Ultrasound response to time-reversal symmetry breaking below the superconducting phase transition

Chris Halcrow, Paul Leask, Egor Babaev · 2025

Read Ultrasound response to time-reversal symmetry breaking below the superconducting phase transition by Chris Halcrow, Paul Leask, Egor Babaev (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-18922.txt.

Introduction

Chris Halcrow and two co-authors ask how sound can reveal a hidden change inside a superconductor. Some superconductors, after they start to conduct with no resistance, later break time-reversal symmetry, a state where the material acts as if time runs one way rather than the other. Sound waves slow or fade as they pass through a crystal, and those shifts can signal such changes.

The team builds a theory that links the stretch of the crystal lattice to the quantities that describe the superconducting state. They sort out how each symmetry type adds to the sound signal in four-fold crystals. Worked cases show how sound speed changes with temperature across both transitions. The results show sound tests can spot weak links between parts of the state, and that outside strain can reshape the response.

Catalog record

CREATORChris Halcrow, Paul Leask, Egor Babaev
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-18922

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ultrasound response to time-reversal symmetry breaking below the superconducting phase transition Chris Halcrow, Paul Leask, Egor Babaev Abstract Ultrasound attenuation is a powerful probe of symmetry-breaking phenomena in superconductors. In this work, we develop a framework to model the ultrasound response of multi-component superconductors undergoing a time-reversal symmetry breaking transition below the superconducting phase transition. By coupling the elastic strain of the crystal lattice to the superconducting order parameters through group-theoretical analysis of tetragonal crystals, we classify how different symmetry channels contribute to the ultrasound signal. Using a two-component Ginzburg–Landau theory, we analyze the temperature dependence of sound velocity across both superconducting and time-reversal symmetry breaking transitions for several cases, including ( A 1 ​ g , A 1 ​ g ) (A_{1g},A_{1g}) , ( A 2 ​ g , B 1 ​ g ) (A_{2g},B_{1g}) , and E g E_{g} representations. Our results demonstrate that ultrasound measurements are highly sensitive to the presence of bilinear Josephson couplings and can distinguish between different realizations of the superconducting state. We further show how external strain can significantly alter the ultrasound response in systems breaking time reversal symmetry. I Introduction Ultrasound has long served as a powerful experimental tool for probing the properties of superconducting materials. A peak in ultrasonic attenuation below T_{C} was predicted by BCS (Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer) theory Bardeen et al. 1957 and was confirmed experimentally Tinkham 2004 . In recent years, the scope of superconductivity research has expanded to especially focus on materials that exhibit multiple broken symmetries, particularly those with multi-component order parameters, including many unconventional pairing states (see, e.g. Sigrist and Ueda 1991 ). Identifying and understanding extra broken symmetries in a superconducting states is currently one of the central research theme in superconductivity. Ultrasound is sensitive to the symmetry of the underlying superconducting state because it couples directly to lattice strain, which in turn interacts with the order parameter through symmetry-dependent couplings. Variations in sound velocity and attenuation across phase transitions can thus reveal detailed information about the nature of symmetry breaking. In particular, different components of the strain tensor transform according to distinct irreducible representations (irreps) of the crystal’s point group symmetry, allowing ultrasound to selectively probe specific symmetry channels. Ultrasound data was one of the important probes that showed that UPt 3 Müller et al. 1986 and UBe 13 Golding et al. 1985 were unconventional superconductors, with interesting symmetries. Ultrasound measurements have recently been used to argue that Sr 2 RuO 4 is a multi-component superconductor Benhabib et al. 2021 and that URu 2 Si 2 Ghosh et al. 2020 and UTe 2 Theuss et al. 2024a have only one component. In Ba 1-x K x Fe 2 As 2 the longitudinal and transverse ultrasonic responses provided, along with other probes, evidence of a novel state: an electron quadrupling condensate Grinenko et al. 2021a ; Halcrow et al. 2024 . Furthermore, an unusual attenuation signal has been interpreted evidence of domain walls, suggesting a broken additional