Non-Commutation Chains in Pre- and Post-Selection Paradoxes This paper is part of a dissertation submitted in fulfillment of the requirements of a degree Master of Science in Mathematics and Foundations of Computer Science University of Oxford, Trinity Term 2024
Ouissal Moumou · 2025
Read Non-Commutation Chains in Pre- and Post-Selection Paradoxes This paper is part of a dissertation submitted in fulfillment of the requirements of a degree Master of Science in Mathematics and Foundations of Computer Science University of Oxford, Trinity Term 2024 by Ouissal Moumou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-16258.txt.
Introduction
Quantum systems that are both pre-selected and post-selected can yield measurement results that seem to defy logic. Ouissal Moumou proves a conjecture about these paradoxes for a restricted case of the logical type. The proof shows that every such paradox in that case contains a chain of measurements that do not commute, meaning their order matters.
The work also links the finding to a recent theory of causal balance. That theory is shown to block the paradoxes in question. Pinning paradoxes to non-commuting chains gives a concrete handle on a puzzling corner of quantum theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ouissal Moumou |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-16258
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Non-Commutation Chains in Pre- and Post-Selection Paradoxes This paper is part of a dissertation submitted in fulfillment of the requirements of a degree Master of Science in Mathematics and Foundations of Computer Science University of Oxford, Trinity Term 2024 Ouissal Moumou Abstract Peculiar measurements can be obtained on systems that undergo both pre- and post-selection. We prove a conjecture from [ 1 ] on logical Pre- and Post-Selection (PPS) paradoxes for a restricted case. We prove that all of these paradoxes admit non-commutation chains. We also relate this to the theory of causal balance, recently introduced in [ 1 ] , and show how the theory blocks such paradoxes. 1 Introduction Suppose a quantum system is pre-selected in the state |\psi\rangle at time t_{0} and post-selected in the state \langle\phi| at time t_{2} . Suppose also that the system undergoes an intermediate projective measurement \{\mathit{P}\} at time t_{1} . One could calculate the probability of the intermediate measurement by conditioning both on the pre- and post-selection, this is the main spirit behind the ABL rule introduced in [ 2 ] . For a degenerate operator C at time t , the probability of obtaining an outcome c_{n} is specified by the ABL rule as P(C)=\frac{|\langle\phi|P_{C=c_{n}}|\psi\rangle|^{2}}{\sum_{i}|\langle\phi|P_{C=c_{i}}|\psi\rangle|^{2}}, (1) where P_{C=c_{i}}=\sum_{i}|\Phi\rangle\langle\Phi| is the projection on the states with eigenvalue c_{i} . Peculiar situations arise for specific choices of |\psi\rangle , \{\mathit{P}\} , and \langle\phi| in which the probabilities obtained are non-intuitive. These situations are referred to as pre- and post-selection paradoxes. [ 1 ] posited that these paradoxes are absent within the framework of causal balance theory, as this theoretical framework inherently avoids what we term “non-commutation chains” in the present work. A non-commutation chain, which we define rigorously in Section 3 , arises when the intermediate projection operator in a pre- and post-selection scenario fails to commute with both the pre-selected and post-selected quantum states. We establish a proof for a restricted subset of Ormrod’s conjecture from [ 1 ] , demonstrating that all paradoxes within this constrained class exhibit a systematic occurrence of non-commutation chains. We start with the quantum pigeonhole principle as an exemplar of these paradoxes to provide intuitive understanding, followed by a formal definition of pre- and post-selection phenomena that establishes the theoretical foundation for our subsequent proof. We conclude with a discussion of the implications and directions for future research. 1.1 The Quantum Pigeonhole Principle Paradox [ 3 ] introduced the quantum pigeonhole principle in which 3 particles are prepared in a superposition state of being in 2 different boxes. Boxes 1 and 2 are represented by |0\rangle and |1\rangle respectively. A superposition of being in both boxes 1 and 1 would then be represented more conveniently with |+\rangle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(|0\rangle+|1\rangle) . Therefore, the states corresponding to the pre- and post-selection states are \displaystyle|\psi\rangle \displaystyle={|+\rangle}_{1}{|+\rangle}_{2}{|+\rangle}_{3}, \displaystyle\langle\phi| \displaystyle={\langle i|}_{1}{\langle i|}_{2}{\langle i|}_{3}, respectively, where \langle i|=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\langle 