Learning Centre Partitions from Summaries This work was funded by the SPOR National Data Platform
Félix Camirand Lemyre · 2025
Read Learning Centre Partitions from Summaries This work was funded by the SPOR National Data Platform by Félix Camirand Lemyre (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-16337.txt.
Introduction
Multi-site studies often share only site-level summaries, yet sites may not all share the same true values. Zinsou Max Debaly and three co-authors build tests that work from summaries alone to check whether sites match. Their clustering method merges sites only when the tests fail to reject equality, step by step.
A multi-round version rechecks merges on resampled summaries for stability, and theory says it finds the true grouping as data grow. Tests on simulated data and on United States airline delay data from 2007 found sound groupings. Clear stopping rules make the method easy to repeat.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Félix Camirand Lemyre |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 94 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-16337
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Learning Centre Partitions from Summaries This work was funded by the SPOR National Data Platform Félix Camirand Lemyre Abstract Abstract: Multi-centre studies increasingly rely on distributed inference, where sites share only centre-level summaries. Homogeneity of parameters across centres is often violated, motivating methods that both test for equality and learn centre groupings before estimation. We develop multivariate Cochran-type tests that operate on summary statistics and embed them in a sequential, test-driven Clusters-of-Centres (CoC) algorithm that merges centres (or blocks) only when equality is not rejected. We derive the asymptotic \chi^{2} -mixture distributions of the test statistics and provide plug-in estimators for implementation. To improve finite-sample integration, we introduce a multi-round bootstrap CoC that re-evaluates merges across independently resampled summary sets; under mild regularity and a separation condition, we prove a golden-partition recovery result: as the number of rounds grows with n , the true partition is recovered with probability tending to one. We also give simple numerical guidelines, including a plateau-based stopping rule, to make the multi-round procedure reproducible. Simulations and a real-data analysis of U.S. airline on-time performance (2007) show accurate heterogeneity detection and partitions that change little with the choice of resampling scheme. Keywords: Aggregated Estimating Equations; Bootstrap; Heterogeneity Detection; Multivariate Cochran Test. 1 Introduction The proliferation of large-scale, distributed data systems across domains, ranging from healthcare and finance to education, marketing, and the environmental sciences, has transformed the landscape of modern statistical inference. Advances in cloud computing, digital infrastructure, and real-time data acquisition have enabled the collection of massive datasets from geographically dispersed sources. Whether through sensor networks, enterprise data lakes, or nationwide administrative registries, multi-site data generation is now the norm rather than the exception. In parallel, growing societal and legal concerns over privacy, confidentiality, and ethical data use have led to the development of stringent data protection frameworks, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in Europe and the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) in the United States. These frameworks often prohibit the pooling of sensitive, individual-level data into centralized repositories, especially in high-stakes domains involving personal, financial, or health information. As a result, federated or distributed inference paradigms, where data remain local to each site and only aggregate statistics, model summaries, or encrypted representations are exchanged, have emerged as crucial tools for collaborative analytics. These approaches preserve data sovereignty while enabling joint modeling, estimation, and hypothesis testing across multiple centres or organizations. They are particularly well-suited to studies of rare events, subgroup-specific dynamics, or heterogeneous populations, where a single site may lack sufficient data, but combined information can yield robust and generalizable insights. Early distributed inference methods typically relied on straightforward aggregation rules. For instance, the naive average pools local parameter estimates from each centre without sophisticated weighting, whereas inverse-variance weighted (IVW) averaging incorporates estimation uncertainties from each centre to improve statistical efficiency. More advanced approaches have subsequently been developed, such as the communication-efficient surrogate likelihood (CSL) proposed by Jordan et al. 2019 and the aggregated estimating equations (AEE) introduced by Lin and Xi 2011 . These methods significantly enhance estimation accuracy compared to simplistic averaging