First principles simulation of the collective rovibronic ground state in a cavity
Niclas Krupp, Moritz Huber, Cheng Luo, Oriol Vendrell · 2025
Read First principles simulation of the collective rovibronic ground state in a cavity by Niclas Krupp, Moritz Huber, Cheng Luo, Oriol Vendrell (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-17243.txt.
Introduction
Niclas Krupp, Moritz Huber, Cheng Luo, and Oriol Vendrell simulate molecules trapped in light cavities in a 2025 arXiv paper. Strong coupling between light and matter inside such cavities can shift how molecules react and how charge and energy move. Claims in the field clash, though, in part because studies pick distinct Hamiltonians and state forms.
The team runs numerically exact simulations from a first-principles light-matter Hamiltonian. Electrons, nuclei, and cavity photons are treated on the same footing. Their test system is a Shin-Metiu model with rotation, vibration, and electronic motion all live, handled by a tree tensor network method. A cavity does change single molecules a bit, mostly in rotation and nuclear motion. The change tracks the coupling per molecule, then fades as the group grows toward bulk size, which helps explain why lab claims are hard to reproduce.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Niclas Krupp, Moritz Huber, Cheng Luo, Oriol Vendrell |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 80 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-17243
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
First principles simulation of the collective rovibronic ground state in a cavity Niclas Krupp, Moritz Huber, Cheng Luo, Oriol Vendrell Abstract Strong light–matter coupling in Fabry–Perot cavities can modify ground-state molecular reactivity, charge and energy transport, while modifications to single-molecule properties have not been observed experimentally. The mechanisms and reproducibility of such effects remain contested, with conflicting theoretical predictions driven by differences in Hamiltonian choice and quantum state representation. Here, we resolve these ambiguities with numerically exact quantum simulations of cavity-coupled molecular ensembles based on the ab initio light–matter Hamiltonian, treating electrons, nuclei, and cavity photons on equal footing. We investigate ensembles of the rotational-vibrational-electronic Shin-Metiu model using variational tree-tensor-network quantum dynamics, capturing rovibronic couplings and anharmonicity. Embedding ensembles in a cavity induces local modifications of rotational, nuclear, and—more weakly—electronic observables in individual molecules. The extent of these modifications depends only on the per-molecule coupling strength up until each molecule reaches the ultrastrong coupling regime, which remains unattainable in practical Fabry–Perot setups. Increasing ensemble size toward the thermodynamic limit causes these local modifications to vanish regardless of dipole self-energy inclusion. Nonetheless, global ground-state observables, such as light–matter coupling energy contributions (affecting overall polarizability) and cavity field displacement fluctuations, depend crucially on proper treatment of intermolecular and light–matter correlations, whereas intramolecular observables remain largely insensitive. These insights are crucial for guiding future investigations using approximate quantum treatments, and for the interpretation of experimental results in polaritonic chemistry. I Introduction Strong coupling between reactive molecular systems and confined electromagnetic modes can can result in modified chemical reactivity, both for thermal and photo-activated reactions, thereby opening up pathways to mode-selective and tunable chemistry Ebbesen 2016 ; Garcia-Vidal et al. 2021 ; Hirai et al. 2023 . Depending on the cavity mode frequency, distinct properties and reactivities can be addressed: In the electronic strong coupling regime (ESC), cavity-enhanced selectivity of photochemical reactions Hutchison et al. 2012 and modified intersystem crossing dynamics Yu et al. 2021 could be demonstrated, among others Xiang and Xiong 2024 . Experiments in the vibrational strong coupling (VSC) regime have reported cavity-modification of electrical Kumar et al. 2024 and ionic conductivity Fukushima et al. 2022 , non-covalent interactions Joseph et al. 2021 , as well as reaction rates Lather et al. 2019 ; Thomas et al. 2019 ; Ahn et al. 2023 . Cavity-modified reaction rates are particularly intriguing, as the prospect of controlling chemical reactivity with light has been a long-standing goal since the advent of lasers Bloembergen and Zewail 1984 ; Zewail 1980 . Nonetheless, the extent to which cavities influence reactivity – especially whether modifications of single-molecule properties are required for rate changes to occur – remains actively debated Thomas et al. 2024 ; Schwartz and Hutchison 2025 ; Schwennicke et al. 2025 . This ongoing uncertainty makes it challenging to establish clear and general conditions under which cavity-controlled reactions could become feasible Fidler et al. 2023 ; Chen et al. 2024 ; Wang