The Metallicity Dependence of PAH Emission in Galaxies II: Insights from JWST/NIRCam Imaging of the Smallest Dust Grains in M101
Cory M. Whitcomb, J.-D. T. Smith, Elizabeth Tarantino, Karin Sandstrom, Thomas S.-Y. Lai(賴劭愉), Lee Armus, Alberto Bolatto, Martha Boyer, Daniel A. Dale, Bruce T. Draine, Brandon S. Hensley, Desika Narayanan, Julia Roman-Duval, Evan D. Skillman · 2025
Read The Metallicity Dependence of PAH Emission in Galaxies II: Insights from JWST/NIRCam Imaging of the Smallest Dust Grains in M101 by Cory M. Whitcomb, J.-D. T. Smith, Elizabeth Tarantino, Karin Sandstrom, Thomas S.-Y. Lai(賴劭愉), Lee Armus, Alberto Bolatto, Martha Boyer, Daniel A. Dale, Bruce T. Draine, Brandon S. Hensley, Desika Narayanan, Julia Roman-Duval, Evan D. Skillman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-18347.txt.
Introduction
Small carbon-rich dust grains called PAHs glow in many galaxies, but they grow scarce where heavy elements are rare. Cory M. Whitcomb and 13 co-authors study that drop with new space telescope images. Their 2025 paper uses JWST camera maps of M101, a nearby spiral galaxy. The maps cover zones from Sun-like makeup down to about two-fifths of it.
The team tracked the shortest PAH glow, which comes from the smallest grains. Its share of all PAH light tripled as the heavy element share fell, rising from about one percent to about three percent. That trend matches a model where grain growth is held back in poor material. Some loss of small grains to harsh light stays possible if the size cutoff stays low. Oddly, the small-grain glow rose against total heat glow even as all PAH output fell. The smallest grains may simply be the toughest.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cory M. Whitcomb, J.-D. T. Smith, Elizabeth Tarantino, Karin Sandstrom, Thomas S.-Y. Lai(賴劭愉), Lee Armus, Alberto Bolatto, Martha Boyer, Daniel A. Dale, Bruce T. Draine, Brandon S. Hensley, Desika Narayanan, Julia Roman-Duval, Evan D. Skillman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-18347
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Metallicity Dependence of PAH Emission in Galaxies II: Insights from JWST/NIRCam Imaging of the Smallest Dust Grains in M101 Cory M. Whitcomb, J.-D. T. Smith, Elizabeth Tarantino, Karin Sandstrom, Thomas S.-Y. Lai(賴劭愉), Lee Armus, Alberto Bolatto, Martha Boyer, Daniel A. Dale, Bruce T. Draine, Brandon S. Hensley, Desika Narayanan, Julia Roman-Duval, Evan D. Skillman Abstract We explore the physical origins of the observed deficit of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) at sub-solar metallicity using JWST/NIRCam imaging of the nearby galaxy M101, covering regions from solar metallicity ( Z ⊙ Z_{\odot} ) down to 0.4 Z ⊙ Z_{\odot} . These maps are used to trace the radial evolution of the shortest-wavelength PAH feature at 3.3 µm, which is emitted preferentially by the smallest PAHs ( < < 100 carbon atoms). The fractional contribution of PAH 3.3 µm to the total PAH luminosity ( Σ \Sigma PAH) increases by 3 × 3\times as metallicity declines, rising from ∼ \sim 1% to ∼ \sim 3% over the observed range, consistent with prior predictions from the inhibited grain growth model based on Spitzer spectroscopy. We explore model refinements including photon effects and alternative size evolution prescriptions, and find that a modest amount of small grain photo-destruction remains possible, provided the grain size cutoff does not exceed ∼ \sim 55 carbon atoms. The best-fit models predict 3.3 µm / / Σ \Sigma PAH will rise to ∼ \sim 5.6 − 7.7 % 5.6-7.7\% at 10% Z ⊙ Z_{\odot} . Surprisingly, even as Σ \Sigma PAH drops significantly relative to the total infrared luminosity (TIR) as metallicity declines, 3.3 µm/TIR alone rises , potentially indicating the mass fraction of the smallest PAH grains increases as the total dust content in galaxies drops. The current model cannot fully reproduce this trend even if the unusually strong effects of changing radiation field hardness on 3.3 µm/TIR are included. This may be evidence that the smallest PAHs are uniquely robust against destruction and inhibited growth effects. These results highlight the pivotal role that short-wavelength PAH emission can play in studies of low-metallicity and high-redshift galaxies. show][email protected] I Introduction The smallest carbonaceous dust grains that can survive in the interstellar medium (ISM) emit a strong vibrational feature at 3.3 µm. These dust grains are commonly believed to be polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) composed of about 20 – 100 carbon atoms ( Tielens 2008 ; Draine et al. 2021 ) . The general population of PAHs extends