A treasure hunt in the pool of spectra classified as high-redshift QSOs by the spectroscopic pipeline of the SDSS DR16
Helmut Meusinger · 2025
Read A treasure hunt in the pool of spectra classified as high-redshift QSOs by the spectroscopic pipeline of the SDSS DR16 by Helmut Meusinger (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-18889.txt.
Introduction
Survey pipelines mislabel spectra, and those mistakes can hide rare objects in plain sight. Helmut Meusinger mines one such error pile in this 2025 paper. The Sloan Digital Sky Survey pipeline had tagged about four thousand spectra as quasars at very high redshift. He re-examined all of them by hand and by class.
After dropping poor spectra and three special plates, the true picture emerged. Only about a quarter were really quasars at that distance. Half were quasars at lower redshift, and the rest split between galaxies and stars. Many of the misfits proved unusual and were reassigned to rare types. The results are gathered into a catalogue. The study is a reminder that automated labels at the extremes are shaky. It also shows error piles are treasure pools for odd objects.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Helmut Meusinger |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-18889
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A treasure hunt in the pool of spectra classified as high-redshift QSOs by the spectroscopic pipeline of the SDSS DR16 Helmut Meusinger Abstract The discovery of outsiders in the form of unusual, rare, or even unknown object types is important as they can provide useful information about otherwise hidden physical phenomena and processes. The present study takes advantage of the fact that the automated spectroscopic pipeline of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) occasionally assigns uncommon spectra to high-redshift QSOs. This paper presents an analysis of ∼ 4000 \sim 4000 spectra that are QSOs with redshifts z > 4.5 z>4.5 according to the spectroscopic pipeline of the SDSS DR16. It turns out that, after excluding non-classifiable spectra of low quality and those from three special plates, only 26 % are high- z z QSOs, 50 % are QSOs at lower redshifts, 16 % are galaxies, and 8 % are stars. A significant proportion of the latter three categories prove to be unusual and are re-assigned here to a variety of rare types. The results of the re-evaluation are summarised in a catalogue. 1 Introduction The Sloan Digital Sky Survey ( York et al. 2000 , SDSS;) has revolutionised the database of Extragalactic astronomy. SDSS-I/II contains spectra for about 4 10^{4} QSOs with redshifts up to z\approx 5.5 ( Schneider et al. 2010 ) . The spectra were obtained by a pair of multi-object spectrographs with a total of 640 fibres, which produced an average resolving power of \approx 2000 in the wavelength interval 3800 Å to 9200 Å. In the next steps, SDSS-III and SDSS-IV used an upgraded pair of spectrographs for the Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey ( Dawson et al. 2013 , BOSS;) and the Extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey ( Dawson et al. 2016 , eBOSS;) that have a total of 1000 fibres and an extended wavelength coverage up to 10 400 Å. Multiple target selection algorithms were applied and large numbers of faint QSOs and galaxies were detected. The SDSS Data Release 16 ( Ahumada et al. 2020 , DR16;) contains more than four million spectra of QSOs, galaxies, and stars. The final SDSS-IV QSO catalogue from the DR16 ( Lyke et al. 2020 , QCDR16,) lists 750 414 QSOs. One of the opportunities and at the same time one of the challenges arising from the huge number of spectra is the possibility of discovering rare, unusual or even previously unknown types of QSOs, galaxies, and stars. For the vast majority of the SDSS QSOs, the spectral energy distribution (SED) in the optical and UV is well represented by composite spectra ( Vanden Berk et al. 2001 , e.g.) . However, due to the multiple physical processes involved, QSOs exhibit a wide range of spectral properties that can differ greatly from the standard spectrum. It is widely agreed that objects whose properties deviate significantly from the norm may hold a key to important physical processes, e.g. related to the evolution of active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and their impact on the host galaxies ( Harrison & Ramos Almeida 2024 , see review by) . The SDSS has confirmed the existence of rare populations of QSOs with unusual spectral properties, such as a red continuum, unusual broad absorption lines (BALs), weak or absent emission lines in combination with an unobscured continuum (WLQs), or double-peaked broad emission lines ( Fan et al. 1999 ; Fan & SDSS Collaboration 2002 ; Hall et al. 2002 ; Strateva et al. 2003 ; Plotkin et al. 2008 , e.g.) . Another rare phenomenon is that of the changing-look QSOs (CLQs), which show extreme temporal changes that correspond to a transition between different QSO types ( LaMassa et al. 2015 ; Potts & Villforth 2021 ; Komossa et al. 2024 , e.g.) . For statistical analyses it is important to increase the number of known objects of such types. Larger, but still relatively small, samples have been discovered by using specialised methods for the detection of outsiders ( Meusinger et al. 2012 ; Fustes et al. 2013 ; Wei et al. 2013 ; Meusinger & Balafkan 2014 ; Meusinger et al. 2016 ; Baron & Poznanski 2017 ; Doorenbos et al. 2021 ; Reis et al. 2021 ; Tiwari & Vivek 2025 , e.g.) . The main aim of the present study is also to find rare and unusual spectra, but using a different method. The automated spectroscopic pipeline of the SDSS tends to assign a high redshift to spectra of outliers, which can be those of low quality or of unusual types. The result of an SQL query for high- z QSOs should therefore be treated with caution if the aim is actually to obtain a sample of high- z QSOs. On the other hand, it can also prove to be a kind of treasure trove for rare and unusual spectra. This paper presents the results of an analysis of nearly 4000 spectra to which the spectroscopic pipeline of the SDSS DR16 has assigned redshifts z>4.5 . The analysis and classification of the spectra are described in Sect. 2 , the resulting object sample is presented in Sect. 3 , some unusual types are briefly discussed in Sect. 4 . Due to the variety of object types involved, it is not possible to discuss them in detail. Readers are encouraged to do further research. The Appendices present the description of the catalogue and a number of illustrating spectra. The objects are labelled here with their SDSS name, with the exception of the figures, where the designation ‘SDSS’ is omitted for reasons of space. Spectra are labelled with plate-MJD-fiberID. The Lambda Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM) cosmology is assumed with H_{0}=73 km s -1 Mpc -1 , \Omega_{\rm\Lambda}=0.73 , and \Omega_{\rm M}=0.27 . 2 Re-classification of the spectra The list of spectra for the present study was extracted via SQL query from the catalogue SpecObjAll on the Catalog Archive Server of the SDSS DR16. The only selection criteria were the classification as QSOs with z>4.5 and the requirement that the zWarning flag is either zero (i.e. no problems) or 64 (i.e. negative fluxes occur). The resulting list contains 3955 spectra, which are intentionally not limited to those from plates of good quality. The spectra were downloaded from the SDSS Science Archive Server using the bulk load service. The original idea was to use the software tool ASPECT ( in der Au et al. 2012 ) for the construction of a Kohonen self-organising map ( Kohonen 2001 , SOM;) . The SOM technique is an artificial neural network algorithm that uses unsupervised learning to sort the spectra by similarity. In previous studies, this method has proven to be efficient in the selection of rare, unusual objects from large samples of SDSS spectra ( Meusinger et al. 2012 ; Meusinger & Balafkan 2014 ; Meusinger et al. 2016 ; Meusinger et al. 2017 ) . However, initial tests with a SOM for a subsample of spectra from the present sample have shown that this method is less efficient here, as the sample is extremely inhomogeneous. This led to the decision to ‘manually’ classify the spectra individually. Figure 1: Four examples of problematic spectra with special