Echoes from the Dark: Galaxy Catalog Incompleteness in Standard Siren Cosmology
Nicola Borghi, Michele Moresco, Matteo Tagliazucchi, Giulia Cuomo · 2025
Read Echoes from the Dark: Galaxy Catalog Incompleteness in Standard Siren Cosmology by Nicola Borghi, Michele Moresco, Matteo Tagliazucchi, Giulia Cuomo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-18243.txt.
Introduction
Nicola Borghi and 3 co-authors study how missing galaxies in a catalogue weaken cosmic sums from wave events. Their 2025 paper deals with standard sirens, where a gravity wave plus its host galaxy pins the expansion rate. Real catalogues miss hosts, since faint galaxies escape our surveys.
Their open pipe, CHIMERA, keeps the host-weight logic firm as completeness varies. A hundred fake wave events in a next-run setup give tight rates when catalogues are full. As completeness drops, precision slides in an S-shaped way. Mass-based host weights sharpen both the best case and the slide. A fair rate stays in reach with part-full lists.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nicola Borghi, Michele Moresco, Matteo Tagliazucchi, Giulia Cuomo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-18243
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Echoes from the Dark: Galaxy Catalog Incompleteness in Standard Siren Cosmology Nicola Borghi, Michele Moresco, Matteo Tagliazucchi, Giulia Cuomo Abstract Gravitational wave observations can be combined with galaxy catalogs to constrain cosmology and test modified gravity theories using the standard siren method. However, galaxy catalogs are intrinsically incomplete due to observational limitations, potentially leaving host galaxies undetected and thereby weakening constraints or potentially introducing systematic errors. In this work, we present a self-consistent framework to study catalog incompleteness and host weighting effects, implemented in the publicly available CHIMERA pipeline. We obtain joint cosmological and astrophysical population constraints from 100 binary black hole (BBH) events in a LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA O5-like configuration, using spectroscopic galaxy catalogs with varying completeness levels and stellar-mass host weighting schemes. We find percent-level constraints on H 0 H_{0} with complete catalogs, reaching precision of 1.6 % 1.6\% , 1.3 % 1.3\% , and 0.9 % 0.9\% for constant, linear, and quadratic mass weighting, respectively. As completeness decreases, the precision degrades following a sigmoid trend, with a threshold and steepness that increase for stronger weightings. Simultaneously, the correlation between H 0 H_{0} and the BBH population mass scale also increases, making results more sensitive to assumptions about the astrophysical population. Remarkably, 2 % 2\% precision remains achievable when catalogs contain only 50 % 50\% of the potential host galaxies within the gravitational wave detection horizon, while 1 % 1\% precision requires host probabilities scaling with stellar mass squared. The results are robust against host weighting mismodeling, even at moderate completeness levels. This work further highlights the importance of spectroscopic galaxy surveys in standard siren cosmology and provides a pathway for developing the science case of future facilities. 1 Introduction Gravitational waves (GWs) from compact binary coalescences (CBCs) are maturing as a robust observational probe to constrain cosmology and fundamental physics, offering a new perspective on existing cosmological tensions ( Verde et al. 2019 ; Moresco et al. 2022 ; Di Valentino et al. 2025 ) . Because GWs carry direct information on the CBC luminosity distance, they can be used as standard distance indicators or standard sirens ( Schutz 1986 ; Holz & Hughes 2005 ) . With the additional source redshift information, it is then possible to constrain cosmology via the luminosity distance-redshift relation. However, the source redshift cannot be obtained directly from current GW data, as it is degenerate with the source masses. When an electromagnetic counterpart is identified and the host galaxy redshift is measured, a bright siren measurement becomes possible. To date, the only confirmed bright siren is GW170817 ( Abbott et al. 2017b ) , resulting in a Hubble constant measurement at 15\,\% precision ( Abbott et al. 2017a ) . The latest release of the Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog 4 (GWTC-4.0) by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) Collaboration contains 219 confident CBC detections, the majority of which are binary