and Yelin 2021 . Since the pioneering experiments by the group of Ebbesen Thomas et al. 2016 ; Thomas et al. 2019 , several mechanistic explanations have been put forward, including alteration of the potential energy barrier due to strong coupling Galego et al. 2019 ; Riso et al. 2022 , new dynamic energy redistribution pathways among molecules and within molecules Sun and Vendrell 2022 ; Sun and Vendrell 2023 ; Li et al. 2021a , cavity-induced polarization hotspots Sidler et al. 2024a , and optical filtering effects Schwennicke et al. 2025 . Experimental verification of these proposed mechanisms in the collective coupling regime is still outstanding Campos-Gonzalez-Angulo et al. 2023 . This is aggravated by the lack of reproducibility of some experiments Wiesehan and Xiong 2021 ; Imperatore et al. 2021 , and the challenging separation of polaritonic and non-polaritonic effects in optical cavity setups Schwennicke et al. 2025 ; Thomas et al. 2024 ; Michon and Simpkins 2024 . Fundamentally, the mechanism behind the multitude of vibrational strong-coupling experiments remains thus unclear, despite the vast amount of theoretical developments in recent years Campos-Gonzalez-Angulo et al. 2023 ; Fregoni et al. 2022 ; Wang and Yelin 2021 . Typical Fabry-Pérot (FP) cavity setups comprise a large number of electrons and nuclei which couple to cavity photons. The enormous dimensionality of such cavity-molecule systems makes simulations, which treat electrons, nuclei and photons on the same quantum-mechanical footing, computationally extremely demanding. Hence, a multitude of approximate methods for solving the time-(in)dependent Schrödinger equation of the coupled electron-nuclear-photonic system have been developed Flick et al. 2017 ; Fregoni et al. 2022 ; Ruggenthaler et al. 2023 . As of yet, however, there is no consensus in the theory community on parameter regimes (characterized by, e.g., coupling strength, number of molecules and cavity frequency) in which these approximations hold and where they break down. Specifically, two open questions are heavily debated in the current literature Sidler et al. 2024a ; Horak et al. 2025 ; Schäfer et al. 2020 ; Fiechter and Richardson 2024 ; Martínez-Martínez et al. 2018a ; Galego et al. 2015 : When does the so-called dipole self-energy (DSE, or self-polarization term) become relevant such that it cannot be omitted in simulations? And: Can coupling to the cavity significantly alter the molecular electronic ground state under typical experimental conditions? Note that the two questions are connected since the dipole-self energy term mediates intra- and intermolecular electron-electron and electron-nuclear interactions which can impact the molecular electronic structure. While the first question addresses approximations to the light-mater interaction Hamiltonian, the second question relates to the appropriate approximations to the molecular wavefunction under strong coupling. In the following, we will thus briefly review both types of common approximations. It is instructive to categorize the approximations on the level of the light-matter Hamiltonian into a hierarchy which is displayed in Figure 1 . Starting point is the so-called Pauli-Fierz Hamiltonian, i.e., the minimal coupling Hamiltonian in Power-Zienau-Woolley (PZW) gauge which correctly describes the interaction between molecules and a quantized transverse electromagnetic field in the non-relativistic limit. Ab initio treatments Ruggenthaler et al. 2023 of a FP cavity-molecule systems are usually based on the Pauli-Fierz Hamiltonian (PFH) with a single “effective” quantized mode of light, \displaystyle\hat{H}_{\mathrm{PF}}=\sum_{j=1}^{N}\hat{H}_{\mathrm{mol}}^{(j)}+\frac{\hat{p}_{C}^{2}}{2}+\frac{\omega_{C}^{2}}{2}\hat{q}_{C}^{2}-\omega_{C}\hat{q}_{C}\vec{\lambda}\cdot\hat{\vec{D}}+\frac{1}{2}\left(\vec{\lambda}\cdot\hat{\vec{D}}\right)^{2}, (1) where \hat{q}_{C} and \hat{p}_{C} denote displacement coordinate and conjugate momentum of the cavity mode with frequency \omega_{C} respectively, and \vec{\lambda} is the light-matter coupling strength. Here and throughout the manuscript, atomic units are used if not mentioned otherwise. Although the PFH describes exactly the interaction of matter and transverse electromagnetic modes in the absence of relativistic effects, and therefore it is termed “ab initio” in this sense, in most instances one does not consider the physical specifics of the cavity when determining the coupling strength \vec{\lambda} . Hence, in fact most applications of the PFH consider effective electromagnetic modes and treat \vec{\lambda} as a model parameter (see, e.g., Sidler et al. 2024a ; Schnappinger and Kowalewski 2024 ; Castagnola et al. 2025 ). In this form of the light-matter Hamiltonian, coupling between the molecular ensemble to the cavity field results in two distinct interaction terms: a bilinear interaction between cavity displacement and ensemble dipole \hat{\vec{D}} , \hat{H}_{\mathrm{cav-mol}}\equiv-\omega_{C}\hat{q}_{C}\vec{\lambda}\cdot\hat{\vec{D}} , and a quadratic term, mediating interactions between all molecular dipoles with themselves. The