Experiments on geostrophic convection: the role of the Prandtl number

Hannah M. Clercx, Rudie P.J. Kunnen · 2025

Read Experiments on geostrophic convection: the role of the Prandtl number by Hannah M. Clercx, Rudie P.J. Kunnen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-20126.txt.

Introduction

Hannah Clercx and Rudie Kunnen wrote this 2025 arXiv paper on fluid experiments. They study convection in a rotating cylinder of water. Heat drives the flow while steady rotation shapes it, a setup that mimics flows at planetary scale. The authors focus on how heat transfer depends on a property called the Prandtl number.

The Prandtl number compares how fast momentum and heat spread through a fluid. By changing the water temperature, the team covered a modest range of its values. They measured the Nusselt number, which gauges how well convection carries heat. Doubling the Prandtl number cut heat transfer by about a quarter. The authors link the drop to changes in the thin boundary layers near the plates. Sidewall temperature readings also let them gauge heat carried by a wall-bound flow mode.

Catalog record

CREATORHannah M. Clercx, Rudie P.J. Kunnen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-20126

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Experiments on geostrophic convection: the role of the Prandtl number Hannah M. Clercx, Rudie P.J. Kunnen Abstract Flows at planetary scales are generally driven by buoyancy and influenced by rotation. Rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RRBC) is a practical and simple model that can be used to describe these systems. In RRBC, thermally induced convection occurs, which is influenced by the constant rotation it experiences. We study RRBC in a cylinder in the geostrophic regime, where the dominant force balance is between Coriolis and pressure-gradient forces. Experiments are performed to assess the dependence of the Nusselt number Nu \mathrm{Nu} (efficiency of convective heat transfer) on the Prandtl number Pr \mathrm{Pr} (ratio of kinematic viscosity over thermal diffusivity), a relation that is not explored much for geostrophic convection. By using water at different mean temperatures we can reach 2.8 ≤ Pr ≤ 6 2.8\leq\mathrm{Pr}\leq 6 . We study the relation between Pr \mathrm{Pr} and Nu \mathrm{Nu} at constant Ekman number Ek = 3 × 10 − 7 \mathrm{Ek}=3\times 10^{-7} (an inverse measure for strength of rotation) for two different diameter-to-height aspect ratios ( Γ = 1 / 5 \Gamma=1/5 and 1 / 2 1/2 ) of the setup. The corresponding constant Rayleigh numbers (strength of thermal forcing) are Ra = 1.1 × 10 12 \mathrm{Ra}=1.1\times 10^{12} and 1 × 10 11 1\times 10^{11} , respectively. Additionally, we measure the relation between the Rayleigh number Ra \mathrm{Ra} and Nu \mathrm{Nu} for 4 × 10 10 ≤ Ra ≤ 7 × 10 11 4\times 10^{10}\leq\mathrm{Ra}\leq 7\times 10^{11} , Ek = 3 × 10 − 7 \mathrm{Ek}=3\times 10^{-7} and Pr = 3.7 \mathrm{Pr}=3.7 . It is found that Nu \mathrm{Nu} exhibits a significant dependence on Pr \mathrm{Pr} , even within this limited range. Increasing Pr \mathrm{Pr} by a factor 2 resulted in a decrease of Nu \mathrm{Nu} of about 25 % 25\% . We hypothesize that the decrease of Nu \mathrm{Nu} is caused by the changing ratio of the thermal and kinetic boundary layer thicknesses as a result of increasing Pr \mathrm{Pr} . We also consider the anticipated contributions of the wall mode to the heat transfer using sidewall temperature measurements. I Introduction Rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RRBC) is a simplified model intended to represent geophysical and astrophysical flows, as it considers flows driven by buoyancy and affected by rotation. In this model, a flow is confined between two horizontal plates, heated from below and cooled at the top, while rotating about a vertical axis. Regimes in RRBC vary from the rotation-unaffected regime to the rotation-dominated (or geostrophic) regime Kunnen2021 ; Ecke2023 . These regimes can be defined using dimensionless parameters; here we use the Rayleigh number \mathrm{Ra} , the Ekman number \mathrm{Ek} and the Prandtl number \mathrm{Pr} . We define \mathrm{Ra}=\frac{g\alpha}{\nu\kappa}\Delta TH^{3}\,,\quad\mathrm{Ek}=\frac{\nu}{2\Omega H^{2}}\,,\quad\mathrm{Pr}=\frac{\nu}{\kappa}\,, (1) where g is gravitational acceleration, H the distance between the plates and \Delta T the temperature difference between them, \Omega the rotation rate and \alpha , \nu and \kappa are the thermal expansion coefficient, kinematic viscosity and thermal diffusivity of the fluid, respectively. \mathrm{Ra} is an indication for the strength of thermal forcing, \mathrm{Ek} quantifies the ratio between the viscous and the Coriolis