Residual fertility and delay in sterile insect population dynamics

Ruqaya Hussein, Sergey Kryzhevich, Khosro Tajbakhsh · 2025

Read Residual fertility and delay in sterile insect population dynamics by Ruqaya Hussein, Sergey Kryzhevich, Khosro Tajbakhsh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-17519.txt.

Introduction

Ruqaya Hussein, Sergey Kryzhevich, and Khosro Tajbakhsh model a mosquito control method that can partly fail. Their 2025 arXiv paper studies the sterile insect technique, used against malaria, dengue, and yellow fever. Released sterile males mate with wild females, and the population should crash. In practice, some released insects keep residual fertility, and delays creep into the life cycle.

Their three-dimensional delayed model joins wild, sterile, and non-sterile insects with a saturated release rate. The authors find when the positive equilibrium stays stable and when a Hopf bifurcation sets the population oscillating. Below a critical delay, the system holds steady; past it, cycles can emerge. As residual fertility varies in a narrow band, the non-sterile population swings sharply, a sign of sensitive dependence. The warning for field programmes is that small leaks of fertility can flip outcomes.

Catalog record

CREATORRuqaya Hussein, Sergey Kryzhevich, Khosro Tajbakhsh
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-17519

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Residual fertility and delay in sterile insect population dynamics Ruqaya Hussein, Sergey Kryzhevich, Khosro Tajbakhsh Abstract . The sterile insect technique controls mosquito-borne diseases such as malaria, dengue, and yellow fever through either eradication or depressing the associated vector population. We formulate a three-dimensional delayed mosquito population suppression model with a saturated release rate to explore the interactive dynamics between wild, sterile, and non-sterile mosquitoes, focusing on the delay and residual fertility in the interactive dynamics among insects. We investigate the stability of the positive equilibrium and derive the Hopf bifurcation conditions. We establish the stability conditions for the positive equilibrium and examine how the time delay ( τ \tau ) and residual fertility affect the non-sterile insects’ dynamics. Below the critical values of the delay, the system remains stable, while beyond that, the Hopf bifurcation is guaranteed under certain circumstances. However, analysis shows a clear band of non-sterile insect population values as residual fertility varies within a very narrow range. This suggests that within this interval, the system exhibits sensitive dependence on the fertility parameter, likely due to underlying nonlinear dynamics. Numerical simulations are presented to support our analytical results, followed by a brief discussion of the findings. Keywords: Delay differential equation, Hopf bifurcation, Mosquitoes population model, Residual fertility. 1. Introduction Several methods exist to control mosquito-borne diseases. The traditional approach uses insecticides, but another effective strategy is reducing the wild mosquito population by means of Sterile Insect Technique (SIT), also known as the Sterile Insect Release Method (SIRM). First introduced by E. F. Knipling in 60th 1960s, SIT has been successfully applied in many regions across the world against various insect pests and vectors both in agriculture and medicine. Mosquitoes have four life stages, including egg, larva, pupa, and adult, that take 7 to 20 days from oviposition to adult death on average [ 1 ] . Their feeding habits are unique as only adult females consume blood (required for egg production), while males feed exclusively on plant nectar. Females target mammals, including humans, as well as birds, reptiles, and amphibians [ 4 ] . The principle of SIT against these important insects involves rearing sterile male mosquitoes and releasing them into wild populations. When a wild female mates with a sterile male, she either fails to reproduce or her eggs do not hatch. Over time, this reduces the mosquito population through generations. However, before implementing SIT, optimal release strategies and sterile mosquito quantities must be carefully determined [ 5 ] . Numerous mathematical models have been developed to investigate the interactive dynamics between wild and sterile mosquito populations. Key contributions include studies by but not limited to [ 6 , 18 , 19 ] . The survey by [ 6 ] relies on ordinary differential equations (ODEs) and explores three distinct strategies for releasing sterile mosquitoes, including a constant release rate, a release rate proportional to the wild mosquito population, and a saturated release rate proportional to the wild population. Other workers have investigated spreading dynamics by integrating stage structure [ 22 , 23 ] , time delays [ 2 , 10 , 18 ] , spatial diffusion [ 10 , 24 ] , and environmental heterogeneity through stochastic equations [ 11 ] . Delay differential equations (DDEs) have recently gained increasing attention in mathematical modeling. Introducing delays allows for a more realistic description of biological phenomena