Finite-temperature Yang-Mills theories with the density of states method: towards the continuum limit
Ed Bennett, Biagio Lucini, David Mason, Maurizio Piai, Enrico Rinaldi, Davide Vadacchino, Fabian Zierler, (on behalf of the TELOS collaboration) · 2025
Read Finite-temperature Yang-Mills theories with the density of states method: towards the continuum limit by Ed Bennett, Biagio Lucini, David Mason, Maurizio Piai, Enrico Rinaldi, Davide Vadacchino, Fabian Zierler, (on behalf of the TELOS collaboration) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-19009.txt.
Introduction
Ed Bennett and six co-authors study how a Yang-Mills theory behaves when heated, using a lattice simulation method built for hard cases. Many such theories jump sharply between a confined phase and a free phase as temperature rises. If that jump happened in the early universe, it could have left a background of gravitational waves that detectors might one day hear. Standard sampling methods struggle to measure the jump cleanly.
The team applies the density of states method to a theory with the gauge group Sp(4). They map its first-order transition in very large volumes for two depths of the time direction, a step toward the smooth continuum limit. They confirm signs of a true sharp jump: coexisting states, lingering metastable states, latent heat, and surface tension. Several ways of locating the critical point agree with each other.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ed Bennett, Biagio Lucini, David Mason, Maurizio Piai, Enrico Rinaldi, Davide Vadacchino, Fabian Zierler, (on behalf of the TELOS collaboration) |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-19009
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Finite-temperature Yang-Mills theories with the density of states method: towards the continuum limit Ed Bennett, Biagio Lucini, David Mason, Maurizio Piai, Enrico Rinaldi, Davide Vadacchino, Fabian Zierler, (on behalf of the TELOS collaboration) Abstract A first-order, confinement/deconfinement phase transition appears in the finite temperature behavior of many non-Abelian gauge theories. These theories play an important role in proposals for completion of the Standard Model of particle physics, hence the phase transition might have occurred in the early stages of evolution of our universe, leaving behind a detectable relic stochastic background of gravitational waves. Lattice field theory studies implementing the density of states method have the potential to provide detailed information about the phase transition, and measure the parameters determining the gravitational-wave power spectrum, by overcoming some the challenges faced with importance-sampling methods. We assess this potential for a representative choice of Yang-Mills theory with S p ( 4 ) Sp(4) gauge group. We characterize its finite-temperature, first-order phase transition, in the thermodynamic (infinite volume) limit, for two different choices of number of sites in the compact time direction, hence taking the first steps towards the continuum limit extrapolation. We demonstrate the persistence of non-perturbative phenomena associated to the first-order phase transition: coexistence of states, metastability, latent heat, surface tension. We find consistency between several different strategies for the extraction of the volume-dependent critical coupling, hence assessing the size of systematic effects. We also determine the minimum choice of ratio between spatial and time extent of the lattice that allows to identify the contribution of the surface tension to the free energy. We observe that this ratio scales non-trivially with the time extent of the lattice, and comment on the implications for future high-precision numerical studies. I Introduction Finite-temperature, first-order phase transitions in gauge theories are critical to our understanding of particle physics and cosmology. Yet, their characterization on the lattice requires overcoming algorithmic and technological challenges. It is hence the subject of a vast literature, both for SU(3) gauge theories—see for example the discussion in Ref. borsanyi:2022xml , the review Aarts:2023vsf , and references therein, in particular Refs. Svetitsky:1982gs ; Yaffe:1982qf , but also Refs. Kajantie:1981wh ; Celik:1983wz ; Kogut:1983mn ; Svetitsky:1983bq ; Gottlieb:1985ug ; Brown:1988qe ; Fukugita:1989yb ; Bacilieri:1989ir ; Alves:1990pn ; Boyd:1995zg ; Boyd:1996bx ; Borsanyi:2012ve ; Shirogane:2016zbf and Refs. Saito:2011fs ; Ejiri:2019csa ; Kiyohara:2021smr ; Fromm:2011qi ; Cuteri:2020yke ; Borsanyi:2021yoz —and for other gauge groups, relevant for new physics Lucini:2002ku ; Lucini:2003zr ; Holland:2003kg ; Lucini:2005vg ; Pepe:2005sz ; Pepe:2006er ; Cossu:2007dk ; Panero:2009tv ; Datta:2010sq ; Lucini:2012wq ; Bruno:2014rxa ; Appelquist:2015yfa ; Appelquist:2015zfa ; LatticeStrongDynamics:2020jwi ; Bruno:2024dha . Appealing extensions of the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics postulate the existence of new dark sectors Strassler:2006im ; Cheung:2007ut ; Hambye:2008bq ; Feng:2009mn ; Cohen:2010kn ; Foot:2014uba ; Bertone:2016nfn , taking a variety of forms: composite dark matter models DelNobile:2011je ; Hietanen:2013fya ; Cline:2016nab ; Cacciapaglia:2020kgq ; Dondi:2019olm ; Ge:2019voa ; Beylin:2019gtw ; Yamanaka:2019aeq ; Yamanaka:2019yek ; Cai:2020njb , strongly interacting massive particle (SIMP) models Hochberg:2014dra ; Hochberg:2014kqa ; Hochberg:2015vrg ; Bernal:2017mqb ; Berlin:2018tvf ; Bernal:2019uqr ; Tsai:2020vpi ; Kondo:2022lgg ; Chu:2024rrv ; Maas:2021gbf ; Zierler:2021cfa ; Kulkarni:2022bvh ; Pomper:2024otb , dark dilaton effective field theories Cacciapaglia:2023kat ; Ferrante:2023bcz ; Appelquist:2024koa . They address puzzles in the Standard Model of cosmology, such as observational evidence that dark energy and dark matter, that have no SM explanation, dominate our present universe (see, e.g., the review in Ref. Cirelli:2024ssz ). Even explaining the observed baryonic component requires a matter-antimatter asymmetry that admits no dynamical SM origin—see Refs. Laine:1998jb ; Morrissey:2012db for reviews, and references therein. In particular Refs. Kajantie:1996mn ; Karsch:1996yh ; Gurtler:1997hr ; Rummukainen:1998as ; Csikor:1998eu ; Aoki:1999fi ; DOnofrio:2015gop ; Gould:2022ran show the failure of the Sakharov’s out-of-equilibrium condition Sakharov:1967dj for electroweak baryogenesis. If the dark sector gauge theory undergoes, in the early universe, a strong first-order phase transition, it leads to the emission of gravitational waves Witten:1984rs ; Kamionkowski:1993fg ; Allen:1996vm ; Schwaller:2015tja ; Croon:2018erz ; Christensen:2018iqi , potentially detectable by future experimental programmes Seto:2001qf ; Kawamura:2006up ; Crowder:2005nr ; Corbin:2005ny ; Harry:2006fi ; Hild:2010id ; Yagi:2011wg ; Sathyaprakash:2012jk ; Thrane:2013oya ; Caprini:2015zlo ; LISA:2017pwj ; LIGOScientific:2016wof ; Isoyama:2018rjb ; Baker:2019nia ; Brdar:2018num ; Reitze:2019iox ; Caprini:2019egz ; Maggiore:2019uih —see also Ref. afzal2023nanograv . Appraising the viability of experimental searches necessitates a precise characterization of the physics in proximity of the transition, including a measurement of the parameters that control the gravitational wave (GW) power spectrum. Of particular interest are \alpha and \beta/H_{\ast} Caprini:2019egz , related, respectively, to latent heat and bubble nucleation rate (and bubble surface tension). 1 1 1 Calculating the nucleation rate is itself a challenging task Kalikmanov2013 . The main challenge for the direct lattice numerical calculation of these quantities (that act as input values in numerical packages such as PTPlot Caprini:2019egz ) is that first-order phase transitions are accompanied by phase coexistence and metastability. These phenomena compromise ergodicity and detailed balance requirements of traditional importance-sampling techniques, based on Markov chain Monte Carlo update algorithms, and lead to critical slowing down Berg:1991cf . Indirect routes can be pursued to estimate the power spectrum in strongly coupled theories Huang:2020crf ; Halverson:2020xpg ; Kang:2021epo ; Reichert:2021cvs ; Reichert:2022naa ; Pasechnik:2023hwv , using effective Polyakov-loop theory Pisarski:2000eq ; Pisarski:2001pe ; Pisarski:2002ji ; Sannino:2002wb ; Ratti:2005jh ; Fukushima:2013rx ; Fukushima:2017csk ; Lo:2013hla ; Hansen:2019lnf and matrix models Meisinger:2001cq ; Dumitru:2010mj ; Dumitru:2012fw ; Kondo:2015noa ; Pisarski:2016ixt ; Nishimura:2017crr ; Guo:2018scp ; KorthalsAltes:2020ryu ; Hidaka:2020vna . Most recently, gauge-gravity duality techniques Maldacena:1997re ; Gubser:1998bc ; Witten:1998qj ; Aharony:1999ti , adapted to capture confinement and chiral symmetry breaking Witten:1998zw ; Klebanov:2000hb ; Maldacena:2000yy ; Chamseddine:1997nm ; Babington:2003vm ; Butti:2004pk ; Brower:2000rp ; Karch:2002sh ; Kruczenski:2003be ; Sakai:2004cn ; Sakai:2005yt , have also been used for the treatment first-order phase transitions in strongly coupled field theories—see, e.g., Refs Bigazzi:2020phm ; Ares:2020lbt ; Bea:2021zsu ; Bigazzi:2021ucw ; Henriksson:2021zei ; Ares:2021ntv ; Ares:2021nap ; Morgante:2022zvc ; Bea:2021zol ; Bea:2022mfb ; Bea:2024xgv ; Bea:2024bxu ; Bea:2024bls . This paper adopts a new, alternative strategy to gain direct access to the proximity of first-order phase transitions, that takes inspiration from flat histogram Berg:1991cf and density of states Wang:2000fzi methods. The Logarithmic Linear Relaxation (LLR) algorithm Langfeld:2012ah ; Langfeld:2013xbf ; Langfeld:2015fua ; Cossu:2021bgn —see also Ref. DElia:2024qxa —is precisely described in the body of the paper. The underlying idea is to scan the space of configurations with a density function inspired by the microcanonical (rather than canonical) ensemble in statistical mechanics, and treat on equal footing stable, metastable, as well as unstable configurations of the lattice system, overcoming the difficulties connected with importance sampling methods. A number of increasingly sophisticated analyses have already been performed, pertaining to Abelian gauge theories Langfeld:2015fua , and to SU(3) theories at zero Cossu:2021bgn and finite temperature Mason:2022trc ; Mason:2022aka ; Lucini:2023irm . Finite-temperature studies exist also for Sp(4) Bennett:2024bhy , SU(4) Springer:2021liy ; Springer:2022qos and SU(N_{c}) Springer:2023wok ; Springer:2023hcc , all of which yield encouraging preliminary results. We consider a lattice non-Abelian gauge theory, the Sp(4) Yang-Mills theory in four dimension, characterize its finite-temperature deconfinement transition using the LLR algorithm, and perform the first scaling test to approach the continuum and infinite-volume limits. To this purpose,