Polarization Transmission in the Electron-Ion Collider’s Hadron Storage Ring
E. Hamwi, G. H. Hoffstaetter · 2025
Read Polarization Transmission in the Electron-Ion Collider’s Hadron Storage Ring by E. Hamwi, G. H. Hoffstaetter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-18558.txt.
Introduction
A future Electron-Ion Collider needs proton beams that keep their spin alignment at high energy. Eiad Hamwi and Georg H. Hoffstaetter study how to protect that polarization in the collider's hadron storage ring. Their 2025 paper flags a threat: a symmetry-breaking collision zone excites strong spin resonances that can scramble the spins. Two rescue strategies are compared in simulations.
One strategy tunes the beam's vertical phase between devices called Siberian snakes so that scrambling kicks cancel. Both live-tuned and fixed settings worked through the strongest resonances. The second strategy turns the snakes' rotation axes to suppress the resonances at their source. A new, highly symmetric scheme the authors call Doubly Lee-Courant proved most robust and least sensitive to energy. They recommend that scheme as the base, with phase tuning for fine fixes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | E. Hamwi, G. H. Hoffstaetter |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-18558
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Polarization Transmission in the Electron-Ion Collider’s Hadron Storage Ring E. Hamwi, G. H. Hoffstaetter Abstract The successful operation of the future Electron-Ion Collider is contingent on maintaining high hadron beam polarization up to 275 GeV. The Hadron Storage Ring lattice, however, features a symmetry-breaking interaction region that excites strong, non-systematic spin resonances, posing a significant threat to polarization preservation. This paper systematically investigates two complementary strategies to ensure high polarization transmission. The first method involves optimizing the vertical betatron phase advance between Siberian snakes to orchestrate a cancellation of depolarizing kicks across the ring. We demonstrate through simulations that both dynamic and fixed-optics solutions based on this principle can successfully preserve polarization through the strongest resonances. The second, more powerful approach involves optimizing the snake rotation axes to suppress resonance driving terms at their source. We revisit established symmetric configurations, such as the Lee-Courant schemes, and introduce a novel, highly symmetric “Doubly Lee-Courant” (DLC) scheme, which enforces a local π \pi spin phase advance across every consecutive pair of snakes. Our analysis reveals a clear performance hierarchy, with the DLC configuration providing an exceptionally robust and energy-insensitive baseline for polarization preservation. We conclude that a hybrid strategy, using a DLC snake scheme as a symmetric foundation and betatron phase tuning for fine corrections, offers the most effective path forward for the EIC and future high-energy polarized beam facilities. I Introduction The scientific program of the future Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) at Brookhaven National Laboratory depends critically on the acceleration of high-intensity, high-polarization hadron beams to energies up to 275 GeV Willeke 2021 ; Berg et al. 2023a . Preserving polarization through acceleration is a formidable challenge: as the beam is ramped, it must cross hundreds of spin-depolarizing resonances Ranjbar et al. 2001 . The standard method of overcoming these resonances in high-energy synchrotrons is the use of Siberian snakes, specialized magnet insertions that rotate the spin by 180° around some axis Derbenev and Kondratenko 1977 ; Derbenev and Kondratenko 1979 ; Courant 1989 ; Wienands 1991 ; Syphers et al. 1997 . These axes are chosen to fix the stable spin precession tune at \nu_{0} = 1/2, which avoids all first-order spin resonances. Nonetheless, the presence of strong first-order resonances of the ring without snakes gives rise to higher-order resonant phenomena after introducing snakes. A high degree of symmetry in the accelerator lattice simplifies the resonance structure without snakes. In contrast to its predecessor, the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC), whose threefold super-periodicity significantly simplifies the resonance structure, the EIC Hadron Storage Ring (HSR) includes complex interaction regions (IRs) that break this symmetry Witte et al. 2021 ; Berg et al. 2023b . The result is the excitation of significantly stronger spin resonances that can severely depolarize the beam. To address these challenges, depolarizing spin kicks from different sections of the ring must be made to cancel, a process we refer to as “snake matching” Hoffstaetter 2004 ; Hoffstaetter 2006 . This paper systematically explores two complementary strategies for optimizing polarization transmission in the HSR. The first approach (Method I) manipulates the orbital dynamics by optimizing the vertical betatron phase advance \phi_{y} between snakes. By tuning the orbital phase, the depolarizing effects of different lattice sections can be