Waves drive the rise and fall of 2D flows in rotating turbulence

Sébastien Gomé, Anna Frishman · 2025

Read Waves drive the rise and fall of 2D flows in rotating turbulence by Sébastien Gomé, Anna Frishman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-18323.txt.

Introduction

Spinning fluids behave in odd ways: small swirls can merge into flows as wide as their container. Sébastien Gomé and Anna Frishman study that dance in rotating turbulence in this 2025 paper. Three-dimensional waves and flat, wide flows grow side by side in such systems. The puzzle is why the flat flows survive when only 3D waves are fed energy.

The pair built a wave-kinetic theory, a math frame for how waves trade energy. They show that near-resonant wave hits force a new rule: waves keep a trait called helicity split by sign. That rule pushes wave energy into the wide flat flows and holds them steady. Their formulas predict the energy flow from spin rate, turbulence strength, and box shape. Computer runs of the flow equations matched the theory well. As spin rises, the transfer fades and the flow flips to wave-led turbulence.

Catalog record

CREATORSébastien Gomé, Anna Frishman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE143 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-18323

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Waves drive the rise and fall of 2D flows in rotating turbulence Preprint: APS/123-QED Sébastien Gomé, Anna Frishman Abstract Turbulence follows a few well-known organizational principles, rooted in conservation laws. One such principle states that a system conserving two sign-definite invariants self-organizes into large-scale structures. Ordinary three-dimensional turbulence does not fall within this paradigm. However, when subject to rotation, 3D turbulence is profoundly altered: rotation produces 3D inertial waves, while also sustaining emergent two-dimensional structures and favoring domain-scale flows called condensates. This interplay raises a fundamental question: why and when are 2D flows sustained even when only 3D waves are excited? Using extensive numerical simulations of the rotating 3D Navier–Stokes equations together with a quasi-linear wave–kinetic theory, we show that near-resonant interactions between 3D waves and a large-scale 2D flow impose an additional conservation law: inertial waves must conserve their helicity separately for each helicity sign. This emergent sign-definite invariant constrains the waves to transfer their energy to large-scale 2D motions. However, as rotation increases, resonance conditions become more restrictive and the energy transfer from 3D to 2D progressively vanishes, leading to a transition from condensate-dominated turbulence to pure inertial-wave turbulence for the 3D modes. We derive analytical expressions for this 3D–2D energy transfer as a function of rotation, Reynolds number and domain geometry, and verify them numerically. Together, these results establish a mechanism underlying two-dimensionalization in rotating turbulence, and, more broadly, illustrate how wave–mean flow interactions can drive large-scale self-organization. Rotating turbulent flows abound in nature, from industrial to geophysical and even astrophysical flows. Yet, they remain challenging to understand, as they exhibit signatures of two-dimensional, three-dimensional and wave turbulence. A guiding principle for understanding turbulence is that out-of-equilibrium fluxes arise through inviscid conservation laws, determining how the various degrees of freedom interact. A remarkable manifestation is provided by systems which conserve two sign-definite, scale-related, quantities, causing turbulence to self-organize into large-scale structures. The archetype system following this principle is the two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations (2DNSE), in which both energy and enstrophy (the vorticity squared) are conserved and flow in opposite directions: energy cascades upscale and enstrophy downscale ( Fjørtoft 1953 ; Kraichnan 1967 ) . In a finite domain and with low dissipation, energy is ultimately concentrated on the lowest modes and forms a condensate: a strong large-scale coherent flow fueled by small-scale eddies. Three-dimensional fluids, in contrast, conserve energy and sign-indefinite helicity (the scalar product between velocity and vorticity ( Moffatt 1969 ) ) and are organized very differently: both energy and helicity are