forces, \mathrm{Pr} quantifies the ratio between the momentum diffusivity and the thermal diffusivity. As a result, it is related to the ratio of the kinetic boundary layer and the thermal boundary layer. When \mathrm{Pr}>1 , the kinetic boundary layer is expected to be thicker than the thermal boundary layer, whereas when \mathrm{Pr}<1 , the reverse is true Schlichting1979 . Another parameter that is frequently encountered in the literature is the convective Rossby number \mathrm{Ro} , defined as Kunnen2021 ; Ecke2023 \mathrm{Ro}=\frac{\sqrt{g\alpha\Delta TH}}{2\Omega H}=\mathrm{Ek}\sqrt{\frac{\mathrm{Ra}}{\mathrm{Pr}}}\,, (2) giving an a priori indication of the ratio of the strength of thermal forcing to the importance of rotation. Recently, the geostrophic regime of rotating convection (or geostrophic convection in short) has been studied more extensively, as it is believed that this regime most accurately represents geophysical and astrophysical flows Kunnen2021 . The geostrophic regime is characterized by small Ekman and Rossby numbers, resulting in a principal balance of forces between the Coriolis force and the pressure gradient: the so-called geostrophic balance. As a result the flow is rotation-dominated: the flow is organized along the rotation axis but with turbulent fluctations remaining (often referred to as quasi-two-dimensional turbulence, e.g. Alexakis2018 ; Kunnen2021 ). It is a challenge to reach the geostrophic regime in current experimental setups. Large-scale setups are required to simultaneously achieve large enough Rayleigh numbers to induce bulk convection and small enough Ekman numbers for rotational constraint Cheng2018 . This leaves many open questions concerning the dependency of the heat transfer on certain parameters. With this in mind, an experimental study is done on the variation of the Prandtl number \mathrm{Pr} . We want to determine whether and how this affects the efficiency of convective heat transfer, parameterized by the Nusselt number \mathrm{Nu}=\frac{qH}{k\Delta T}\,, (3) where q is the heat flux and k the thermal conductivity. The heat flux in the geostrophic regime of rotating convection has only scarcely been probed with experiments. Most studies have used constant \mathrm{Pr} with water ( \mathrm{Pr}\approx 4-7 ) Cheng2015 ; Cheng2020 ; Lu2021 ; Hawkins2023 or gases ( \mathrm{Pr}\approx 0.7 ) Ecke2014 ; Wedi2021 as the working fluid. Experimental work on rotating convection with variation of \mathrm{Pr} has been done, but mostly outside of the geostrophic regime at higher values of \mathrm{Ek}\gtrsim 10^{-6} Liu1997 ; Zhong2009 ; Weiss2016 . Abbate & Aurnou Abbate2023 could reach a smaller \mathrm{Ek}\geq 2\times 10^{-7} at \mathrm{Ra} up to 2\times 10^{12} , employing water and other liquids to have \mathrm{Pr} between 6 and 10^{3} . Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) studies investigating variation of \mathrm{Pr} in rotating convection have used cylindrical domains Zhong2009 ; Stevens2010 ; Zhang2021 or rectilinear domains with periodic boundary conditions in the horizontal directions King2013 ; Stellmach2014 ; Yang2020 ; AguirreGuzman2022 ; Anas2024 . Additionally, effects of \mathrm{Pr} have been considered in simulations employing an asymptotically reduced set of governing equations valid in the limit of rapid rotation Sprague2006 ; Julien2012 ; Maffei2021 . These simulations also consider a horizontally periodic domain. We summarize the parameter ranges for these studies in Table 1 . The main conclusion from these works is that, for larger \mathrm{Pr}\gtrsim 1 and at moderate values of \mathrm{Ra}\lesssim 10^{10} and \mathrm{Ek}\gtrsim 10^{-6} , there exists a range of parameter values where the convective heat transfer is larger with rotation than without. The excess amount (can be up to about 60\% Anas2024 ) generally increases with \mathrm{Pr} and reaches its maximum at progressively higher rotation rates (smaller \mathrm{Ek} ) Stevens2010 ; Yang2020 ; Anas2024 . The mechanism involved is Ekman pumping Pedlosky1982 ; Kundu2008 acting as an efficient transport mechanism for boundary-layer fluid towards the opposite plate, where an ‘optimal’ condition is found when kinetic and temperature boundary layers are of equal thickness. However, when moving to more extreme parameters \mathrm{Ra}\gtrsim 10^{10} and \mathrm{Ek}\lesssim 10^{-6} , the convective heat flux overshoot with respect to the non-rotating case vanishes Cheng2015 ; Cheng2020 . Table 1: Parameter overview of studies of turbulent rotating convection with variation of the Prandtl number \mathrm{Pr} . Note that the asymptotic simulations do not separately consider \mathrm{Ra} and \mathrm{Ek} as input parameters.

Read the complete text