made to cancel, effectively establishing a snake-matched condition across a given energy range. This approach leaves the snake configuration fixed and leverages lattice optics to suppress resonance driving terms. The second, more powerful approach (Method II) manipulates the spin dynamics directly by varying the snake rotation axes. For a ring with 2N snakes, the single constraint of \nu_{0}=\frac{1}{2} leaves a 2N-1 dimensional parameter space of possible snake-axis configurations. Within this space, additional symmetry constraints yield systematically stronger polarization preservation. We revisit the known Lee-Courant schemes Vogt et al. 2000 , which impose N constraints to achieve local spin phase advances of \pi , and show that these outperform generic configurations. Building on this, we introduce and analyze a novel, more restrictive arrangement we term the “Doubly Lee-Courant” (DLC) scheme. This highly symmetric configuration imposes 2N-1 constraints, leaving only a single degree of freedom, and enforces a \pi spin phase advance across every consecutive pair of snakes. To our knowledge, this is the first systematic investigation of the DLC class, which we find provides an exceptionally robust baseline for suppressing depolarization. We present a comprehensive comparative analysis of these two methods for the EIC HSR. With Method I, using non-perturbative, spin-orbit simulations that compute the amplitude-dependent spin tune, we demonstrate that optimized betatron-phase schemes can successfully navigate the beam while ramping through the strongest resonant regions in realistic lattice models. We then show with Method II that snake-axis optimization, particularly under the DLC principle, provides an even more powerful route. Finally, we assess the practical trade-offs between the two approaches, considering both optics control and hardware constraints, and conclude that the symmetry principles uncovered in our snake-axis study offer a flexible and powerful new toolkit for the design of future high-energy polarized-beam facilities. II Theoretical Framework and Methodology II.1 Spin Dynamics in Accelerator Lattices II.1.1 The Thomas-BMT Equation The motion of a particle’s spin vector, \mathbf{S} , in an external electromagnetic field is described by the Thomas-Bargmann-Michel-Telegdi (T-BMT) equation Bargmann et al. 1959 . This equation can be derived semiclassically by considering the Larmor precession in the particle’s rest frame and applying the requisite Lorentz boosts to the laboratory frame, which correctly incorporates the relativistic effect of Thomas precession. Alternatively, it can be obtained as a semiclassical expansion in \hbar of the Dirac equation through a Foldy-Wouthuysen transformation (unlike the usual non-relativistic expansion seen in textbooks) Conte et al. 1996 ; Heinemann and Barber 1998 . In the lab frame, for a particle with charge q , mass m , and momentum \mathbf{p}=\gamma m\mathbf{v} , the spin precesses according to \frac{d\mathbf{S}}{dt}=\boldsymbol{\Omega}_{\mathrm{BMT}}\times\mathbf{S} , where the precession vector is given by: \boldsymbol{\Omega}_{\mathrm{BMT}}=-\frac{q}{\gamma m}\left[(G\gamma+1)\mathbf{B}_{\perp}+(G+1)\mathbf{B}_{\parallel}\right.\\ \left.-\frac{G\gamma^{2}}{\gamma+1}\frac{\mathbf{v}}{c^{2}}(\mathbf{v}\cdot\mathbf{B})-\left(G\gamma+\frac{\gamma}{\gamma+1}\right)\frac{\mathbf{v}}{c^{2}}\times\mathbf{E}\right], (1) where G=(g-2)/2 is the gyromagnetic anomaly, and \mathbf{B}_{\perp} and \mathbf{B}_{\parallel} are the magnetic field components perpendicular and parallel to the particle’s velocity, respectively. In a modern high-energy synchrotron like the EIC Hadron Storage Ring (HSR), the particle motion is ultra-relativistic ( \gamma\gg 1 ) and the lattice is composed primarily of transverse magnetic fields for bending and focusing. The electric fields are localized to RF cavities and are longitudinal, and solenoidal fields are generally not used for high-energy hadron beams. Under these conditions and the paraxial approximation, the T-BMT equation simplifies considerably. Transforming to a co-moving coordinate frame that follows the particle’s trajectory s(t) , the equation of motion becomes \frac{d\mathbf{S}}{ds}=\boldsymbol{\Omega}(s)\times\mathbf{S} , with the precession vector dominated by the magnetic fields perpendicular to the design orbit: \boldsymbol{\Omega}(s)\approx-\frac{q}{\gamma m\mathbf{v}}\left[(G\gamma+1)\mathbf{B}_{\perp}\right]=-\frac{q}{p}\left[(G\gamma+1)\mathbf{B}_{\perp}\right]. (2) The term G\gamma represents the number of additional spin precessions relative to the momentum vector per turn. On the design closed orbit of a perfectly flat ring with only vertical dipole fields B_{y} , the precession is purely vertical. The rate of this precession relative to a revolution defines the closed-orbit spin tune , \nu_{0} : \nu_{0}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\oint\frac{qG\gamma B_{y}}{p}ds=G\gamma. (3) Associated with this tune is a periodic, stable spin direction on the closed orbit, known as the invariant spin field on the closed orbit, \mathbf{n}_{0}(s) . In an ideal flat ring, \mathbf{n}_{0} is