Adaptive mechanical proofreading toward faithful clonal selection
Qing Xu and Shenshen Wang · 2025
Read Adaptive mechanical proofreading toward faithful clonal selection by Qing Xu and Shenshen Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-17422.txt.
Introduction
Qing Xu and Shenshen Wang propose a mechanical twist on proofreading in the immune system. Their 2025 arXiv paper starts from a classic idea: cells spend energy to cut errors, and kinetic proofreading sharpens how T cells tell ligands apart. Whether the adaptive immune system leans on that trick alone to stay faithful remains an open question.
The authors suggest that B cells use force itself as a proofreader. Through dynamic cell-cell contact, a B cell pulls on its target, and feedback between force and contact growth lets it pick high-affinity receptors with care. A minimal model, checked against experiments, shows the scheme sorts receptor quality well no matter how much ligand is present. A telling sign of feedback is that contact time shrinks as ligand grows more abundant. The authors note uses from curbing autoimmunity to boosting vaccines.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Qing Xu and Shenshen Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-17422
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Adaptive mechanical proofreading toward faithful clonal selection Qing Xu and Shenshen Wang Abstract To ensure faithful information transmission, cells utilize nonequilibrium drives to reduce errors. Kinetic proofreading is a classic mechanism known to sharpen ligand discrimination by T lymphocytes. It remains an open question whether the adaptive immune system relies solely on kinetic proofreading to boost fidelity. Here, we suggest an alternative: an enhanced form of mechanical proofreading (MPR) in which adaptive force exertion via dynamic cell-cell contact allows faithful selection of high-affinity B lymphocytes. Using a minimal model validated with experiment, we show that adaptive MPR, characterized by mechanical feedback between force generation and contact formation, enables robust discrimination of receptor quality regardless of ligand quantity. Although MPR generically balances the tradeoffs between speed and fidelity, a negative scaling of contact duration with ligand abundance indicates the presence of feedback. Due to its ability to modulate interactions of distinct ligands that share load at membrane contacts, adaptive MPR can be harnessed to mitigate autoimmunity or enhance multivalent vaccines. Overall, this work suggests a generalization of the proofreading mechanism to encompass cellular designs that act across scales to enable competing functionalities. pacs Valid PACS appear here I Introduction One basic characteristic of life is the ability to operate with extraordinary fidelity. Key processes responsible for propagating inheritable information inside living cells – protein translation, RNA transcription, and DNA replication – are known to have far lower error rates than expected at thermal equilibrium. It is thus believed that cells utilize non-equilibrium drives to detect and correct errors through a kinetic proofreading mechanism ninio1975kinetic ; hopfield1974kinetic ; ehrenberg1980thermodynamic ; murugan2014discriminatory . This dissipative mechanism reduces errors by amplifying the effect of binding energy differences between competing molecular substrates, via a cascade of enzymatic reactions (proofreading steps) that slow the progress toward the product. Thus, speed is traded for accuracy. Vital to organismal survival, natural immunity demands efficiency no less than fidelity – in order to contain self-amplifying threats (invasive agents or cancerous cells). Although the ability of T lymphocytes to exquisitely discriminate self from nonself peptides is considered a classic example of kinetic proofreading (KPR) mckeithan1995kinetic , it is unclear if the adaptive immune system relies solely on KPR for fidelity-enhancing purposes. Here, we suggest an alternative possibility: humoral immunity – constantly renewing through clonal diversification and selection – can employ an enhanced form of mechanical proofreading (MPR) to achieve efficient and faithful selection of high-affinity B lymphocytes, producing robust yet tunable responses that are not directly selected for. In contrast to KPR in which the proofreading steps are downstream of receptor binding inside the cell, MPR takes effect through the dynamic junction formed between mutually engaged cells – intracellular forces organize interfacial patterns of force-sensitive receptor-ligand species and modulate information transfer by deforming opposing membranes and molecular complexes. Using a minimal construction of force schemes that distills the distinctive feature of MPR, we contrast schemes that differ in their ability to adapt to the system state. We find that, when force can sense and adapt to the contact pattern organized under force, such