Unified dark fluid with null sound speed as an alternative to phantom dark energy
and Antony Lewis · 2025
Read Unified dark fluid with null sound speed as an alternative to phantom dark energy by and Antony Lewis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-16155.txt.
Introduction
New sky surveys hint that dark energy may change over time and may even cross into a strange phantom state. Raphaël Kou and Antony Lewis test a simpler story: one unified dark fluid that acts as both dark matter and dark energy. Their fluid has no sound speed and no uneven stress, yet it matches the same growth history of the universe.
Fits to data from space and ground surveys come close to the standard evolving model, without any phantom part. Growth of cosmic structure also looks much the same. Telling the two stories apart will be hard, even for the next wave of surveys.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | and Antony Lewis |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-16155
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unified dark fluid with null sound speed as an alternative to phantom dark energy and Antony Lewis Abstract Recent BAO measurements from DESI, when combined with CMB and supernovae data, suggest evolving dark energy and in particular point to a possible phantom regime, with an equation of state parameter w < − 1 w<-1 . This behaviour is theoretically problematic, as it violates the null energy condition and typically leads to instabilities in the perturbations. We explore an alternative phenomenological way to model dark matter and dark energy based on a unified dark fluid (UDF). By construction, our model reproduces the same background expansion history as DESI’s best-fit using the Chevallier–Polarski–Linder (CPL) parametrization, but assumes a vanishing rest-frame sound speed and no anisotropic stress. This simple prescription ensures a consistent and physical treatment of perturbations, and the use of a unified dark sector avoids phantom behaviour by construction. We model CMB, large-scale structure, and redshift-space distortion observables, and find differences with CPL that are typically at the few-percent level. As a result, we forecast that even stage IV CMB and galaxy surveys will have limited power to discriminate between our UDF and CPL at the linear level. At the non-linear level, we study spherical collapse in the UDF and show that within this framework, structure formation proceeds very similarly to standard scenarios. Using Planck, DESI BAO DR2, and DESY5 supernovae data, we demonstrate that this simple UDF model fits current observations nearly as well as CPL, while treating perturbations consistently. Because most cosmological observations are not sensitive to how the dark sector is split, the unified framework can also approximate the phenomenology of interacting dark energy–dark matter scenarios or evolving dark matter, making it a general way to model the data, at least as long as the dark components have a vanishing sound speed, which is the most distinctive feature of our analysis. This highlights that a unified dark fluid with evolving equation of state and null sound speed is sufficient to pass current constraints without a phantom component. 1 Introduction The nature of the dark energy responsible for cosmic acceleration remains uncertain. While the cosmological constant is still consistent with many observations, recent Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) measurements from the DESI collaboration [ 1 ] , in combination with Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and supernovae data, have shown interesting hints for evolving dark energy. Modelling the dark energy equation of state through the Chevallier-Polarski-Linder (CPL) parametrization [ 2 , 3 ] \displaystyle w(a)=w_{0}+w_{a}(1-a), (1.1) they found a preference for phantom crossing dark energy [ 4 ] , where the dark energy equation of state, being greater than -1 at low redshift, becomes lower than -1 at high redshift. This hint for phantom crossing is not only found with the CPL parametrization, but is also preferred when using other analytical parametrizations or when reconstructing the equation of state with Gaussian processes, redshift bins or splines [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] . Phantom crossing dark energy therefore seems to be favoured in order to reproduce the background expansion of the Universe suggested by the data. This preference for