Rethinking Molecule Synthesizability with Chain-of-Reaction

Seul Lee² ∗ , Karsten Kreis¹, Srimukh Prasad Veccham¹, Meng Liu¹, Danny Reidenbach¹, Saee Paliwal¹, Weili Nie¹ † , Arash Vahdat¹ † ¹ NVIDIA ² KAIST · 2025

Read Rethinking Molecule Synthesizability with Chain-of-Reaction by Seul Lee² ∗ , Karsten Kreis¹, Srimukh Prasad Veccham¹, Meng Liu¹, Danny Reidenbach¹, Saee Paliwal¹, Weili Nie¹ † , Arash Vahdat¹ † ¹ NVIDIA ² KAIST (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-16084.txt.

Introduction

Computer-designed molecules often cannot be made in a real lab, which limits their use in drug work. Seul Lee and seven co-authors present ReaSyn, a method that reshapes a target molecule into one with a workable building plan. Plans are written as trees that can be grown from the bottom up or the top down with one model.

A second stage edits whole plans by adding, removing, or swapping steps. In tests, ReaSyn led on rebuilding known makeable molecules and on goal-driven search. It also beat prior tools at growing new hits. The cycle of builds and edits explores a huge space with care.

Catalog record

CREATORSeul Lee² ∗ , Karsten Kreis¹, Srimukh Prasad Veccham¹, Meng Liu¹, Danny Reidenbach¹, Saee Paliwal¹, Weili Nie¹ † , Arash Vahdat¹ † ¹ NVIDIA ² KAIST
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-16084

