An idealized general circulation model for the atmospheric circulation on the ice giants
I. Guendelman, Y. Kaspi · 2025
Read An idealized general circulation model for the atmospheric circulation on the ice giants by I. Guendelman, Y. Kaspi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-17217.txt.
Introduction
Ilai Guendelman and Yoahi Kaspi built a new climate model for Uranus and Neptune in a 2025 arXiv paper. The two ice giants are the least explored planets, and a puzzle hangs over them. Their winds look much alike, even though their tilts and inner heat differ a great deal. Past models have struggled to match the winds seen by telescopes.
The pair's idealized model sweeps through settings to see how winds and overturning flows respond. Depth turns out to be the key knob. When the model's lower layer runs deep enough, the flow stops caring about the shape of the imposed heat pattern. In that regime, moving air itself, through eddy flows that carry momentum sideways and upward, sustains the circulation. That finding explains why two unlike planets can wear such similar winds.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | I. Guendelman, Y. Kaspi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-17217
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An idealized general circulation model for the atmospheric circulation on the ice giants I. Guendelman, Y. Kaspi Abstract Uranus and Neptune are the least explored planets in the Solar System. A key question regarding the two planets is the similarity of their observed flows despite the great differences in their obliquity and internal heating. To answer this fundamental question and understand the ice giants atmospheric circulation, we developed a new general circulation model (GCM). This tool will also be key to facilitating the success of future missions to the ice giants, for which atmospheric flows will be a measurable quantity. Past GCMs for the ice giants have struggled to reproduce the observed winds on Uranus and Neptune. Using our idealized GCM, we systematically explored how the zonal wind and meridional circulation respond to different model and physical parameters; our main focus was on the depth of the domain. We show that in cases where the bottom layer of the model is deep enough, the simulated flow is independent of the meridional structure of the forcing temperature, indicating that dynamical processes, and not the imposed thermal forcing, are the dominant drivers of the circulation and the thermal structure. A momentum balance analysis further shows that meridional and vertical eddy momentum flux convergence are both central to maintaining the circulation. These results provide a physical explanation for the similarity of the flow on Uranus and Neptune although their solar and internal forcing are significantly different. The modeling framework developed in this study can serve as a foundation for the development of more comprehensive GCMs of the ice giants and help guide the interpretation of future mission data. 1 Introduction The ice giants, Uranus and Neptune, are the least explored planets in our Solar System; one flyby of these planets was performed by Voyager 2 in 1986 and 1989, respectively ( Flasar et al. 1987 ; Pearl et al. 1990 ; Pearl & Conrath 1991 ) . Almost 40 years later, following successful missions exploring Saturn and Jupiter, there is increasing attention toward an orbiter mission to these planets ( Ferri et al. 2020 ; Fletcher et al. 2020 ; Dahl et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . Having scarce observations of these planets makes them difficult to study. A main example of the challenges of studying these planets is interpreting the atmospheric flow on these planets. Although both planets have very different internal and solar forcing ( Helled et al. 2020 , e.g.,) , observations suggest that the cloud-level zonal wind structure on these planets is qualitatively similar, with a retrograde flow around the equator and a prograde flow in each hemisphere centered in the midlatitudes ( Hueso & Sánchez-Lavega 2019 , Figure 1 , e.g.,) . The similarity in the observed winds between Uranus and Neptune is puzzling given the different solar forcing (due to their different obliquity) and different internal heating. This observed flow is fundamentally different from the flow observed on the gas giants where there is a broad prograde equatorial jet and multiple jets poleward of it. An additional difference from the gas giants is that in the gas giants the observed banding in the atmosphere is correlated with the different jets ( Duer et al. 2021 ) , while this is not the case in the ice giants ( De Pater et al. 2014 ; Karkoschka 2015 ; Fletcher et al. 2020 ) . This difference might suggest that the ice giants observations are biased or that the relationship between the overturning circulation that is assumed to control the banding and the jets on the ice giants is qualitatively different from the gas giants. Figure 1: Left: Cylindrical projection of the fit to the observed winds down to 0.95 of the planet radii for Uranus (top) and Neptune (bottom). Right: Analytical fit to the observed winds on Uranus ( Sromovsky et al. 2015 , top,) and Neptune ( French et al. 1998 , bottom,) . Fletcher et al. 2020 suggested a qualitative description of the meridional circulation on Uranus and Neptune based on existing observations. However, there is a lack of both observations and modeling work on the ice giants. Only a few efforts have been made to simulate the general circulation of the atmosphere of the ice giants in a global circulation model. Most of these past efforts were part of efforts to simulate the flow on Jupiter and Saturn, and not to directly simulate the circulation of the ice giants. These efforts are generally divided into the use of deep or shallow circulation models, the difference between these efforts being the assumed depth of the atmosphere. In both approaches, the ability to produce a flow that resembles the observed flow is limited. Lian & Showman 2010 and Liu & Schneider 2010 showed in an idealized shallow model a transition from prograde to retrograde equatorial flow using different physical mechanisms; however, the simulated winds there were significantly weaker compared to the observed winds. Aurnou et al. 2007 showed a transition in a deep model from a flow that resembles the one observed on the gas giants to a flow that resembles that observed on the ice giants; however, such models are driven with unrealistic internal heat fluxes, and thus cannot be compared quantitatively to the observed circulation. The choice of the circulation model depends on our understanding of how deep the flow is in these planets. Kaspi et al. 2013 analyzed Voyager 2 gravity measurements and found an upper limit of \sim 1000 km for the depth of the winds. This means that the circulation is limited to the upper 4\% or less of the planet, similarly to the case of Jupiter ( Kaspi et al. 2018 ) . Soyuer et al. 2023 revisited this analysis and found a similar estimate for the depth. Similar estimations for the penetration depth of the winds are supported by magnetic considerations ( Soyuer et al. 2020 ) . These results suggest that a relatively shallow atmosphere model should be sufficient to reproduce the flow on these planets. However, studies using shallow models have not been able to do so. Liu & Schneider 2010 used an idealized model with idealized radiation, dry convection, and forced by annual mean insolation and idealized internal heating. Although they were able to generate a retrograde equatorial jet and approximately one broad jet in the midlatitudes, the winds produced in this model were significantly weaker compared to the observed ones. More recently Milcareck et al. 2024a have used a more complex model that incorporates different parameterizations of physical processes and a realistic radiation scheme with a seasonal cycle. Their results also suffer from weak winds, in addition to having a very complex zonal wind vertical structure that does not fit the observed winds. Having a model that can simulate the flow on Uranus and Neptune is important for the ability to plan future missions and to interpret current and future observations. The challenges in doing so led to this work in which we employ an idealized general circulation model to simulate the atmospheric circulation on the ice giants. In Section 2 we present and motivate the use of the model. In Section 3 we present our