phantom dark energy is however problematic for several reasons. Firstly, the density of a phantom dark energy increases over time, and thus violates the Null Energy Condition (NEC) [ 10 , 11 ] , which would have dramatic consequences for our understanding of physics. Secondly, even though the preference for phantom dark energy relies mainly on observations of the background expansion of the Universe, describing the perturbations in this regime is very tricky as phantom dark energy tends to induce singularities in the perturbations. Background expansion measurements, such as with BAO and supernovae, are only sensitive to the evolution of the total energy density of the Universe as determined by the Friedmann–Lemaître equations. They do not depend on how this density is divided among the various components. In particular, such observations cannot distinguish how the total dark sector is split between dark matter and dark energy. This indeterminacy leaves us free to partition the dark sector in different ways, a freedom known as the “dark degeneracy” [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . Combining dark matter and dark energy in a unified dark fluid is therefore equivalent at the background level, and avoids the need for phantom components, as we shall see in section 2 . This approach can therefore reproduce the background expansion preferred by recent measurements, while describing the perturbations in a physical way and without violating the NEC. We present our theoretical model in section 2 , before investigating its effect on CMB and Large-Scale Structure (LSS) observations in section 3 . We constrain this model using recent data and compare it to the standard CPL model in section 4 . Finding very similar results between our unified model and CPL, we test whether those two models will be distinguishable with stage IV data in section 5 . Finally, in section 6 we study the theoretical predictions of the spherical collapse with our model, to test whether it can reproduce small-scale structure formation. 2 Theoretical model In this work, we describe the density content of the Universe through different components, namely radiation ( \Omega_{r} ), baryons ( \Omega_{b} ), massive neutrinos ( \Omega_{\nu} ) and a Unified Dark Fluid (UDF) ( \Omega_{\textrm{UDF}} ). The Friedmann-Lemaître equation therefore follows \displaystyle H^{2}(a)=H_{0}^{2}\left[\Omega_{r}a^{-4}+\Omega_{b}a^{-3}+\Omega_{\nu}(a)+\Omega_{\textrm{UDF}}(a)\right], (2.1) where H(a) is the Hubble rate at a scale factor a and H_{0} is the Hubble rate today ( a=1 ). The UDF modelling relies on the generalized dark matter approach [ 19 ] , in which a fluid can be described at the background and perturbation levels by setting the fluid’s equation of state, sound speed, and anisotropic stress. In particular, in order to reproduce the background expansion described in the CPL parametrization, we impose \displaystyle w_{\textrm{UDF}}(a) \displaystyle=\frac{\Omega_{\textrm{de}}(a)w_{\textrm{de}}(a)+\Omega_{c}(a)w_{c}(a)}{\Omega_{\textrm{de}}(a)+\Omega_{c}(a)} (2.2) \displaystyle=\frac{\Omega_{\textrm{de}}e^{-3w_{a}(1-a)}a^{-3(1+w_{0}+w_{a})}(w_{0}+w_{a}(1-a))}{\Omega_{\textrm{de}}e^{-3w_{a}(1-a)}a^{-3(1+w_{0}+w_{a})}+\Omega_{c}a^{-3}}, (2.3) where (\Omega_{\textrm{de}},w_{\textrm{de}}) and (\Omega_{c},w_{c}) are the dark energy and cold dark matter density and equation of state parameters in the non-unified case, using CPL to parametrize the dark energy evolution. Note that the parameters \Omega_{c} , w_{0} and w_{a} are only used here to parametrize the equation of state of the UDF, and are not used in any other equation. We also clarify that for convenience, whenever we refer to CPL, we implicitly think about the non-unified model in which dark matter is assumed to be cold, and dark energy is parametrized with the CPL model. We hence loosely use the acronym “CPL” instead of “CPL+CDM”. Figure 1 : UDF equation of state evolution with scale factor. For comparison, we also show the dark matter and dark energy equations of state as a function of scale factor. The dark energy equation of state corresponds to the best-fit to DESI BAO DR2, Planck CMB and DESY5 supernovae obtained in the CPL parametrization. Figure 1 shows the evolution of the equation of state of the UDF as a function of scale factor, using the best-fit values for w_{0} , w_{a} and \Omega_{c} obtained using Planck (PR4 NPIPE [ 20 ] at high multipoles, 2018 [ 21 ] at low multipoles), DESI BAO DR2 [