and reduce communication burdens. For a comprehensive overview, see the recent review work by Gao et al. 2022 . A critical challenge in multi-centre analyses is inherent heterogeneity among data centres. Variations in data collection protocols, patient demographics, and equipment calibration lead to systematic differences across sites, complicating straightforward aggregation. Ignoring such heterogeneity can introduce biases and obscure clinically meaningful variations. Despite extensive data harmonization efforts, such as the Observational Health Data Sciences and Informatics (OHDSI)’s Observational Medical Outcomes Partnership (OMOP) common data model, heterogeneity often persists. Traditionally, Cochran’s Q test (see, for example, Kulinskaya et al. 2011 ) has been employed to detect inter-study heterogeneity in meta-analyses and can be adapted for multi-centre studies. This test evaluates whether discrepancies among site-specific estimates exceed expectations from sampling variability alone. However, Cochran’s Q test and its random-effects model extensions ( Higgins and Thompson 2002 ) are inherently univariate, assessing single parameters or outcomes independently and thus overlooking covariance structures among multiple correlated parameters. Multivariate extensions ( Gasparrini et al. 2012 ) primarily test for the existence of random effects rather than directly assessing the equality of parameter vectors across multiple centres. To our knowledge, no multivariate Cochran-type test explicitly designed to test parameter equality in a distributed inference context exists in the literature, likely due to traditional meta-analysis settings’ limited availability of detailed summary statistics, prompting reliance on parameter-by-parameter univariate tests. Recent works in distributed inference address heterogeneity primarily through two distinct approaches. The first involves designing estimation procedures that aim to identify a prevailing common parameter among the centre-specific parameters, treating the remaining parameters as outliers. For instance, Minsker 2019 proposed a robust estimator at the aggregation stage, while Guo et al. 2025 developed a two-step procedure that first selects centres sharing the prevailing parameter via a data-driven criterion and subsequently performs post-selection inference using resampling methods. These approaches generally assume that at least K/2 centres share the same true parameter; see Assumption 1 in Guo et al. 2025 or Section 2.4.1 in Minsker 2019 . Our goal is different: we learn the full centre partition. Our paper introduces a novel perspective suitable for highly heterogeneous settings, explicitly accommodating the extreme scenario in which each centre defines its own parameter. The second approach posits a global model encompassing both centre-specific nuisance parameters and globally common parameters. Examples include the fully parametric distributed modeling framework of Gu and Chen 2023 and the semi-parametric partially linear framework studied by Zhao et al. 2016 . However, such frameworks currently lack explicit guidelines to differentiate between parameters that are genuinely common and those that are heterogeneous. Closely related to our setting, Chen et al. 2024 recently considered clustering of centres with a focus on high–dimensional models. They propose a penalized estimator that simultaneously performs variable selection (e.g., via a SCAD penalty) and convex–clustering–based fusion. However, the stated guarantees require nontrivial prior knowledge of the oracle grouping structure, such as lower and upper bounds on cluster sizes, to specify tuning parameters appropriately ( Chen et al. 2024 , Theorems 1–2) . Moreover, parameter consistency does not by itself ensure clustering consistency: although convex clustering admits a unique solution for each tuning level, that solution depends on the tuning parameter, and for sufficiently large values all centres may be merged into a single cluster even when the underlying parameters differ. By contrast, our test-based merging method is free of tuning parameters and recovers true partition of centres (see Theorem 1). Overview of contributions. In this paper, we (i) derive multivariate Cochran-type global and two-block integration tests for equality of parameter vectors that operate on centre-level summaries statistics; (ii) propose a test-driven clustering algorithm (CoC-algorithm) that merges blocks only when equality is not rejected, with a deterministic largest- p tie-break; (iii) prove a golden-partition recovery result for multi-round CoC-algorithm based on bootstrap resamples , under standard regularity and a separation between true blocks, \mathbb{P}\!\big(\widehat{\mathcal{C}_{n}}^{(R(n))}=\mathcal{P}\big)\to 1 where \widehat{\mathcal{C}_{n}}^{(R(n))} is the estimated partition from multi-round CoC-algorithm consisting in R(n) rounds and \mathcal{P} the true underlying partition. 1.1 Notation Throughout, \Rightarrow denotes convergence in distribution. For a vector u and a positive–semidefinite matrix \Sigma ,