and improves predictive accuracy. Such models are also called Retarded Functional Differential Equations (RFDEs). Unlike ODEs, RFDEs are infinite-dimensional dynamical systems, leading to richer dynamics, including oscillations, instability, chaos, and altered stability properties. DDEs are widely used in science, engineering, biology, and medicine for modeling population dynamics, epidemiology, immunology, and neural networks [ 29 , 30 ] . [ 25 ] developed a DDE framework to study wild-sterile mosquito interactions and to assess control strategy efficacy. [ 19 ] constructed a DDE model accounting for only fertile sterile mosquitoes, focusing on constant-release scenarios, and in a more recent study, [ 26 ] evaluated sterile mosquito suppression strategies by incorporating delayed releases. Also, [ 27 ] formulated a delayed suppression model with constant sterile mosquito releases. One critical issue in SIT programs is residual fertility in sterile insects that can be challenging when the number of non-sterile sperms/insects in releasing insects/packages exceeds a threshold. This factor is normaly considered as a fixed parameter in SIT modelling; however, in the current work, like [ 18 ] who considred number of released sterile mosquitoes as an independent dynamical equation rather than as a fixed parameter, we incorporate residual fertility as a coupled ODE to wild and sterile insects system of ODEs to analyze consequent dynamics of insects who are escaped from being sterilized enough through irradiation process. Simultaneously, the same delay in releasing both sterile and non-sterile insects as a critical parameter in the success of both SIT and population dynamics of this small portion of sterile insects is studied analytically and numerically. This paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the complete formulation of the delay differential equation model. In Section 3, we analyze the stability of the origin, boundary, and positive equilibria, focusing on the circumstances under which Hopf bifurcation can occur in the dynamics, considering the saturated sterile mosquito release rate. Section 4 provides numerical simulations that validate the theoretical results, particularly emphasizing how time delay and residual fertility affect non-sterile insects’ population dynamics. Finally, Section 5 concludes by discussing the key findings and their implications. All numerical simulations were performed using MATLAB R2014b, while analytical computations were conducted in Mathematica 12.0. 2. The model formulation We present a three-dimensional delayed mathematical model with a nonlinear saturated releasing rate containing an ODE governing the dynamics of non-sterile insects coupled to wild and sterile insects’ ODEs. Without interactions, the dynamics of the wild mosquito population follow logistic growth. After releasing sterile mosquitoes into the wild population, the system is governed by the following delay differential equations: (2.1) \begin{split}\frac{dw}{dt}&=\Big(\frac{aw(t)+rs(t-\tau)}{1+w(t)+g(t)+s(t-\tau)}-(\xi_{1}(w(t)+g(t)+s(t-\tau))\Big)w(t)\\ \frac{dg}{dt}&=\frac{bw(t)}{1+w(t)}-\Big(\xi_{2}(w(t)+g(t)+s(t))\Big)g(t)\\ \frac{ds}{dt}&=\frac{cw(t)}{1+w(t)}+\Big(\frac{rs(t)+aw(t-\tau)}{1+w(t-\tau)+g(t)+s(t)}-(\xi_{3}(w(t-\tau)+g(t)+s(t))\Big)s(t)\end{split} Where • w(t),g(t) , and s(t) are populations of wild, sterile, and non-sterile mosquitoes, respectively, at time t ; • N(t)=w(t)+g(t)+s(t) is total mosquito population; • a is the wild offspring production rate per mating; • \xi_{i},i=1,2,3 are density-dependent death rates for wild, sterile, and non-sterile mosquitoes, respectively; • b is the sterile mosquito release rate; • c is residual fertility or non-sterile mosquito release rate (small portion of g that remains fertile); • r is the non-sterile offspring production rate per mating. The parameters b (sterile release rate) and c (residual fertility proportion) critically influence population dynamics. Adjusting b can suppress wild mosquito numbers, while r and c determine the effectiveness of the SIT program. High c or r may counteract SIT by increasing the reproduction of fertile insects. The coordinates of the system are changed as W=w-w^{*} , G=g-g^{*} , and S=s-s^{*} to see the positive equilibrium at the origin, and then we expand the Taylor series of the system ( 2.2 ) up to the fourth order. The new equations in terms of new variables W, G, S are as follows. (2.2) \begin{split}\frac{dW}{dt}&=a_{1}+a_{2}W(t)+a_{3}G(t)+a_{4}S(t-\tau)+a_{5}W^{2}(t)+a_{6}W^{3}(t)+a_{7}W^{4}(t)+a_{8}G^{2}(t)\\ &+a_{9}G^{3}(t)+a_{10}G^{4}(t)+a_{11}S^{2}(t-\tau)+a_{12}S^{3}(t-\tau)+h.o.t.,\\ \frac{dG}{dt}&=b_{1}W^{4}(t)+b_{2}W^{3}(t)+b_{3}W^{2}(t)+b_{4}W(t)+b_{5}G^{2}(t)+b_{5}G(t)W(t)+b_{5}G(t)S(t)\\ &+b_{6}S(t)+b_{7}G(t)+b_{8}\\ \frac{dS}{dt}&=c_{1}+c_{2}G(t)+c_{3}S(t)+c_{4}W(t-\tau)+c_{5}W^{2}(t-\tau)+c_{6}W^{3}(t-\tau)+c_{7}W^{4}(t-\tau)\\ &+c_{8}W(t)+c_{9}W^{2}(t)+c_{10}W^{3}(t)+c_{11}W^{4}(t)+c_{12}G^{2}(t)+h.o.t.,\end{split} The expressions for the coefficients a_{i},i=1,2,...12;b_{j},j=1,2,...8 ; and c_{k},k=1,2,....12 are provided in Appendix ( A ). Linearizing ( 2.2

Read the complete text