A Systematic Survey of Empirical User Studies of Unintentional Information Disclosure in Everyday Digital Interaction

Reza Shahriari, Eric D. Ragan · 2025

Read A Systematic Survey of Empirical User Studies of Unintentional Information Disclosure in Everyday Digital Interaction by Reza Shahriari, Eric D. Ragan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-16003.txt.

Introduction

People often share private facts online without meaning to, and that slip can lead to theft or misuse of their data. Reza Shahriari and Eric D. Ragan survey past user studies on this kind of unwanted sharing. Their review covers 101 papers from six top meetings held between 2018 and 2023.

The survey sorts studies by method, both number-based and talk-based, and by topic area. Hot topics include data privacy, web browser safety, and privacy tools. By comparing study styles, the authors map where research effort has gone. Their map can guide new work on ways to cut the risks of daily online life.

Catalog record

CREATORReza Shahriari, Eric D. Ragan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-16003

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Systematic Survey of Empirical User Studies of Unintentional Information Disclosure in Everyday Digital Interaction Reza Shahriari, Eric D. Ragan Abstract The exchange of personal information in digital environments poses significant risks, including identity theft, privacy breaches, and data misuse. Addressing these challenges requires a deep understanding of user behavior and mental models in diverse contexts. This paper presents a systematic literature review of empirical user studies on unintentional information disclosure in usable security, covering 101 papers published across six leading conferences from 2018 to 2023. The studies are categorized based on methodologies—quantitative and qualitative—and analyzed for their applications in various scenarios. Major subtopics, including data privacy, security in browsers, and privacy tools, are examined to highlight research trends and focal areas. This review provides details on topics and application areas that have received the most research attention. Moreover, by comparing descriptive and experimental approaches, findings aim to guide researchers of strategies to mitigate risks associated with online everyday interaction. K eywords Usable Security \cdot Human-Computer Interaction 1 Introduction Online browsing and app usage are integral to both our personal and professional lives as people depend on various tools and applications to navigate the digital world. Engaging in activities such as exchanging, submitting, and sharing information through emails [ Wash et al.(2021) , Mayer et al.(2021) ] , social media [ Minaei et al.(2022) , Amon et al.(2020) ] , or other digital platforms [ Emami-Naeini et al.(2021) , Yang et al.(2022) ] is commonplace. However, the online exchange of information comes with significant challenges and risks, particularly concerning privacy and security. There is always a potential for unauthorized access and data breaches, which can lead to the release of personal and sensitive information, resulting in identity theft, financial loss, and other malicious activities. To address online privacy and security issues, people adopt various protective behaviors [ Youn(2005) , Chen et al.(2017) ] . These include downloading apps only from reliable and trusted sources and ensuring that the software they use meets high security and privacy standards. Additionally, they may seek to stay informed about potential threats by keeping up with security incidents affecting their families, friends, or the broader community, which helps them identify and avoid similar risks [ Mehrnezhad et al.(2022) , Youn(2005) ] . Furthermore, they adjust their privacy settings to control who can access their information and posts, and they exercise caution before sharing personal details that malicious parties could misuse [ Ebert et al.(2023) , Chen et al.(2017) ] . Despite these efforts, only a limited number of users consistently familiarize themselves with or follow these risk prevention measures. Therefore, it is crucial to develop software and tools with well-established default security standards to minimize risks. Understanding how people engage with the digital world is essential for identifying specific challenges. The field of usable security and privacy (USP) helps identify these challenges at the intersection of human behavior and digital security [ Sasse and Flechais(2005) ] . USP helps security experts focus on critical risk areas, enabling more analysis of people’s behavioral patterns and ultimately enhancing overall online safety. While USP is a broad research area, this review specifically concentrates on the subtopic of online information disclosure in everyday digital interactions. We use the term information disclosure to describe situations in which users, often unintentionally, reveal personal or sensitive data through routine online activities such as web browsing, email, or social media use. This focus reflects a consistent pattern in prior empirical studies, which examine how users make decisions about sharing, withholding, or managing data in digital environments. Studying this area is critical because users’ privacy and security are shaped not only by technical safeguards but also by individual choices about data sharing and software settings. Additionally, people may struggle to grasp the nuances of potential information disclosure through different problems, vulnerabilities, and risks. The dependencies on various applications and types of data further complicate this understanding. Because of the need to understand user choice, human-subjects research methodology is commonly employed to study user behaviors and thinking. Different choices of user studies, such as controlled experiments using hypothetical cases or surveys that reflect more realistic personal experiences, provide varying degrees of control and insight. Experiments may offer more control but often rely on hypothetical scenarios, whereas surveys, though less controlled, may capture more authentic personal experiences. Differences in user study types directly affect the knowledge gained, making it crucial to consider the overlap among methods applied, research subtopics focused on, and types of applications studied. This review aims to highlight the value of a systematic literature review in organizing and assessing the research methods applied across different areas of information disclosure. This will assist future researchers in selecting practical approaches for their studies and ultimately help lower users’ online risks. It provides an overview of areas that have received more attention and identifies key topics that could benefit from future work by providing evidence of what research methods have been most effected in different areas. The review spans six leading research conferences in security and human-computer interaction in recent years (2018–2023), filtering from a total of 8185 papers to 101 papers given detailed analysis. We focus on empirical studies involving people, emphasizing the various methods used to conduct user studies. Each method offers unique benefits and limitations. Users have diverse experiences and perspectives that influence their disclosure decisions, which might vary significantly between laboratory settings and real-world contexts. Personal past experiences differ from hypothetical scenarios, and there are distinct challenges in understanding risk when dealing with hypothetical cases versus real personal information. 2 Background 2.1 Overview of Usable Security and Privacy USP aims to make security and privacy mechanisms both accessible and effective by balancing robust protection with user-friendly design. This necessitates a review of key areas where information is at higher risk of disclosure due to the nature of information exchanged or shared. One common topic within USP is authentication , which focuses on securing users’ online accounts and data by verifying their identities [ Ur et al.(2017) , Bhana and Flowerday(2020) , Liu et al.(2019) ] . For instance, when a user logs into an email account, the authentication process ensures that the user is who they claim to be, typically through passwords or other verification methods. In this context, a significant contribution to USP was the development and evaluation of a data-driven password meter, which measures the strength of passwords and provides users with actionable feedback to enhance password security [ Ur et al.(2017) ] . Another crucial subarea in USP is the study of user behavior for security and privacy. This refers to the actions or decisions that individuals take that affect their privacy or data security. For instance, Wu et al. [ Wu et al.(2018) ] explored how the explanations provided by browsers about private browsing modes shape users’ misconceptions and beliefs. Many users incorrectly assumed that private browsing would prevent geolocation tracking, protect against malware, eliminate advertisements, and stop tracking by websites and network providers. Moreover, differences between expert and non-expert users of the Tor Anonymity Network emphasize the importance of understanding how Tor works to mitigate risks [ Gallagher et al.(2017) ] . Experts have a technical understanding

Read the complete text