Large language models surpass domain-specific architectures for antepartum electronic fetal monitoring analysis
Sheng Wong, Ravi Shankar, Beth Albert, Gabriel Davis Jones · 2025
Read Large language models surpass domain-specific architectures for antepartum electronic fetal monitoring analysis by Sheng Wong, Ravi Shankar, Beth Albert, Gabriel Davis Jones (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-18112.txt.
Introduction
Sheng Wong and 3 co-authors bench many model types at reading fetal heart traces before birth. Their 2025 study is the first broad test of its kind for this task. Past work used tailor-made models for the traces, with few checks against broad modern models.
Thousands of short traces feed more than fifteen models, from niche to language based. Tuned language models won most rounds across data levels. When a key womb signal was missing, niche models held up better. The wins cost far more compute, the team notes. Real use must weigh score gains against that run cost.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sheng Wong, Ravi Shankar, Beth Albert, Gabriel Davis Jones |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-18112
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Large language models surpass domain-specific architectures for antepartum electronic fetal monitoring analysis Sheng Wong, Ravi Shankar, Beth Albert, Gabriel Davis Jones Abstract Foundation models (FMs) and large language models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable capabilities across diverse domains through training on massive datasets. These models have demonstrated exceptional performance in healthcare applications, yet their potential for electronic fetal monitoring (EFM)/cardiotocography (CTG) analysis, a critical technology for evaluating fetal well-being, remains largely underexplored. Antepartum CTG interpretation presents unique challenges due to the complex nature of fetal heart rate (FHR) patterns and uterine activity, requiring sophisticated analysis of long time-series data. The assessment of CTG is heavily based on subjective clinical interpretation, often leading to variability in diagnostic accuracy and deviation from timely pregnancy care. This study presents the first comprehensive comparison of state-of-the-art AI approaches for automated antepartum CTG analysis. We systematically compare time-series FMs and LLMs against established CTG-specific architectures. Our evaluation encompasses over 500 CTG recordings of varying durations reflecting real-world clinical recordings, providing robust performance benchmarks across different modelling paradigms. Our results demonstrate that fine-tuned LLMs achieve superior performance compared to both foundation models and domain-specific approaches, offering a promising alternative pathway for clinical CTG interpretation. These findings provide critical insights into the relative strengths of different AI methodologies for fetal monitoring applications and establish a foundation for future clinical AI development in prenatal care. Keywords Electronic fetal monitoring \cdot Cardiotocography \cdot Obstetrics \cdot Time-Series Classification \cdot Large Language Models \cdot Foundation Models 1 Introduction The development of large language models (LLMs) and foundation models (FMs) has demonstrated unprecedented performance across multiple domains, achieving capabilities that were previously thought impossible awais2025foundation ; naveed2025comprehensive . These models, trained on billions of parameters and vast corpora of data, have demonstrated impressive capabilities in various tasks, including natural language understanding, computer vision, and time-series forecasting liang2024foundation ; naveed2025comprehensive . The primary advantage of these models lies in their ability to learn dense, generalizable representations of real-world phenomena, enabling effective adaptation to multiple downstream tasks through human-interpretable instructions. The healthcare sector has emerged as a particularly compelling application domain for these systems, with models demonstrating proficiency in diagnostic reasoning, medical question answering, and medical imaging analysis garcia2024medical ; shool2025systematic ; panagoulias2024evaluating ; bachmann2024exploring ; penny2025reducing . Despite significant advances, the application of foundation models and LLMs to cardiotocography (CTG) analysis remains largely unexplored. CTG monitoring remains an integral part of antepartum care, providing clinicians with continuous assessment of fetal well-being through simultaneous recording of fetal heart rate (FHR), and uterine activity (UA) with a tocodynamometer (toco) cohen2012accuracy . The interpretation of CTG recordings requires in-depth analysis of complex temporal patterns, including baseline heart rate variability, accelerations, decelerations, and their relationship to uterine activity. These recordings can range from ten minutes to several hours in duration, exhibiting substantially different patterns across these temporal scales. Current CTG interpretation relies predominantly on visual assessment by trained medical professionals following established clinical guidelines. However, this approach of manual CTG review is inherently subjective and time-consuming, with significant inter-observer variability documented in CTG interpretations gagnon1993comparison ; rei2016interobserver ; hernandez2023reliability ; tolladay2025comparing . These challenges make this domain particularly suitable for the application of AI approaches. Nevertheless, most existing automated CTG analysis algorithms employ traditional machine learning (ML) methods or domain-specific neural network architectures designed specifically for this application khan2025patchctg ; wong2025cleanctg ; chen2021intelligent ; chiou2025development . While these approaches have shown promise, they have not leveraged the representational learning capabilities and transfer learning potential offered by large-scale foundation models. This study addresses this critical gap by conducting the first comprehensive comparative evaluation of modern AI approaches for antepartum CTG analysis. We systematically compare the performance of foundation models, LLMs, and established CTG-specific architectures across a diverse dataset of CTG recordings. Our methodology encompasses extensive training and fine-tuning experiments designed to optimise each model’s ability to identify abnormalities in CTG recordings. The primary aim of this study is to establish an objective performance benchmark and provide insights into the relative strengths and limitations of different modelling approaches for automated fetal monitoring. 2 Related Work More recently, DL models have demonstrated superior performance by automatically learning relevant features from raw CTG data khan2025patchctg ; sun2024neurofetalnet . PatchCTG, a model based on the PatchTST architecture originally developed for time-series analysis, achieved an AU-ROC of 0.77 in discriminating between normal and abnormal fetal states khan2025patchctg . Similarly, NeuroFetalNet introduced a multi-scale convolutional neural network enhanced with channel attention mechanisms for remote fetal monitoring, achieving 94.23% accuracy and outperforming existing approaches sun2024neurofetalnet . Several advanced time-series architectures have shown promising results in various temporal classification tasks, but remain largely unexplored for CTG analysis. Models such as Informer, which employs self-attention mechanisms for long sequence time-series forecasting, and TimesNet, which transforms 1D time-series into 2D tensors, capture temporal variations at different scales, have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance across multiple time-series benchmarks zhou2021informer ; wu2022timesnet ; liu2022non . Despite their success in multiple domains, these architectures have not been systematically evaluated for fetal monitoring applications. Time-series FMs represent a relatively new approach in temporal data analysis, leveraging large-scale pre-training on diverse time-series datasets to learn generalizable temporal representations liang2024foundation . These models, while typically smaller than general-purpose LLMs, are specifically designed to capture complex temporal patterns and can be fine-tuned for various downstream tasks. Recent models such as Sundial, Moment, and Mantis have demonstrated strong generalisation capabilities across multiple time-series domains, including forecasting, classification, and anomaly detection liang2024foundation ; goswami2024moment ; liu2025sundial ; feofanov2025mantis ; wang2024deep . However, their application to CTG analysis remains unexplored, despite the potential benefits of transfer learning from broader temporal pattern recognition. General LLMs have also been successfully adapted for time-series applications through techniques such as prompt engineering and parameter-efficient fine-tuning. Model families, including LLama and Phi, along with specialised extensions like TimeLLM and LoRA-based adapters, have shown promising results in processing long temporal contexts characteristic of CTG recordings touvron2023llama ; abdin2024phi ; hu2022lora ; jin2023time . Initial explorations of LLMs for CTG interpretation have yielded mixed results. sun2025ctg evaluated a multi-agent LLM system that decomposed CTG interpretation into five distinct features: baseline, variability, accelerations, decelerations, and sinusoidal patterns. Using GPT-4.1 agents to classify each feature independently before aggregating results, the system achieved 96.40% accuracy on 50 CTG recordings, significantly outperforming both traditional DL methods and a single LLM approach that achieved only 79.80% in accuracy. Conversely, psilopatis2025comparative found that none of the evaluated LLMs, including GPT-4, performed better than chance when discriminating between normal and abnormal CTG traces across 60 recordings, suggesting potential limitations in zero-shot CTG interpretation. GUMILAR20251140 took a different approach by evaluating LLM performance on CTG image interpretation rather than time-series data, comparing model outputs with assessments from doctors of varying experience levels. Through blinded expert ratings on Likert scales, the study found that GPT-4o outperformed junior doctors and achieved accuracy comparable to senior obstetricians, though the evaluation was limited to only seven CTG images. Critically, all existing LLM studies for CTG analysis have been constrained by small sample sizes and have not explored fine-tuning approaches, leaving substantial room for methodological improvement and more comprehensive evaluation. 3 Methodology 3.1 Data Preparation CTG recordings were obtained from the Oxford Maternity (OxMat) database, a longitudinal repository of antepartum CTGs collected