Bridging Cybersecurity Practice and Law: a Hands-on, Scenario-Based Curriculum Using the NICE Framework to Foster Skill Development

Colman McGuan, Aadithyan V. Raghavan, Komala M. Mandapati, Chansu Yu, Brian E. Ray, Debbie K. Jackson, Sathish Kumar · 2025

Read Bridging Cybersecurity Practice and Law: a Hands-on, Scenario-Based Curriculum Using the NICE Framework to Foster Skill Development by Colman McGuan, Aadithyan V. Raghavan, Komala M. Mandapati, Chansu Yu, Brian E. Ray, Debbie K. Jackson, Sathish Kumar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-17263.txt.

Introduction

Colman McGuan and six co-authors wrote a 2025 arXiv paper on training cybersecurity staff who also grasp the law. Small and mid-size firms must guard their systems, yet the national NICE framework that maps the needed skills is hard to put into practice. The team set out to turn that framework into lessons a small firm can use.

First they list the attack routes small firms face most often. Then they map the tasks, knowledge, skills, and abilities in the NICE framework onto those attacks, in both technical and non-technical terms. On that base they build a scenario-based curriculum that drops learners into lifelike incidents. The course blends hands-on drills with real skill building. Firms can also use the model to judge their current staff or to guide hiring.

Catalog record

CREATORColman McGuan, Aadithyan V. Raghavan, Komala M. Mandapati, Chansu Yu, Brian E. Ray, Debbie K. Jackson, Sathish Kumar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-17263