to molecules composed of \sim 1,000 carbon atoms which are theorized to be responsible for the strong, broad emission features in the 3 – 18 µm spectral range in observations of the ISM of galaxies. The emission from the 3.3 µm PAH feature constitutes about 1 – 3% of all PAH emission power, and about 0.1% of the total infrared luminosity of star-forming galaxies ( Lai et al. 2020 ) . Several studies have found a significant deficit in the luminosity from PAH vibrational features relative to the total dust luminosity at sub-solar metallicity (i.e., the PAH-metallicity relation or PZR, see Whitcomb et al. 2024 , and references therein) . Many of these studies attribute the deficit to a decrease in the fractional abundance of PAHs relative to larger dust grains due to enhanced photo-destruction of smaller PAHs in the harder radiation fields of low-metallicity environments where dust shielding and ISM density are significantly lower ( Madden et al. 2006 ; Gordon et al. 2008 ) . Recent studies have reported MIR emission from PAHs ( Spilker et al. 2023 ; Witstok et al. 2023 ) and UV attenuation by PAHs ( Markov et al. 2025 ; Ormerod et al. 2025 ) in high redshift galaxies. It is crucial that we understand the local relationship between PAHs and metallicity to inform our interpretation of unexpectedly rapid dust formation at these early epochs. The first Paper In this series ( Whitcomb et al. 2024 , Paper I) used Spitzer/Infrared Spectrograph (IRS) spectroscopic maps to study the observed PZR for all PAH bands between 5 and 20 µm in three nearby spiral galaxies: M101, NGC 628, and NGC 2403. We found that, when corrected for the effects of softer radiation fields in the galaxy’s bulge, the ratio of total PAH luminosity ( \Sigma PAH) to total infrared luminosity (TIR) is approximately constant at high metallicity, as seen in previous studies ( Sutter et al. 2024 ) . \Sigma PAH/TIR remains constant until a threshold is reached at Z_{\mathrm{th}} \equiv 0.63 ~\pm~ 0.03 of solar metallicity ( Z_{\odot} ), below which \Sigma PAH/TIR decreases rapidly. By studying the evolution of PAH feature strengths as metallicity decreases, we found a general trend where the total PAH luminosity shifts from longer to shorter wavelength features. To test potential explanations for the observed band-resolved PZR, we built on the latest dust grain models from Draine et al. 2021 that depend on grain size and the illuminating radiation field. The leading model from Paper I (W24 model) shifts average PAH sizes smaller and decreases the overall number of PAH grains as metallicity decreases. This behavior can be interpreted as a result of metallicity-dependent inhibited grain growth. In this scenario, PAH grains are theorized to grow through the accretion of carbon atoms and other PAH precursors in the dense ISM ( Zhang et al. 2025b ) , but this process is increasingly inhibited as the gas-phase metallicity decreases ( Zhukovska & Henning 2013 ) . The W24 model predicts that the shortest-wavelength major PAH feature at 3.3 µm, which was inaccessible with Spitzer spectroscopy, would vary most strongly with metallicity, increasing in fractional strength relative to all PAH power (PAH 3.3/ \Sigma PAH) by more than a factor of three between Z_{\odot} and 0.4 Z_{\odot} . In this paper, the second in the series, we combine new JWST/NIRCam imaging of the 3.3 µm PAH feature with the Spitzer-IRS spectroscopy from Paper I in a deep radial strip across the nearby star-forming galaxy M101, covering metallicities from Z_{\odot} to 0.4 Z_{\odot} . With these data, we can study co-spatial variations in all major PAH features as a function of metallicity at physical scales of \sim 350 pc. Including the 3.3 µm feature allows us to trace the abundance of the smallest PAH grains in galaxies and place new constraints on the inhibited growth PZR model. We find that, as predicted in Paper I, PAH 3.3 µm/ \Sigma PAH increases substantially as Z/Z_{\odot} varies from 1 to 0.4. Figure 1: Top: PAH 3.3 µm emission isolated from F335M with the method adopted in this work (see § III ). Note the apparent ‘cliff’ at the right of the image where galaxy structure seems to end abruptly (see § IV.2 ). Bottom: three-color image with PAH 3.3 µm in red, F360M+PAH 3.3 µm in green, and F300M in blue. Apertures defined in Paper I are indicated in green, the apertures used to study the cliff are shown in cyan, and the off-galaxy aperture discussed in § II.3 is shown in magenta. This Paper Is organized as follows. In § II we describe our JWST/NIRCam data reduction and analysis process. In § III we describe the methods used to isolate PAH 3.3 µm emission in the