Kinematics of synthetically observed high- z z rotating disks: reliability and biases of 3D fitting tools 2026 Kinematics of synthetically observed high- z z rotating disks: reliability and biases of 3D fitting tools – 11
M. Yttergren, K. K. Knudsen, J. Molina, G. C. Jones, K. Kade, J. Scholtz, A. Bewketu Belete · 2025
Read Kinematics of synthetically observed high- z z rotating disks: reliability and biases of 3D fitting tools 2026 Kinematics of synthetically observed high- z z rotating disks: reliability and biases of 3D fitting tools – 11 by M. Yttergren, K. K. Knudsen, J. Molina, G. C. Jones, K. Kade, J. Scholtz, A. Bewketu Belete (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-18328.txt.
Introduction
Distant galaxies are hard to read: their gas motion shows up blurred and faint. M. Yttergren and six co-authors test how well three software tools recover that motion. Their 2025 paper builds fake galaxies that spin like disks, then makes fake telescope data from them. The fake data mimics what the ALMA telescope would record.
The tools, 3DBarolo, GalPaK3D, and Qubefit, each fit a 3D model to the fake data. On average all three were sound for group studies, with small over- or under-estimates of how cold and orderly the spin is. For single galaxies, though, the range of answers was wide. That range grows for galaxies that are not clean spinners. The authors urge readers to use their listed offsets and ranges when reading real distant galaxies. They also note a quick check that can be pulled from the data cube itself.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Yttergren, K. K. Knudsen, J. Molina, G. C. Jones, K. Kade, J. Scholtz, A. Bewketu Belete |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-18328
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Kinematics of synthetically observed high- z z rotating disks: reliability and biases of 3D fitting tools 2026 Kinematics of synthetically observed high- z z rotating disks: reliability and biases of 3D fitting tools – 11 M. Yttergren, K. K. Knudsen, J. Molina, G. C. Jones, K. Kade, J. Scholtz, A. Bewketu Belete Abstract Resolved high-redshift galaxy gas kinematics is a rapidly evolving field driven by increasingly powerful instrumentation. However, the resolution and sensitivity still impose constraints on interpretation. We investigate the uncertainties inherent to high- z z galaxy kinematical analysis by modelling a suite of rotating disk galaxies, generating synthetic interferometric ALMA observations, and fitting them with the 3D-kinematical tools 3D {}^{\text{3D}} Barolo , GalPaK 3D {}^{\text{3D}} , and qubefit . We present the recovered 3D-fitted kinematical parameters to assess their reliability, quantify the range of values possible for individual source studies, and establish the systematic biases present for observed samples. The V / σ V V/\sigma_{\rm V} ratio, which indicates how dynamically cold a system is, is of particular importance and depends on the choice of 3D-fitting tool. On average, 3D {}^{\text{3D}} Barolo and qubefit slightly overestimates V / σ V V/\sigma_{\rm V} ( < 1 σ <1\sigma ) and GalPaK 3D {}^{\text{3D}} underestimates it ( < 2 σ <2\sigma ). Therefore, all three tools are reliable for kinematical studies of averages of high-redshift galaxy samples. The value range possible for individual sources is significant, however, even more so for samples of not purely rotation dominated sources. To determine whether an observed galaxy is rotation dominated enough to be fitted with a 3D-kinematical tool, V / σ V V/\sigma_{\rm V} can be extracted directly from the observed data cube, with some caveats. We recommend that the median offsets, value ranges, and tool-dependent biases presented in this paper are taken into account when interpreting 3D-fitted kinematics of observed high-redshift galaxies. 