Nonparametric efficient estimation of the longitudinal front-door functional
Marie S. Breum, Helene C. W. Rytgaard, Torben Martinussen, Erin E. Gabriel · 2025
Read Nonparametric efficient estimation of the longitudinal front-door functional by Marie S. Breum, Helene C. W. Rytgaard, Torben Martinussen, Erin E. Gabriel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-19040.txt.
Introduction
Marie S. Breum and three co-authors build estimators for a causal quantity that arises when a treatment's effect flows entirely through a middle variable. This front-door setup helps when hidden factors tangle treatment and outcome directly, so the usual adjustment fails. Their version is longitudinal: treatment and mediator both change over time. Apart from a simple plug-in estimator, no proper methods existed for it.
The authors derive estimators that are nonparametric and efficient, meaning they lean on few assumptions and waste little data. The estimators handle high-dimensional mediators and are multiply robust, staying valid if parts of the model are right. They also allow machine-learning estimates of the nuisance parts while keeping inference honest. Simulations confirm the theory, and the team applies the method to an infant trial on peanut allergy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marie S. Breum, Helene C. W. Rytgaard, Torben Martinussen, Erin E. Gabriel |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 96 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-19040
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nonparametric efficient estimation of the longitudinal front-door functional Marie S. Breum, Helene C. W. Rytgaard, Torben Martinussen, Erin E. Gabriel Abstract The front-door criterion is an identification strategy for the intervention-specific mean outcome in settings where the standard back-door criterion fails due to unmeasured exposure-outcome confounders, but an intermediate variable exists that completely mediates the effect of exposure on the outcome and is not affected by unmeasured confounding. The front-door criterion has been extended to the longitudinal setting, where exposure and mediator are measured repeatedly over time. However, to the best of our knowledge, applications of the longitudinal front-door criterion remain unexplored. This may reflect both limited awareness of the method and the absence of suitable estimation techniques. In this report, we propose nonparametric efficient estimators of the longitudinal front-door functional. The estimators are multiply robust and allow for the use of data-adaptive (machine learning) methods for nuisance estimation while providing valid inference. The theoretical properties of the estimators are showcased in a simulation study. Keywords: front-door adjustment; longitudinal data; one-step estimation; TMLE; unmeasured confounders 1 Introduction The seminal work of 11 showed that if a variable exists that completely mediates the effect of exposure on the outcome and is not affected by unmeasured confounding, then the intervention-specific mean outcome is identified by the front-door formula, even if there are unmeasured exposure-outcome confounders. This is a valuable form of identification, specifically in observational settings with unmeasurable and complex confounders of exposure and outcome. In 11 , Pearl considered a hypothetical trial investigating the effect of smoking on lung-cancer, where smoking and lung-cancer are likely confounded by unmeasured genetic predispositions. If we can measure the amount of tar deposited in a subject’s lungs, and we believe that smoking does not have any direct effect on lung cancer except that mediated by tar, then the front-door criterion allows for identification of the average causal effect of smoking on lung cancer. Another possible example is an observational study of seasonal influenza vaccination, where many unmeasurable behavioral differences may lead to different probabilities of being vaccinated and infected. However, there are also numerous biological variables, many of which will be known and often used in Phase II trials of the vaccine, that are unlikely to be confounded with these behaviors. In this case, the front-door criterion would allow us to identify the average causal effect of vaccination on the infection rate, provided that we believe that vaccination does not have a direct effect on infection except that mediated by the biological variables measured in the trial. Some recent real-data applications of the front-door criterion are given in 6 ; 9 ; 12 ; 21 and 7 . Often, the exposure and mediator will vary over time. For example, the vaccination scheme described above may require more than one dose. 13 extended the front-door criterion to the longitudinal setting to identify the population average difference in the outcome comparing two different exposure histories. To our knowledge, applications of the longitudinal front-door criterion remain an open area. This may reflect that, with the exception of a simple plug-in estimator proposed by 13 , no suitable estimating techniques exist. By introducing new estimators, this work provides the tools needed to bring such applications within reach. Even in the point treatment setting, relatively few estimators have been suggested in the literature, compared to the rich literature on back-door estimation. In 5 the authors proposed a multiply robust one-step estimator of the front-door formula for a dichotomous mediator. 