An ensemble of Gaussian fields with multifractal statistics for turbulence

Mark Warnecke 1, Lukas Bentkamp 2, Gabriel B. Apolinário 2, Michael Wilczek 2, Perry Johnson 1 · 2025

Read An ensemble of Gaussian fields with multifractal statistics for turbulence by Mark Warnecke 1, Lukas Bentkamp 2, Gabriel B. Apolinário 2, Michael Wilczek 2, Perry Johnson 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-19622.txt.

Introduction

Turbulence stirs fluids into swirls at every scale, and its statistics still resist exact theory. Mark Warnecke and four co-authors build a model that mixes two known ideas. Multifractal models capture the bursty spikes of turbulence well. Superstatistics instead blend many simple random processes into one richer whole. The authors lift a multifractal rule for velocity jumps into an ensemble of Gaussian fields.

Careful choices of correlation and weights let the ensemble match real turbulence at both mid and fine scales. It also settles into sane large-scale behavior. The model can adopt any of the standard burst-shape spectra used in the field. The authors detail the statistics the construction produces. A flexible generator of fake turbulence helps test instruments and theories alike.

Catalog record

CREATORMark Warnecke 1, Lukas Bentkamp 2, Gabriel B. Apolinário 2, Michael Wilczek 2, Perry Johnson 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-19622