transferred to small scales ( Chen et al. 2003 ; Ditlevsen and Giuliani 2001 ) . However, when a 3D fluid is rotated, its phenomenology fundamentally changes, while its invariants remain the same. Rotation produces 3D inertial waves ( Yarom et al. 2013 ) , each with an energy and a helicity of a given sign, while also tending to homogenize the flow along the rotation axis, generating two-dimensional motions ( Godeferd and Moisy 2015 ) . Once energized, 2D modes seem to exhibit an inverse energy cascade, similarly to 2DNSE, which progressively generates larger-scale flows ( Smith et al. 1996 ; Smith and Waleffe 1999 ; Smith and Lee 2005 ; Chen et al. 2005 ; Mininni and Pouquet 2010 ; Yarom et al. 2013 ; Deusebio et al. 2014 ; Campagne et al. 2015 ; Biferale et al. 2016 ; Buzzicotti et al. 2018a ; Alexakis and Biferale 2018 ; van Kan and Alexakis 2020 ; Lam et al. 2023 ; Shaltiel et al. 2024 ) . With low dissipation, this leads to the generation of large-scale condensates in these rotating 3D flows ( Kolvin et al. 2009 ; Rubio et al. 2014 ; Guervilly et al. 2014 ; Le Reun et al. 2017 ; Di Leoni et al. 2020 ; Aguirre Guzmán et al. 2020 ; Kolokolov et al. 2020 ; de Wit et al. 2022 ; Shaltiel et al. 2024 ) . How and why two-dimensionalization occurs in rotating turbulence remains unsettled. Generally, for strong rotation, nonlinear interactions should be restricted to resonances, but such 3D-2D interactions have a strictly vanishing coupling ( Waleffe 1992 ; Cambon et al. 1997 ; Bordes et al. 2012 ) . This causes 3D and 2D modes to decouple in the limit of infinite rotation, as established mathematically in ( Babin et al. 1997 ; Babin et al. 1999 ) , which stabilizes 2D motions when those are directly excited ( Gallet 2015 ; Billant 2021 ) . However, most experiments and numerical simulations do not reach this asymptotic limit, and energy is observed to be transferred from 3D to 2D modes ( Smith et al. 1996 ; Smith and Waleffe 1999 ; Smith and Lee 2005 ; Chen et al. 2005 ; Bourouiba and Bartello 2007 ; Mininni and Pouquet 2010 ; Yarom et al. 2013 ; Deusebio et al. 2014 ; Campagne et al. 2015 ; Biferale et al. 2016 ; Buzzicotti et al. 2018a ; Le Reun et al. 2017 ; Alexakis and Biferale 2018 ; van Kan and Alexakis 2020 ; Lam et al. 2023 ; Shaltiel et al. 2024 ) . This possibly occurs via near-resonant triads ( Waleffe 1992 ; Smith and Waleffe 1999 ; Smith and Lee 2005 ; Alexakis 2015 ; di Leoni and Mininni 2016 ; Le Reun et al. 2020 ) or four-wave interactions ( Brunet et al. 2020 ) , but it is unclear why energy is transferred directionally from 3D to 2D. To date, no mechanism for such a transfer based on the flow’s global inviscid invariants has been established. Here we focus on two-dimensional condensates in rotating 3D turbulence, and identify such a mechanism in this context. Large-scale steady condensates alter the nature of turbulence. They favor non-locality and a different hierarchy of correlations. Contrary to homogeneous and isotropic turbulence, the dynamics is dominated by mean-flow-turbulence interactions. Quasi-Linear (QL) theory (inherited from Rapid Distortion Theory ( Batchelor and Proudman 1954 ) ) provides a self-consistent perturbative statistical framework for this kind of inhomogeneous turbulence ( Marston and Tobias 2023 ) . It has led to analytical predictions of both mean-flow profiles and turbulent correlations in 2DNSE ( Laurie et al. 2014 ; Kolokolov and Lebedev 2016 ; Frishman 2017 ; Frishman and Herbert 2018 ; Doludenko et al. 2021 ) , and has also been applied to 2D geophysical and plasma systems ( Diamond et al. 2005 ; Srinivasan and Young 2012 ; Parker and Krommes 2013 ; Marston et al. 2016 ; Woillez and Bouchet 2017 ; Svirsky et al. 2023 ) We investigate the formation of condensates in rotating 3D turbulence using direct numerical simulations (§ I ) and a quasi-linear wave–kinetic theory (§ II & III ). We show that near-resonant interactions enforce a conservation of helicity by sign, causing inertial waves to energize the large-scale 2D flow (§ IV ). As rotation increases, resonances become increasingly stringent and the coupling vanishes, marking the transition from a condensate-dominated turbulence to an asymptotic turbulence of inertial waves for the 3D modes. We derive scaling predictions for the 3D–2D energy transfer and confirm them numerically, thereby explaining the origin and evolution of two-dimensionalization (§ V ). I Numerical set-up and

Read the complete text