mechanical feedback leads to reduced contact duration with increasing ligand abundance, opposite to when force turns on after a predetermined delay. This feedback allows for robust discrimination of receptor quality against variations in ligand concentration. The same feedback causes ligand antagonism, a phenomenon by which non-agonists alter immune responses to co-presented agonists. Hence, despite being similar to allostery-based proofreading phillips2020molecular by causing conformational changes in molecular substrates, adaptive MPR is a many-body mechanism in which the manner of force exertion may alter the relationship between molecular species that share load at membrane interfaces. This mechanism has intriguing implications for mitigating autoimmunity and enhancing the efficacy of multivalent vaccines. We propose that adaptive MPR at cell-cell contact can enhance the fidelity of clonal selection while meeting competing functional needs, suggesting a generalized proofreading paradigm that encompasses action across scales. Figure 1: B cells apply dynamic forces to control antigen extraction: model validation with independent experiments. (A) A B cell uses its BCRs to bind antigens tethered to an APC, forming localized clusters of BCR-Ag-tether complexes. The contractile cytoskeleton exerts dynamic pulling forces on individual clusters and drives antigen extraction. Force influences the system state by altering the off-rates k_{a}^{\mathrm{off}} and k_{b}^{\mathrm{off}} of the complexes that share load. An inert force F(t) turns on with a preset delay t_{c} , whereas an adaptive force F(m_{\text{max}}) compares the maximum cluster size reached, m_{\text{max}} , to the onset threshold m_{c} . The system state, specified by the instantaneous cluster size m and the number of BCR-bound antigens n , evolves via stochastic binding/unbinding on ether side of the molecular tug-of-wars (Eq. 1). (B,C) Model captures the observed extraction dynamics. (B) Simulated trajectories of (m,n) and applied force F for each scheme. Cluster size in both schemes (red lines) matches the experimental trend of antigen fluorescence natkanski2013 (red symbols). (C) Distributions of contact duration for low/high extraction B cells (“−”/“+”) in both schemes (right two panels) match experimental data suzuki2009 (left panel). High-extraction B cells show a larger median (higher black bar), whereas lower-extraction B cells are skewed toward brief contacts with a tail toward long durations. Parameters: L_{0}=100 , k_{\text{on}}=0.05s^{-1} , E_{a}=12.6k_{B}T , E_{b}=13.3k_{B}T , x_{a}=1.5\text{nm} , x_{b}=2\text{nm} , \beta=5 ; (B) F_{0}=350\text{pN} , t_{c}=1.5\text{min} , m_{c}=60 ; (C) middle: F_{0}/\text{pN}\sim\mathcal{U}(250,900) , t_{c}/\text{min}\sim\text{LogUniform}(0.1,15) ; right: F_{0}/\text{pN}\sim\mathcal{U}(300,900) , m_{c}\sim\mathcal{U}(20,80) . II Model Within the transient microenvironment called germinal centers (GCs), B lymphocytes improve their antigen recognition capability through a rapid Darwinian process known as affinity maturation eisen1964variations ; victora2012 ; victora2022germinal . In a cyclic fashion, GC B cells diversify their receptor encoding genes during replication via somatic hypermutation and compete for limited survival signals provided by T helper cells. Ideally, B cells expressing higher affinity receptors (BCRs) compete better and expand preferentially. The key step that translates the affinity excess of a B cell clone to its competitive advantage is a vigorous physical process of antigen extraction batista2001 ; suzuki2009 ; natkanski2013 ; mcarthur2025antigen : through a dynamically organized intercellular junction (immunological synapse), a B cell actively acquires antigens from an antigen presenting cell (APC) using cytoskeletal forces and presents the acquired antigens in a processed form on its surface. T helper cells then discern BCR affinity according to the surface density of presented antigens lanzavecchia1985antigen ; victora2010germinal . Consequently, antigen extraction dynamics – tunable through force exertion – control, and potentially limit, the fidelity of clonal selection. Upon binding of a BCR to an antigen (Ag) tethered to the surface of an APC, a BCR-Ag-tether 3-body complex forms. Productive binding deforms the B-cell membrane and drives clustering of BCRs, initiating a series of BCR-Ag interactions. These interactions in turn trigger cytoskeletal remodeling inside the B cell and generation of contractile forces needed to pull Ags away from the APC. Successful Ag extraction occurs when the BCR-Ag bond withstands the forces longer than the Ag-tether bond within a 3-body complex. Once all complexes in a cluster are disrupted, the B cell locally detaches from the APC, concluding one extraction attempt. Previous models jiang2023immune ; jiang2023molecular ; jiang2024physical assume pre-formed clusters subject to constant loads, only depicting the rupture stage. Here, we