21 and 7 independently of each other proposed targeted minimum loss-based estimators (TMLE) of the front-door formula, which can handle continuous and multivariate mediators. 3 proposed various inverse probability weighted (IPW) estimators, including one which is applicable to continuous exposures. We build on this work to derive flexible nonparametric estimators of the longitudinal front-door functional, allowing for continuous and multivariate mediators and binary exposures. In particular, we derive the efficient influence function and propose two types of nonparametric efficient estimators: a one-step estimator ( 20 ) and a targeted minimum loss based estimator (TMLE) ( 18 ; 16 ; 17 ) . We study the double robustness properties of the estimators, and we show that the method allows for the use of data-adaptive (machine learning) methods when estimating the nuisance models. Moreover, both of the proposed estimators avoid direct estimation of the conditional mediator density, which is an advantage when, as will typically be the case, the mediator is high-dimensional. In the point treatment setting, the front-door functional was shown to still have a meaningful interpretation as a population intervention indirect effect (PIIE) when the assumption that there is no direct effect of treatment on the outcome is replaced by a cross-world independence assumption ( 5 ) . Also in the point treatment setting, 21 provided an interventionist interpretation of the front-door functional under a dismissible component assumption. In the Supplementary Materials , we generalize these alternative interpretations to the longitudinal setting, which further enhances the practical utility of our proposed estimators. This report is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we introduce some notation as well as the identification result. In Section 3 , we derive simple estimators based on inverse probability weighting and sequential regression that will be used as building blocks for constructing efficient estimators. In Section 4 , we derive the efficient influence function and propose nonparametric efficient estimators. In Section 5 , we conduct a simulation study to illustrate the large sample properties of the proposed estimators. Some final remarks are provided in Section 6 . Proofs and technical derivations are given in the Appendix . 2 Preliminaries Let t=0,...,T be discrete time points that represent T follow-up visits. We can define the observed data vector as O=(L_{0},A_{0},M_{0},...,A_{T},M_{T},Y) where L_{0}\in\mathbb{R}^{d} is a vector of baseline covariates, A_{t}\in\{0,1\} is the exposure of interest at time t , M_{t}\in\mathcal{M}_{t}\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{p} is a vector of time-varying covariates at time t and Y\in\mathcal{Y}\subseteq\mathbb{R} is the outcome of interest. Let P denote the distribution of O that is assumed to lie in a nonparametric statistical model \mathcal{P} , and let O_{1},...,O_{n} be a sample of iid observations of O . We let \mathbb{E} denote the expectation with respect to P and for a given function f , we let \mathbb{P}_{n}\{f(O)\}=n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^{n}f(O_{i}) denote the empirical average. We will also use \bar{X}_{t}=(X_{0},...,X_{t}) to denote the history of an arbitrary variable X and \underline{X}_{t}=(X_{t},...,X_{T}) to denote the future of a variable. We use the convention that any variable X_{t} with t<0 is defined as the empty set. Let Y(\bar{a}_{T}) be the counterfactual outcome under an intervention that sets \bar{A}_{T}=\bar{a}_{T}\in\{0,1\}^{T} . We will assume that the following consistency assumption holds. Assumption 1 (Consistency) . If \bar{A}_{t}=\bar{a}_{t} then Y(\bar{a}_{t})=Y with probability 1 for t=0,...,T . In the following, we will focus on identification and estimation of the target parameter \displaystyle\Psi^{\bar{a}_{T}}(P)=\mathbb{E}\left\{Y(\bar{a}_{T})\right\}, (1) from which various causal parameters can be defined. For example, the parameter of interest could be the average causal effect of always being exposed versus never exposed, which is defined as the contrast \Psi^{\bar{1}_{T}}(P)-\Psi^{\bar{0}_{T}}(P) . Let U be a set of unmeasured confounders affecting \bar{A}_{T} and Y . The following assumptions will allow for identification of \Psi^{\bar{a}_{T}}(P) in the presence of unmeasured confounders between treatment and