1 Introduction The widespread presence of disk-like galaxies at z\approx 1-3 is considered a key probe of internal mechanisms regulating the life cycle of star-forming galaxies and their evolution across cosmic time ( Förster Schreiber & Wuyts 2020 ) . About half of the current stellar mass observed in galaxies today was formed during an epoch when these systems appeared clumpy and irregular in the restframe UV and optical ( Swinbank et al. 2012 ; Conselice 2014 ) , but their kinematics and global light distribution were largely regular ( Wuyts et al. 2011 ; van der Wel et al. 2014 ; Wisnioski et al. 2019 , e.g.) . Smooth modes of gas accretion, star formation, and outflows set conditions for equilibrium growth that controlled the stellar mass build-up of galaxies ( Genzel et al. 2006 ; Dekel et al. 2009 , e.g.) . Surveys spatially resolving galaxy spectra using integral field units (IFUs) have been pivotal in establishing this picture ( Förster Schreiber et al. 2009 ; Swinbank et al. 2012 ; Wisnioski et al. 2015 ; Stott et al. 2016 ; Turner et al. 2017 ; Förster Schreiber et al. 2018a , e.g.) , and complementary interferometric observations unveiling the cold molecular interstellar medium (ISM) gas phase at high redshift have provided further supporting evidence ( Genzel et al. 2013 ; Molina et al. 2019 ; Übler et al. 2018 ; Genzel et al. 2023 ; Rizzo et al. 2023 , e.g.) . Surprisingly, recent reports suggest a high prevalence of dynamically cold rotating disks at even higher redshifts, where the dynamical ”coldness” of a system is derived from the V_{\rm rot}/\sigma_{\rm V} ratio of gas tracers such as H \alpha and [C ii ] ( Rizzo et al. 2020 ; Rizzo et al. 2021 ; Pope et al. 2023 ; Kohandel et al. 2024 ; Rowland et al. 2024 ; Scholtz et al. 2025a ) . These observations have been further corroborated by James Webb Space Telescope ( JWST ) imaging analysis ( Robertson et al. 2023 ) , suggesting that galaxies were building their stellar mass in a quasi-equilibrium state ( Krumholz & Burkert 2010 , e.g.) even at earlier epochs. However, JWST observations also show the presence of companion galaxies and pre-coalescence mergers ( Jones et al. 2024 ; Scholtz et al. 2025b ; Lamperti et al. 2024 , e.g.) , raising doubts about the accuracy of the tools currently used for identifying and characterizing galaxy disks from three-dimensional datasets. For example, Simons et al. 2019 concluded from synthetic IFU observations at z\approx 2 that for close-pair mergers the risk of classifying a merger as a disk can be as high as 100% depending on the specific disk classification criterion adopted (and weakly dependent on the separation of the merging galaxies). Rizzo et al. 2022 showed that distinguishing between a rotating disk and a merger, and correctly classifying them with the current data quality and methods, is impossible for all but the highest data quality, achievable only for a small sample of the brightest galaxies. Unfortunately, the limited sensitivity and resolution of current observations present challenges in characterizing the morphology and kinematics of the ISM in high-redshift galaxies. The current tools used to classify and characterize the gas kinematics of high-redshift galaxies are far from flawless. These tools face a difficult task: modelling galaxy data with the relatively large point spread function (PSF) or synthesised beam size, which smooths out and circularizes any galaxy structure. The observed rotation velocity fields also appear more regular than they actually are, and the velocity dispersion is artificially increased due to the broadening of the emission lines by unresolved velocity gradients, plus the finite spectral resolution of the instrument (see Glazebrook 2013 , for a review). In some cases, due to the smoothing, even merging systems can be classified as disk-like galaxies ( Smit et al. 2018 ; Simons et al. 2019 ; Rizzo et al. 2022 ) . The tools developed for analysing the ”2D” kinematic fields correct for ”beam-smearing” and instrument spectral broadening effects ( Swinbank et al. 2012 ; Wisnioski et al. 2015 ; Stott et al. 2016 ; Levy et al. 2018 , e.g.) . However, since the convolution with the PSF or synthesized beam is flux-weighted, it affects data cubes as a whole, implying that a more appropriate solution to account for these effects is to model the datasets in three dimensions. Over the last decade, several “3D” galaxy kinematics modelling tools have been developed to overcome these challenges and fully exploit the data cubes delivered by IFUs and radio interferometers (e.g., the Atacama Large Millimetre/sub-millimetre Array–ALMA). Many of these “3D-kinematical tools” are publicly available, and a non-exhaustive list includes TiRiFiC ( Józsa et al. 2007 ) , KinMS ( Davis et al. 2013 ; Davis et al. 2017 ) , {}^{\text{3D}} Barolo ( Di Teodoro & Fraternali 2015 ; Di Teodoro & Peek 2021 ) , GalPaK {}^{\text{3D}} ( Bouché et al. 2015a ; Bouché et al. 2015b ) , qubefit ( Neeleman et al. 2020 ; Neeleman et al. 2021 ) , and DysmalPy ( Davies et al. 2011 ; Davis et al. 2013 ; Price et al. 2021 ; Lee et al. 2025 ) . The major difference among these tools lies in the adopted approach to model the