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bridging Cybersecurity Practice and Law: a Hands-on, Scenario-Based Curriculum Using the NICE Framework to Foster Skill Development Colman McGuan, Aadithyan V. Raghavan, Komala M. Mandapati, Chansu Yu, Brian E. Ray, Debbie K. Jackson, Sathish Kumar Abstract In an increasingly interconnected world, cybersecurity professionals play a pivotal role in safeguarding organizations from cyber threats. To secure their cyberspace, organizations are forced to adopt a cybersecurity framework such as the NIST National Initiative for Cybersecurity Education Workforce Framework for Cybersecurity (NICE Framework). Although these frameworks are a good starting point for businesses and offer critical information to identify, prevent, and respond to cyber incidents, they can be difficult to navigate and implement, particularly for small-medium businesses (SMB). To help overcome this issue, this paper identifies the most frequent attack vectors to SMBs (Objective 1) and proposes a practical model of both technical and non-technical tasks, knowledge, skills, abilities (TKSA) from the NICE Framework for those attacks (Objective 2). The research develops a scenario-based curriculum. By immersing learners in realistic cyber threat scenarios, their practical understanding and preparedness in responding to cybersecurity incidents is enhanced (Objective 3). Finally, this work integrates practical experience and real-life skill development into the curriculum (Objective 4). SMBs can use the model as a guide to evaluate, equip their existing workforce, or assist in hiring new employees. In addition, educational institutions can use the model to develop scenario-based learning modules to adequately equip the emerging cybersecurity workforce for SMBs. Trainees will have the opportunity to practice both technical and legal issues in a simulated environment, thereby strengthening their ability to identify, mitigate, and respond to cyber threats effectively. Keywords— Cybersecurity; SMB; NICE Framework; KSA; Curriculum 1 Introduction Cyberattacks are costly to businesses and are becoming more prevalent each year with 67% of businesses reporting an increase in the number of cyber attacks experienced in the last 12 months as of 2024 [ 1 ] . Due to these cyberattacks, 43% of the companies suffered a loss of customers and 47% found difficulty attracting new ones, up from 21% and 20% in 2023 [ 1 ] . These attacks place immense financial pressure on businesses. In 2024, the cost of a data breach averaged $4.88 million, a 10% increase from 2023 [ 2 ] . Moreover, in 2024, 40% of businesses identified their cyber resilience maturity as either basic or ad hoc in a self assessment—i.e., they lack formal processes and have limited cyber training and awareness [ 1 ] . Businesses cite employees using their own devices as contributing to increased risk exposure [ 1 ] , demonstrating the need for a robust and cross-functional cybersecurity skillset. This is especially concerning for small-medium businesses (SMBs) because of their limited resources and their lack of awareness [ 3 , 4 ] . There are over 34 million SMBs in the US [ 5 ] , and cyberattacks are a serious threat to them. Cybersecurity awareness and education have played a significant role in improving employee awareness. This paper proposes a comprehensive model of knowledge and skillset that will assist SMBs in defending themselves. Our research was steered by three overarching questions. 1. Where do SMBs stand with respect to cybersecurity? This question allows us to collect and synthesize existing data to identify the gap between the current SMB workforce and best practices. 2. What are the most frequent and impactful attacks faced by SMBs? This allows us to center the scope of our research on providing the most robust skillset to SMBs. This is done to maximize the area of coverage with as small of a workforce as possible due to the limited nature of an SMB. Our research found that the most frequent attacks are phishing/social engineering, malware/ransomware, and web-based attacks (Section 4.1 ). 3. How can the workforce be equipped with the necessary knowledge and skills to apply the best practices? This helps us incorporate the NICE Framework [ 6 ] as a bridge between the workforce and the best practices by mapping the tasks, knowledge, skills, and abilities (TKSA) to the most frequent attacks. However, the NICE Framework lists a total of 634 knowledges, 377 skills, 1006 tasks, and 177 abilities, making it costly for SMB owners to investigate and implement. Our research yielded a total of 88 technical TKSA and 54 non-technical TKSA that are required to defend against the three previously mentioned attack types. This is 6.23% of the total TKSAs present in the NICE Framework and is practical for SMBs to implement as it extracts the TKSA most relevant to defend against the attack vectors identified; by creating this subset of TKSA from the NICE Framework, SMBs are able to more efficiently target resources where necessary (Sections 4.2 and 4.3 ). After answering these questions, we develop a scenario-based training to enhance practical understanding and preparedness, which has been shown to be an effective learning model [ 7 ] . The curriculum provides hands-on experience in simulated environments to improve students’ ability to identify, mitigate, and respond to cyber threats as done in [ 8 ] . Guided by the NICE Framework, this curriculum prepares trainees, regardless of their academic background, to navigate the complex field of cybersecurity effectively. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 provides brief preliminary information supplemental to understanding this work. Section 3 discusses related works and touches briefly on the cybersecurity frameworks. Section 4 discusses the proposed methodology behind our research including the identification of the three frequent attack types and determining the best practices to counter them and map them to the TKSA present in the NICE Framework. Section 5 presents the design of the scenario-based learning model while Section 6 analyzes students’ performance and feedback. Lastly, Section 7 gives the closing remarks. 2 Preliminaries This section provides supplementary information important for understanding this work. 2.1 A Note on KSA and TKSA KSA refers to knowledge, skill, and ability, and is the colloquial term used in our research field. However, the NICE Framework introduces tasks, creating the acronym TKSA. In this work, we tend to use KSA when speaking generally about the field of work due to its long-standing prevalence and well-understood meaning in the field. Conversely, when describing the NICE Framework keyword mapping, we tend to use TKSA as not to omit tasks when discussing our work. 2.2 A Note on the NICE Framework This work is the culmination of several years of planning, research, and execution. As such, the most recent version of the NICE Framework at the onset of this work was NIST SP 800-181 [ 9 ] . Since then, NIST SP 800-181 Rev. 1 [ 10 ] has been released. This section serves as an acknowledgment of the NICE Framework revision. In the future, we plan to compare the original version with the latest and alter our approach accordingly. 2.3 Ethics Statement The results of this work use human participation for data analysis. Their names are kept anonymous to protect their personal information. 3 Related Work There exist several cybersecurity frameworks; one such framework is the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 27001, a well-known standard for information security management systems (ISMS) [ 11 ] . The NIST Framework

Read the complete text