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rethinking Molecule Synthesizability with Chain-of-Reaction Seul Lee² ∗ , Karsten Kreis¹, Srimukh Prasad Veccham¹, Meng Liu¹, Danny Reidenbach¹, Saee Paliwal¹, Weili Nie¹ † , Arash Vahdat¹ † ¹ NVIDIA ² KAIST Abstract Abstract: A well-known pitfall of molecular generative models is that they are not guaranteed to generate synthesizable molecules. There have been considerable attempts to address this problem, but given the exponentially large combinatorial space of synthesizable molecules, existing methods have shown limited coverage of the space and poor molecular optimization performance. To tackle these problems, we introduce ReaSyn, a generative framework for synthesizable projection where the model explores the neighborhood of given molecules in the synthesizable space by generating pathways that result in synthesizable analogs. To fully utilize the chemical knowledge contained in the synthetic pathways, we propose a novel perspective that views synthetic pathways akin to reasoning paths in large language models (LLMs). Specifically, inspired by chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning in LLMs, we introduce the chain-of-reaction (CoR) notation that explicitly states reactants, reaction types, and intermediate products for each step in a pathway. With the CoR notation, ReaSyn can get dense supervision in every reaction step to explicitly learn chemical reaction rules during supervised training and perform step-by-step reasoning. In addition, to further enhance the reasoning capability of ReaSyn, we propose reinforcement learning (RL)-based finetuning and goal-directed test-time compute scaling tailored for synthesizable projection. ReaSyn achieves the highest reconstruction rate and pathway diversity in synthesizable molecule reconstruction and the highest optimization performance in synthesizable goal-directed molecular optimization, and significantly outperforms previous synthesizable projection methods in synthesizable hit expansion. These results highlight ReaSyn’s superior ability to navigate combinatorially-large synthesizable chemical space. 1 Introduction Discovering molecules with desired properties in the chemical space comprises the core of drug discovery. However, drug discovery pipelines are often very challenging and labor-intensive due to their vast design space and multi-objective nature. Molecular generative models have recently emerged as a notable breakthrough with the potential to greatly accelerate the drug discovery process. While promising, the practical impact of molecular generative models has remained limited as they share a common problem: generated drug candidates are often synthetically inaccessible [ 13 , 51 ] . This problem arises from neglecting synthesizability during multi-objective molecular optimization, which often leads to exploration outside the synthesizable chemical space. A common strategy to alleviate this issue is to incorporate synthesizability as an additional optimization objective by quantitatively estimating synthesizability [ 11 , 5 , 48 ] . However, this approach is largely impractical since the heuristic synthesizability scores are far from reasonable proxies, as synthesizability is non-linear with structural changes and they cannot take available building block stocks or reaction selectivity into account [ 13 ] . An alternative approach is to constrain the design space to those that are synthetically accessible [ 47 , 27 , 7 , 42 ] , but existing methods that take this approach commonly sacrifice explorability, optimization performance, and controllability in the synthesizable chemical space. A more effective strategy for synthesizable molecule design is to project molecules into the synthesizable space [ 14 , 36 , 46 , 16 ] . In this strategy, often called synthesizable projection or synthesizable analog generation, a model learns to correct unsynthesizable molecules by generating synthetic pathways that lead to synthesizable analogs that are structurally similar to given molecules, thereby ensuring synthesizability under predefined sets of reactions and building blocks. This strategy benefit from its versatile and modular nature and can be used with any off-the-shelf molecular generative method to improve its practicality in real-world drug discovery. It can also be applied to explore neighborhoods in the synthesizable space, allowing the model to perform hit expansion or lead optimization. However, existing methods for synthesizable analog generation do not fully utilize the information from the chemical reactions in synthetic pathways and have shown limited coverage of synthesizable space, as observed in the low reconstruction rates of synthesizable molecules [ 3 , 14 , 36 , 16 ] . While reactants, a reaction rule, and a product together define a chemical reaction, previous methods consider only some of these key components by omitting intermediate product molecules or reaction rules in synthetic pathways, i.e., they show insufficient reasoning capability on their synthetic pathways. To tackle these limitations, we introduce ReaSyn 1 1 1 Inspired of the reasoning nature of our problem, ReaSyn is pronounced similar to “reason”. , a framework for effective synthesizable molecular projection with reasoning (Figure 1 ). Motivated by recent advances in large language model (LLM) reasoning, ReaSyn employs step-by-step thinking akin to chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning [ 53 ] , where each step is a single reaction in a multi-step synthetic pathway. Specifically, ReaSyn utilizes the chain-of-reaction (CoR) notation of synthesis where a full synthetic pathway is represented as a sequence that contains information of reactants, reaction type, and intermediate products of each reaction step as its subsequences (Figure 2 (b)). Used in conjunction with autoregressive modeling with a Transformer architecture [ 50 ] , the proposed CoR notation essentially views synthetic pathways as CoT reasoning paths of an LLM. Unlike previous synthetic pathway representations, our CoR notation explicitly incorporates the knowledge on step-by-step reaction rules by directly including intermediate molecules obtained from an external reaction executor, such as the RDKit library [ 29 ] . By imposing extra supervision on these intermediate molecules, the model can explicitly learn the chemical rules with richer supervision signals. Moreover, viewing synthetic pathway generation as LLM reasoning, the CoR notation also allows us to adopt techniques from LLM reasoning such as outcome-based reinforcement learning (RL) finetuning and test-time compute scaling, which we tailor here for improved synthesizable projection with ReaSyn. We experimentally validate the effectiveness and versatility of ReaSyn on various tasks including synthesizable molecule reconstruction, synthesizable goal-directed molecular optimization, and synthesizable hit expansion. ReaSyn outperforms existing methods with superior reconstruction rate and pathway diversity in synthesizable molecule reconstruction, and achieves state-of-the-art performance in finding synthesizable chemical optima in synthesizable goal-directed molecular optimization and hit expansion. All these results indicate that ReaSyn has broader coverage and powerful explorability of the synthesizable chemical space, highlighting its efficacy as a practical tool in real-world drug discovery scenarios. We summarize our contributions as follows: • We propose ReaSyn, a framework for synthesizable projection that uses the CoR notation of synthesis to view synthetic pathways as CoT reasoning paths. • We propose RL finetuning and test-time compute scaling schemes tailored for projecting molecules into the synthesizable space to further enhance the performance of ReaSyn. • We demonstrate the effectiveness and versatility of ReaSyn in various synthesizable molecule generation and optimization tasks through extensive experiments. Figure 1 : The overall framework of ReaSyn. ReaSyn adopts an encoder-decoder Transformer architecture. After the Transformer encoder encodes the given target molecule, the Transformer decoder autoregressively predicts the synthetic pathways of its synthesizable analog in the CoR notation. ReaSyn has access to a reaction executor that yields the intermediate products with the predicted building blocks and reaction type. The CoR notation provides the model intermediate supervision during training and extra reasoning during inference. Figure 2 : Comparison of the postfix notation and the CoR notation. [START] and [END] tokens are omitted for simplicity. The postfix notation [ 36 , 16

Read the complete text