Functional Information in Quantum Darwinism: An Operational Measure of Objectivity

Arda Batın Tank · 2025

Read Functional Information in Quantum Darwinism: An Operational Measure of Objectivity by Arda Batın Tank (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-17775.txt.

Introduction

Why do split quantum views merge into one shared world? Arda Batin Tank takes up that ask in a 2025 paper on Quantum Darwinism. In that view, a system leaves many copies of its key state in its surroundings. Tank adds a new scale based on how much useful facts each piece holds.

Runs on a mixed dephasing model show three clear trends. The count of good pieces grows fast at first, then levels off. Heat sets a hard cost: each extra bit of shared fact at least doubles the heat that must be shed. Shared fact is thus real, but capped.

Catalog record

CREATORArda Batın Tank
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-17775

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Functional Information in Quantum Darwinism: An Operational Measure of Objectivity Arda Batın Tank Abstract This paper investigates the emergence of classical objectivity in quantum systems through the measure of Functional Information in Quantum Darwinism ( F ​ I Q ​ D FI_{QD} ). The goal is to quantify objectivity as the abundance of environment fragments that independently contain sufficient information about a system’s pointer states. The method relies on the Holevo quantity—an upper bound on accessible information—and introduces a tolerance criterion called δ \delta -adequacy, where fragments are considered adequate if they retain at least ( 1 − δ ) ​ H S (1-\delta)H_{S} bits of pointer information. Numerical simulations of a dephasing model with fragment sampling reveal three robust features: (i) an early-time regime where log ⁡ R δ ​ ( t ) \log R_{\delta}(t) grows approximately linearly, (ii) capacity-limited plateaus determined by fragment size and environment dimension, and (iii) stability of the onset criterion under different sampling strategies and overlap corrections. These results establish F ​ I Q ​ D FI_{QD} as a practical and conservative yardstick for operational objectivity. Beyond numerical findings, the analysis links redundancy growth to thermodynamic costs of record formation and interprets F ​ I Q ​ D FI_{QD} as a resource monotone under noisy dynamics. The study suggests that classical objectivity emerges not as an assumption but as a quantifiable, resource-limited abundance of redundant records. Keywords: Quantum Darwinism, decoherence, objectivity, functional information, Holevo bound 1 Introduction Why do we not encounter macroscopic superpositions in daily life? Quantum theory allows, in principle, superpositions of macroscopically distinct states, yet our experiences are of definite, stable outcomes. This tension is classically dramatized by Schrödinger’s cat—a superposition of “alive” and “dead” that we never actually observe [ 2 ] . The puzzle is not merely rhetorical: if quantum mechanics is universally valid, what physical mechanism selects the definite records and stable appearances that constitute our everyday world? A compact way to phrase the problem uses Hilbert space structure. For N qubits the pure-state manifold has dimension 2^{N} ; almost all states are highly nonclassical superpositions with no classical analogue. As Einstein and Born emphasized in their correspondence [ 3 ] , macroscopic regularities are not generically preserved under arbitrary superposition: naively adding macroscopically distinct wave packets spoils the very narrowness (coarse-grained localization) that makes them classical-looking. Thus the question becomes operational: Which states survive realistic monitoring by the environment, and why do many observers independently agree on the same outcomes? The Copenhagen tradition treated measurement as primitive, postponing a dynamical account of outcome definiteness and intersubjective agreement [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Beginning with Zeh, Zurek, Joos and collaborators, the decoherence program reframed the issue dynamically: open-system interactions with ambient degrees of freedom rapidly suppress interference in non-preferred bases, selecting robust pointer states [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . Decoherence explains why certain states are stable carriers of information under continual environmental monitoring, but it does not by itself explain consensus : why many different observers, accessing different parts of the environment, arrive at the same answer without disturbing the system [ 12 ] . Quantum Darwinism (QD) addresses precisely this gap by treating the environment as a communication channel that broadcasts information about the system’s pointer observable into many disjoint fragments [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . In QD, objectivity is linked to redundancy : small, independent fragments already carry (almost) complete information about the pointer outcome. When this redundancy is high, multiple observers can independently sample different fragments and still agree—an operational notion of classical objectivity emerging from quantum dynamics. By objectivity we will mean, operationally, intersubjective agreement : many observers, each with limited and potentially disjoint access to the environment, can independently infer (almost) the same result about the system, and can verify that agreement without prior coordination [ 13 ] . Why should this be true in a microscopic quantum world? The QD answer is redundant encoding . Let S be monitored by an environment E that decomposes into many subenvironments. If information about a pointer POVM \Pi_{S}=\{\Pi_{x}\} is redundantly imprinted into many fragments F\subset E , then even small fragments contain nearly all the relevant classical information about S . In this picture, consensus is not postulated; it is a statistical consequence of abundant adequate fragments . Our work adopts this operational lens and asks: Can we calibrate objectivity by counting (in an information-theoretic sense) how many small pieces already suffice? This paper develops and validates an operational gauge of objectivity grounded in quantum information theory. Existing diagnostics of QD each have limitations. Partial information plots (PIPs) visualize growth of information with fragment size but require ad hoc thresholds to extract a single number [ 19 , 14 ] . Spectrum broadcast structure (SBS) is a powerful structural signature but often too strict to verify experimentally beyond small systems [ 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . Quantum mutual information (QMI) captures total correlations yet does not distinguish redundancy from bipartite entanglement [ 15 , 24 ] . We seek a conservative, experimentally minded quantity that (i) directly reflects the abundance of individually adequate fragments, (ii) comes with capacity/continuity guarantees, and (iii) affords uncertainty quantification. We introduce Functional Information in Quantum Darwinism , FI_{QD}(\delta)=\log_{2}R_{\delta} , where R_{\delta} is the number of fragments that individually carry at least (1-\delta)H_{S} bits of pointer information (via the Holevo quantity) [ 25 , 26 ] . We (i) formalize the adequacy and onset criteria, (ii) justify an onset-based redundancy R_{\delta}\simeq 1/f_{\delta} with explicit overlap corrections, (iii) validate generic features (near-exponential early growth of \log R_{\delta} , capacity-limited plateaus, tolerance-dependent onsets) in dephasing-type models, and (iv) outline experimental connections and thermodynamic interpretations. 2 Theoretical Background 2.1 Quantum Information Theory Fundamentals A general quantum state is described by a density operator \rho=\sum_{i}p_{i}|\psi_{i}\rangle\langle\psi_{i}|, where \{p_{i}\} is a probability distribution over pure states. The quantum analogue of Shannon entropy is the von Neumann entropy, S(\rho)=-\Tr\!\left(\rho\log_{2}\rho\right), (1) which quantifies the uncertainty or information content of \rho . For a bipartite state \rho_{AB} , the quantum mutual information I(A\!:\!B)=S(\rho_{A})+S(\rho_{B})-S(\rho_{AB}) (2) measures the total correlations (both classical and quantum) between A and B . It is always nonnegative and reduces to the classical Shannon mutual information when \rho_{AB} is diagonal in a product basis. 2.2 Open Quantum Systems Realistic systems are never perfectly isolated; instead, we model the global Hilbert space as a tensor product \mathcal{H}=\mathcal{H}_{S}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{E}, where S is the system of interest and E is its environment. The reduced state \rho_{S}=\Tr_{E}(\rho_{SE}) encodes the accessible statistics for measurements on S alone. In the Born–Markov approximation (weak coupling, memoryless bath), the system dynamics can be written as a completely positive trace-preserving semigroup with generator in Lindblad form [ 27 ] : \frac{d}{dt}\rho_{S}(t)=-i[H_{S},\rho_{S}]+\sum_{k}\gamma_{k}\Big(L_{k}\rho_{S}L_{k}^{\dagger}-\tfrac{1}{2}\{L_{k}^{\dagger}L_{k},\rho_{S}\}\Big). (3) 2.3 Accessible Information and the Holevo Bound Suppose a classical random variable X with distribution \{p_{x}\} is encoded into quantum states \{\rho_{x}\} of a system Q . The ensemble \mathcal{E}=\{p_{x},\rho_{x}\} defines a classical–quantum channel . The Holevo quantity is defined as \chi(\{p_{x},\rho_{x}\})=S\!\left(\sum_{x}p_{x}\rho_{x}\right)-\sum_{x}p_{x}S(\rho_{x}). (4) Holevo’s theorem [ 25 ] states that the accessible classical information obtained by any POVM \mathcal{M} is bounded: I(X:Y)\leq\chi(\{p_{x},\rho_{x}\}).

Read the complete text