black holes (BBHs) without electromagnetic counterparts ( Abbott et al. 2019 ; Abbott et al. 2021 ; Abbott et al. 2023a ; Abbott et al. 2025c ) . It is therefore essential to develop methods to extract the cosmological information without relying on counterpart detection. These dark siren methods include two main complementary approaches. The first consists in statistically inferring the redshift from catalogs of potential host galaxies within the gravitational wave localization volume ( Schutz 1986 ; Del Pozzo 2012 ; Chen et al. 2018 ; Fishbach et al. 2019 ; Gray et al. 2020 ; Palmese et al. 2020 ; Finke et al. 2021 ; Gair et al. 2023 ) . The second consists in breaking the mass-redshift degeneracy by modeling intrinsic astrophysical properties. This is possible with spectral sirens , sources whose source-frame mass distribution contains features such as peaks, gaps, or changes in slope ( Chernoff & Finn 1993 ; Taylor et al. 2012 ; Farr et al. 2019 ; Mastrogiovanni et al. 2021 ; Mancarella et al. 2022 ; Ezquiaga & Holz 2022 ; Mali & Essick 2025 ) . Additional approaches rely on the cross-correlation between the spatial distribution of GWs and galaxies ( Oguri 2016 ; Mukherjee et al. 2021 ; Ferri et al. 2025 ; Pedrotti et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . Recent standard siren analyses ( Mastrogiovanni et al. 2023 ; Gray et al. 2023 ) , including the latest GWTC-4.0 cosmology analysis ( Abbott et al. 2025a ) , have advanced beyond treating catalog and spectral siren methods as independent. Instead, they are jointly combined within a hierarchical Bayesian framework, making it possible to robustly marginalize over the uncertainties of the astrophysical and cosmological parameters simultaneously. Several pipelines are publicly available, including gwcosmo ( Gray et al. 2020 ; Gray et al. 2023 ) , icarogw ( Mastrogiovanni et al. 2023 ; Mastrogiovanni et al. 2024 ) , and CHIMERA ( Borghi et al. 2024 ; Tagliazucchi et al. 2025 ) . For further details on the application of GWs to cosmology, see, for example, Palmese & Mastrogiovanni 2025 ; Pierra & Mastrogiovanni 2025 . While galaxy catalogs provide valuable information, they are intrinsically limited by observational effects that can cause host galaxies to be missed, potentially weakening cosmological constraints ( Gray et al. 2020 ; Cross-Parkin et al. 2025 , e.g.,) and introducing systematic errors ( Perna et al. 2024 ; Hanselman et al. 2025 ; Alfradique et al. 2025 ) . This incompleteness directly relates to assumptions about the CBC host galaxy population, as GW sources may preferentially reside in certain types of galaxies that are more easily detected and thus better represented in surveys. The link between CBCs and their host galaxies has been increasingly investigated through population synthesis studies ( Artale et al. 2020 ; Santoliquido et al. 2022 , e.g.,) and observational analyses ( Vijaykumar et al. 2024 ) , although more BBH events are needed to establish robust observational constraints. As GW data quality improves, accounting for galaxy catalog incompleteness and weighting will become increasingly important. Extending current mock data analyses to model these effects and test for potential systematic errors in future standard siren measurements is a necessary step forward. In Borghi et al. 2024 , we provided standard siren forecasts for 100 BBHs in LVK O4- and O5-like configurations. We included a complete galaxy catalog with host galaxies having a stellar mass higher than \log_{10}(M_{\star}/M_{\odot})>10.5 , obtaining percent-level constraints on H_{0} in the case of a galaxy catalog with spectroscopic redshift measurements. A natural extension would be to include all galaxies regardless of stellar mass. However, this approach would implicitly assume that low-mass galaxies with \log_{10}(M_{\star}/M_{\odot})\approx 6 have the same probability of hosting BBH mergers as massive \log_{10}(M_{\star}/M_{\odot})\approx 12 galaxies. This strong assumption, which extends the BBH hosting probability over several orders of magnitude, requires taking into account observational effects in galaxy surveys. In this paper, we present a self-consistent framework to study the effects of galaxy catalog incompleteness and host weighting in standard siren analyses and provide updated and more realistic forecasts. This framework can be readily applied to ongoing and upcoming surveys such as Euclid ( Euclid Collaboration et al. 2025 ) and DESI ( DESI Collaboration et al. 2024 ) , to inform the science case of future missions such as WST ( Mainieri et al.