discrete symmetry in Sr 2 RuO 4 Ghosh et al. 2022 . One of the most interesting additional symmetries that a superconductor can break is a time-reversal symmetry (TRSB) Zhang et al. 2019 ; Li et al. 2011 ; Xia et al. 2006 ; Vadimov and Silaev 2018 ; Maiti and Chubukov 2013 . Some superconductors undergo two transitions: from normal to time-reversal symmetric superconducting, and then to a TRSB phase. Materials like Sr 2 RuO 4 , UPt 3 , and Ba 1-x K x Fe 2 As 2 (at certain doping values x ) were argued to exhibit such behavior. Detecting and characterizing this transition is a central challenge in establishing new kinds superconducting states. The main aim of this paper is to analyze and to give a detailed pedagogical description of how ultrasound attenuation and velocity change across superconducting phase transitions, particularly in materials that exhibit a lower-temperature TRSB transition within the superconducting phase. We carry this out for materials that are described by mean-field theory. To do this, we develop a theoretical framework using the formalism similar to Sigrist 2002 and we model the coupled dynamics of strain and order parameters near the phase transitions. We focus on tetragonal crystals with D_{4h} symmetry, relevant to many candidate TRSB superconductors, and consider a variety of order parameter symmetries, including (A_{1g},A_{1g}) , (A_{2g},B_{1g}) , and E_{g} irreps. The ultrasonic wave’s dispersion is modified by the interaction with the order parameter, leading to changes in sound velocity and attenuation (absorption coefficient). We show that ultrasound can distinguish between these cases based on whether the sound velocity changes continuously or discontinuously at the transition, and whether responses appear in particular symmetry channels. We discuss that ultrasound is not only sensitive to the presence of TRSB but also to further details of the structure of the superconducting order parameter, and the presence of bilinear Josephson couplings. Since external stress can induce bilinear Josephson terms even in models where they are not present intrinsically, combining that with ultrasound probes offers a tunable mechanism to explore symmetry-resolved properties of superconductors. Figure 1: Schematic depictions of two discussed examples of phase diagrams of systems with a time-reversal symmetry breaking transition within the superconducting phase. The phase diagrams are schematic reconstructions for Ba 1-x K x Fe 2 As 2 (Fig. 1 in Grinenko et al. 2021a ) and a discussed phase diagram in strained Sr 2 RuO 4 (Fig. 1 in Yuan et al. 2021 ). All phase diagrams contain a 1D line where we transition from a normal to a time-reversal symmetric superconducting to a broken time-reversal phase as temperature decreases. This is the series of phase transitions we study in this paper. II Crystal symmetries and elastic strain To determine how ultrasound waves will respond to superconducting states in an elastic medium, we need to couple the superconducting theory to the strain of underlying crystal lattice, \epsilon_{ij}=\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\partial u_{i}}{\partial x_{j}}+\frac{\partial u_{j}}{\partial x_{i}}\right), (1) where \boldsymbol{u} is the local displacement vector. We first begin by considering the ultrasound response to elastic deformations of the crystal lattice in the absence of superconductivity. We will consider a tetragonal crystal throughout this paper, but the analysis extends to cubic and orthorhombic crystals with small modifications. Tetragonal crystals have a D_{4h} symmetry group. The order parameters and strain tensors can be decomposed into irreps of the group. There are four one-dimensional irreps, A_{1g},A_{2g},B_{1g} and B_{2g} , and one two-dimensional irrep E_{g} Kaba and Sénéchal 2019 . The irreps, and some of the order parameters and strains that transform like them are displayed in Table 1 . Irrep Dim. Order P. Strain Elastic C. A_{1g} 1 s , d_{z^{2}} \epsilon_{xx}+\epsilon_{yy} , \epsilon_{zz} (C_{11}+C_{12})/2,C_{33} A_{2g} 1 g_{xy(x^{2}-y^{2})} – – B_{1g} 1 d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} \epsilon_{xx}-\epsilon_{yy} (C_{11}-C_{12})/2 B_{2g} 1 d_{xy} \epsilon_{xy} C_{66} E_{g} 2 (d_{xz},d_{yz}) (\epsilon_{xz},\epsilon_{yz}) C_{44} Table 1: The irreducible representations of the D_{4h} point group and their corresponding order parameters. Also shown in the right most two columns for each irrep is the strain tensor(s) that transform like that irrep, and their associated elastic moduli. Terms in the free energy must be invariant under all symmetries of the point group. In representation theory language, all terms in the free energy must transform like A_{1g} . To find the allowed terms

Read the complete text