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An ensemble of Gaussian fields with multifractal statistics for turbulence Mark Warnecke 1, Lukas Bentkamp 2, Gabriel B. Apolinário 2, Michael Wilczek 2, Perry Johnson 1 Abstract Obtaining accurate field statistics continues to be one of the major challenges in turbulence theory and modeling. From the various existing modeling approaches, multifractal models have been successful in capturing intermittency in velocity gradient and increment distributions. On the other hand, superstatistical models from nonequilibrium statistical mechanics have shown the capacity to model PDFs of various statistical turbulent quantities as ensembles of simpler stochastic processes. Here, we present an approach that generates field statistics in the form of a characteristic functional by promoting a model for multifractal increment statistics to an ensemble of Gaussian fields. By carefully designing the correlation function and the corresponding weight of each subensemble, we are able to define a functional that exhibits multifractal two-point inertial-range and dissipation-range statistics, and that blends into realistic large-scale behavior. Additionally, the method is capable of producing multifractal statistics with any of the widely used singularity spectra. We characterize the fidelity of our approach through comparisons to literature results from direct numerical simulations. Overall, our framework thereby bridges between three different perspectives to turbulence: superstatistics, multifractals, and functional approaches to turbulence. † † affiliation: 1 Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering, University of California Irvine. 2 Theoretical Physics I, University of Bayreuth, Universitätsstraße 30, 95447 Bayreuth, Germany. 1 Introduction Turbulence is characterized by velocity fluctuations whose statistics are strongly scale-dependent. Probability density functions (PDFs) of the velocity increments are approximately Gaussian at separation distances commensurate to and larger than the integral length scale, but display heavier tails as the separation length scale decreases through the inertial range and into the dissipative range of scales. This phenomenon, known as intermittency, presents a major challenge to creating accurate turbulence models. Over the years, a number of techniques have been developed to model intermittency, such as multifractals and superstatistics, which are reviewed in the following. In the language of multifractal theory, multiscale observables can be written as a statistical mixture of a continuum of Hölder exponents. Each exponent h occupies a set of dimension D(h) and this determines the contribution of each h to the full statistics ( Mandelbrot 1977 ; Parisi & Frisch 1985 ; Falconer 1990 ; Meneveau & Sreenivasan 1991 ) . Among the observables to which multifractal theory has been successfully applied are velocity gradients ( Nelkin 1990 ; Chevillard & Meneveau 2006 ; Ishihara et al. 2009 ; Johnson & Meneveau 2017 ; Pereira et al. 2018 ; Luo et al. 2022 ) , Eulerian velocity increments ( Benzi et al. 1984 ; Meneveau & Sreenivasan 1991 ) , Lagrangian velocity increments ( Biferale et al. 2004 ; Arnèodo et al. 2008 ; Chevillard et al. 2005 ; Chevillard et al. 2012 ) , and Lagrangian acceleration ( Biferale et al. 2004 ) . Crucially, it provides a connection between the asymptotic scaling of all of these observables in terms of a single D(h) function. At first glance, superstatistics ( Beck & Cohen 2003 ; Beck 2004 ; Beck 2011 ) represents a complementary approach to model intermittency based on a mixture distribution. Applied to nonequilibrium statistical mechanics, superstatistics describes a mixture of Boltzmann statistics with the temperature as the mixing parameter ( Beck & Cohen 2003 ; Beck 2004 ; Beck 2011 ) . In the context of turbulence, the mixing parameter may be, for instance, the energy dissipation. This description has been shown to capture non-Gaussian turbulence statistics both in the Eulerian ( Beck 2000 ) and Lagrangian frames ( Reynolds 2003 ; Reynolds et al. 2005 ; Beck 2003 ; Beck 2007 ) . It is also worth noting that the multifractal model can be formulated in a way akin to superstatistics. Specifically, Chevillard et al. 2012 considered a superposition of Gaussian increment statistics with a fluctuating variance. This indicates that intimate relations between the two approaches exist. Previous applications of the multifractal and superstatistical approaches have focused on the modeling of individual random variables, e.g., two-point statistics. While the multifractal language provides a connection between the universal properties of different observables ( Benzi et al. 1991 ; Benzi et al. 1998 ; Chevillard et al. 2012 ) , the interest in extending these approaches to modeling the statistics of entire random fields remains. Wilczek 2016 showed that a superposition of Gaussian characteristic functionals (i.e., a statistical ensemble of Gaussian fields) with a fluctuating correlation function is capable of producing non-Gaussianity and intermittency. This naturally leads to the question whether a mixture model with realistic multifractal properties comprising entire field statistics can be developed. A first step into this direction was recently taken by Friedrich et al. 2021 , who developed a model for field statistics with classic K62 multifractal scaling ( Kolmogorov 1962 ; Obukhov 1962 ) . The approach has been extended to enable a statistical refinement of sparse data sets by Lübke et al. 2023 and has furthermore been applied to the stochastic modeling of turbulent wind fields ( Friedrich et al. 2022 ) . We mention as well a complementary approach to field statistics, where realizations of a random field are generated with properties compatible with multifractal theory, either in a static ( Chevillard et al. 2019 ) or dynamic way ( Apolinário et al. 2022 ; Beck et al. 2024 ) . In this paper, we establish a relation between existing multifractal models and the superstatistical Gaussian field ensemble approach. We construct an ensemble of Gaussian fields that features increment and gradient statistics complying with a given multifractal singularity spectrum, albeit only for its even moments. From a conceptual point of view this highlights close connections between the discussed previous approaches and lays the foundation for a future connection to statistical field theories based on the Navier-Stokes equation such as the functional approach ( Hopf 1952 ; Ohkitani 2020 ) . The content is arranged as follows. In Section 2 , we review the multifractal modeling of Chevillard et al. 2012 and the ensemble of Gaussian fields of Wilczek 2016 . In Section 3 , we show how the multifractal description can be generalized to a superstatistical characteristic functional. Section 4 demonstrates the approach with a simple example—the classic lognormal model. In Section 5 , a more general model is considered, with an arbitrary singularity spectrum, and realistic large-scale and viscous-range behavior. Conclusions are drawn in Section 6 . 2 Theoretical background 2.1 Gaussian mixtures for multifractal velocity increment PDFs In this section, we summarize the formulation of multifractals as Gaussian mixtures put forward by Chevillard et al. 2012 . The paper considers velocity increments v=\delta_{\ell}u across a scale \ell in the inertial range, i.e., \eta\ll\ell\ll L where \eta denotes the Kolmogorov scale and L the integral scale of the flow. The velocity increment, conditional on a given Hölder exponent h , is modeled as a zero-mean Gaussian random variable, with PDF g(v;S(\ell;h))=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi S(\ell;h)}}\exp\left[-\frac{v^{2}}{2S(\ell;h)}\right]\,. (1) Notice that we have adopted a notation for the Gaussian PDF g(x;\sigma^{2}) where \sigma^{2} is the variance. Here, S(\ell;h) is the second-order structure function conditional on a given Hölder exponent, and behaves as S(\ell;h)=2\sigma_{u}^{2}\left(1+\left(\frac{L}{\ell}\right)^{2}\right)^{-h}\,, (2) in the inertial and large-scale

Read the complete text