0|+i\langle 1|) . We aim to check whether two particles are in the same box. Since the three particles are in the same initial and final states, we will only demonstrate the paradox for particles 1 and 2. By symmetry, the same applies for particles 2 and 3 and particles 1 and 3. Particles 1 and 2 being in the same box means that they are either both in box 1, or both in box 2 which we represent with projectors P_{11}={|0\rangle}_{1}{|0\rangle}_{2}{\langle 0|}_{1}{\langle 0|}_{2} and P_{22}={|1\rangle}_{1}{|1\rangle}_{2}{\langle 1|}_{1}{\langle 1|}_{2} respectively. On the other hand, particles 1 and 2 being in separate boxes means particle 1 is in box 1 and particle 2 is in box 2, or vice versa, which we represent with projectors P_{12}={|0\rangle}_{1}{|1\rangle}_{2}{\langle 1|}_{1}{\langle 0|}_{2} and P_{21}={|1\rangle}_{1}{|0\rangle}_{2}{\langle 1|}_{1}{\langle 0|}_{2} respectively. Consequently, the two particles under consideration being in the same box corresponds to the projector P_{\text{same}}=P_{11}+P_{22} . Similarly, the two particles being in different boxes correspond to the projector P_{\text{diff}}=P_{12}+P_{21} . Because the value of \langle\phi|P_{\text{same}}\ket{\psi} turns out to be zero, it follows that the probability of finding particles 1 and 2 in the same box using the ABL rule is also zero. Considering the symmetry in our example with the other particles, this means that the probability of finding particles 2 and 3 in the same box in the intermediate measurement is also zero, and so is the probability of finding both particles 1 and 3 in the same box. One then is prompted to conclude that it is with certainty that we observe that no two particles can be found in the same box. However, recalling the very basic yet powerful pigeonhole principle, it is quite peculiar to have two boxes and three particles. Yet, no two particles share the same box! 2 Pre- and Post-Selection Paradoxes: A Formal Definition Below is a formal definition of a pre- and post-selection paradox inspired from [ 4 ] . Consider a Hilbert space, a choice of pre-selection |\psi\rangle and post-selection \langle\phi| , and let \mathcal{P} be a finite set of projectors closed under complements composed of the projectors related to the pre- and post-selection system \{P,I-P\} that are uniquely determined by the projectors P . We only consider the cases in which the ABL probabilities corresponding to using the projectors \{P,I-P\} yield 0 or 1 values (hence the “logical” part). We would like to be able to generate a partial Boolean algebra \mathcal{P^{\prime}} from \mathcal{P} using the following for any P and Q in \mathcal{P^{\prime}} : • If P,Q\in\mathcal{P^{\prime}} and PQ=QP , then PQ\in\mathcal{P^{\prime}} , • If P\in\mathcal{P^{\prime}} , then I-P\in\mathcal{P^{\prime}} . One intuitive way of understanding the new partial Boolean algebra is by considering projectors corresponding to propositions, and the extension to the partial Boolean algebra is our way of wanting to also take disjunctions and conjunctions of the propositions at hand (we originally only had the propositions and their complements given to us by the experiments). Suppose we want to extend the probability function f given to us by the ABL rule from \mathcal{P} to \mathcal{P^{\prime}} . In other words, we want to find a probability function on \mathcal{P^{\prime}} that recovers the probability function defined on \mathcal{P} , such that the following algebraic conditions are satisfied: (i) For all P\in\mathcal{P^{\prime}} , 0\leq f(P)\leq 1 , (ii) f(I)=1 and f(0)=0 , (iii) For all P,Q\in\mathcal{P^{\prime}} , f(P+Q-PQ)=f(P)+f(Q)-f(QP) . Definition 2.1 . (PPS Paradox) Assuming the above setting, we say that the ABL predictions for \mathcal{P} form a logical PPS paradox when we fail to find a function that fails one or more of the algebraic conditions above. Applying this to the case of the pigeonhole principle paradox: the projectors corresponding to two particles being in different boxes P_{\text{diff}_{1,2}} , P_{\text{diff}_{1,2}} , and P_{\text{diff}_{1,2}} . We know that: f(P_{\text{diff}_{1,2}})=1 , f(P_{\text{diff}_{1,2}})=1 , and f(P_{\text{diff}_{1,2}})=1 . We know that p(e)=1 and p(f)=1\implies p(e\land f)=1 . This can be extended in our case of three events, and knowing that the probabilities for these events are all 1 , we can conclude that f(P_{\text{diff}_{1,2}}P_{\text{diff}_{2,3}}P_{\text{diff}_{1,3}})=1. However, note that: P_{\text{diff}_{1,2}}P_{\text{diff}_{2,3}}P_{\text{diff}_{1,3}}=0 . Therefore, f(0)=1 , which violates condition (i) from Definition 2.1 . Thus, the quantum pigeonhole principle is just another instance of logical PPS paradoxes. 3 PPS Paradoxes Admit Non-Commutation Chains We start with the following definition of a non-commutation chain: Definition 3.1 . (Non-Commutation Chain) A projector P