is a logical necessity, not an engineering choice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhangchi Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-20409
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Unified Formal Theory on the Logical Limits of Symbol Grounding Zhangchi Liu Abstract This paper synthesizes a series of formal proofs to construct a unified theory on the logical limits of the Symbol Grounding Problem. We demonstrate through a four-stage argument that meaning within a formal system must arise from a process that is external, dynamic, and non-algorithmic. First, we prove that any purely symbolic system, devoid of external connections, cannot internally establish a consistent foundation for meaning due to self-referential paradoxes. Second, we extend this limitation to systems with any finite, static set of pre-established meanings, proving they are inherently incomplete. Third, we demonstrate that the very "act" of connecting an internal symbol to an external meaning cannot be a product of logical inference within the system but must be an axiomatic, meta-level update. Finally, we prove that any attempt to automate this update process using a fixed, external "judgment" algorithm will inevitably construct a larger, yet equally incomplete, symbolic system. Together, these conclusions formally establish that the grounding of meaning is a necessarily open-ended, non-algorithmic process, revealing a fundamental, Gödel-style limitation for any self-contained intelligent system. Keywords: Symbol Grounding Problem, Formal Proof, Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorems, Self-Reference, Dynamic Semantics, Embodied Cognition, Metalogic, Limitations of Computationalism. 1 Introduction The Symbol Grounding Problem, famously articulated by Harnad [ 2 ] , questions how symbols within a formal system (like a dictionary or a computer program) can acquire intrinsic meaning, rather than being endlessly defined by other ungrounded symbols. This paper aims to provide a single, unified, and formally rigorous answer by demonstrating that the problem’s solution cannot lie within any closed formal system. We will prove that grounding is not a property or state that a system can achieve and finalize, a continuous, open-ended, and non-algorithmic process. Our argument unfolds in a logical progression over four main sections, synthesizing a series of core theorems. First, in Section 2, we establish the foundational formal framework and prove that a purely symbolic system —one with no external connections—is logically incapable of self-grounding. By constructing a self-referential sentence about "groundability," we show that any such system with sufficient expressive power falls into inconsistency or incompleteness, akin to Gödel’s and Tarski’s limitative theorems [ 1 , 6 ] . Second, in Section 3, we address the seemingly obvious solution: providing the system with an initial, finite set of grounded symbols derived from experience. We prove that any statically grounded system is also incomplete. A system can always formulate new, provable truths about its own limitations that cannot be grounded in its original, static experiential base. This establishes the necessity for grounding to be a dynamic process . Third, in Section 4, we investigate the nature of this dynamic process. What is the "grounding act" that expands the system’s connection to the world? We prove that this act is non-inferable . No internal, condition-triggered logical rule can deduce a command to ground a new symbol without risking a contradiction where the system’s inference invalidates its own proven theorems. This suggests the grounding act is an axiomatic, meta-level update, not a logical deduction. Finally, in Section 5, we confront the ultimate computationalist question: can this meta-level update process be simulated by a fixed, external, algorithmic "judgment system"? We prove that any such attempt is futile. The combination of the original system and the judgment system forms a larger, but still closed, "super-system" which is itself subject to the same incompleteness. This proves that the grounding process is fundamentally non-algorithmic . Together, these four proofs paint a complete picture: a system of meaning must, by logical necessity, be an infinitely open universe. Any attempt to draw a final boundary around it or to prescribe a fixed set of rules for its growth will fail, as it cannot account for the meaning of the boundary or the rules themselves. 2 The Formal Framework and the Impossibility of Self-Grounding We begin by defining a formal framework to precisely discuss symbols, definitions, and grounding. Definition 2.1 (Symbolic Language) . A symbolic language \mathcal{L} is a triple \langle S,D,G\rangle , where: • S is a non-empty, countable set of symbols. • D is a Definition Function , D:S\to\mathcal{P}(S) , which maps each symbol s\in S to its direct definitional set. • G is the Grounding Set , G\subseteq S . Symbols in G are postulated to be directly grounded, and for all g\in G , we require D(g)=\emptyset . Definition 2.2 (Definitional Closure) . For a symbol s\in S , its Definitional Closure C(s) is the smallest set satisfying: (1) s\in C(s) , and (2) if s^{\prime}\in C(s) and s^{\prime\prime}\in D(s^{\prime}) , then s^{\prime\prime}\in C(s) . C(s) contains all symbols used directly or indirectly to define s . Definition 2.3 (Groundability) . A symbol s\in S is groundable if and only if its definitional closure intersects with the grounding set: \text{isGroundable}(s)\iff C(s)\cap G\neq\emptyset . s s_{1} s_{2} s_{3} g\in G Fig 1: Definitional closure C(s)=\{s,s_{1},s_{2},s_{3},g\} . Since C(s)\cap G\neq\emptyset , s is groundable. A purely symbolic system would lack the node g . Our first investigation concerns a system that is entirely self-contained. Definition 2.4 (Purely Symbolic System) . A symbolic language \mathcal{L} is a Purely Symbolic System if its grounding set is empty, i.e., G=\emptyset . To prove our main theorem, we assume the system \mathcal{L} has sufficient expressive power to encompass Peano Arithmetic, allowing for Gödel numbering and self-reference [ 1 , 5 ] . Axiom 2.1 (Arithmetization & Expressibility) . There exists a Gödel numbering function \ulcorner\cdot\urcorner for all symbols and formulas. Consequently, there exists a predicate Groundable(n) in \mathcal{L} which is true if and only if "the number n is the Gödel number of a groundable formula." Axiom 2.2 (Diagonal Lemma) . For any predicate P(x) in \mathcal{L} , there exists a sentence \psi such that the system can prove \psi\leftrightarrow P(\ulcorner\psi\urcorner) . Theorem 2.1 (Impossibility of Self-Grounding) . Any purely symbolic system that satisfies Axioms 2.5 and 2.6 cannot internally provide a complete and consistent determination of groundability for all its propositions. Proof. 1. In a purely symbolic system, G=\emptyset . Thus, for any symbol s , C(s)\cap G=\emptyset . By Definition 2.3, no symbol is groundable. 2. Now, assume for contradiction that the system can define a predicate Groundable(x) for its own propositions. Define a new predicate Ungr(x)\equiv\neg Groundable(x) . 3. By the Diagonal Lemma (Axiom 2.6), there exists a sentence P_{\text{ungroundable}} such that the system proves: P_{\text{ungroundable}}\leftrightarrow Ungr(\ulcorner P_{\text{ungroundable}}\urcorner)\quad\text{which is}\quad P_{\text{ungroundable}}\leftrightarrow\neg Groundable(\ulcorner P_{\text{ungroundable}}\urcorner) This sentence asserts its own ungroundability. 4. We analyze the groundability of P_{\text{ungroundable}} . • Case A: Assume P_{\text{ungroundable}} is groundable. Then Groundable(\ulcorner P_{\text{ungroundable}}\urcorner) is true. The equivalence implies the system proves \neg P_{\text{ungroundable}} . A consistent system cannot have a true, groundable proposition whose negation it proves. This is a contradiction. • Case B: Assume P_{\text{ungroundable}} is ungroundable. Then \neg Groundable(\ulcorner P_{\text{ungroundable}}\urcorner) is true. The equivalence implies the system proves P_{\text{ungroundable}} . Here, the system proves a sentence whose content asserts its own lack of a semantic foundation. This creates a rupture between syntactic provability and semantic groundability, as a consistent system should not prove sentences that are, by its own definitions, meaningless. 5. Both cases lead to a contradiction