Pedagogical study of the image of a magnetic dipole in front of a superconducting sphere

Hemansh Alkesh Shah, Kolahal Bhattacharya · 2025

Read Pedagogical study of the image of a magnetic dipole in front of a superconducting sphere by Hemansh Alkesh Shah, Kolahal Bhattacharya (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-15528.txt.

Introduction

Hemansh Alkesh Shah and Kolahal Bhattacharya write a teaching study on a magnet near a superconducting ball. Students worldwide learn the method of images for electric charges near metal balls. The same trick can solve magnet problems, but textbooks rarely show it. A magnetic dipole near such a ball is a good case: the source has direction, unlike a point charge.

The pair solve the case where the dipole points straight at the ball with a single image dipole. For the sideways case, they model the dipole as a loop of current. They find images for the loop's parts that meet the edge rules. From those parts they deduce the image dipoles for the sideways case. The study suits class use.

Catalog record

CREATORHemansh Alkesh Shah, Kolahal Bhattacharya
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-15528

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pedagogical study of the image of a magnetic dipole in front of a superconducting sphere Hemansh Alkesh Shah, Kolahal Bhattacharya Abstract The method of images to solve certain electrostatic boundary-value problems is taught worldwide in undergraduate-level physics courses. Though it is also possible to employ this technique for solving magnetostatic boundary value problems, examples of this usage are rarely found in textbooks or physics pedagogy literature. In particular, the problem of finding the field due to a magnetic dipole kept in front of a superconducting sphere is an interesting one, because (i) it helps the students to compare with the grounded conducting sphere image problem in electrostatics, and (ii) offers a greater degree of difficulty since the source is a dipole (vector), rather than an electric charge (scalar). The present work demonstrates an intuitive way of solving the problem. The case in which the source dipole is oriented radially with respect to the sphere is solved with a single dipole image. In the case of the transverse orientation of the source dipole, we model the dipole as a current loop. Then, we find the image of the radial and transverse current elements that satisfy the boundary conditions. Then, we show that this method can be used to deduce the form of the image dipoles when the dipole is oriented in the transverse direction. This method is very much intuitive and accessible for undergraduate-level students. Keywords : Method of images, superconductivity. 1 Introduction The method of images is an elegant technique to solve electrostatic boundary value problems. One can calculate the field or potential when a known charge distribution is placed near a surface (for example, a conducting body). The boundary condition on the surface is given, but the charge induced on the surface is unknown. The tricky job is accomplished by asserting that the field can be expressed as a sum of the field due to the known charge distribution, as well as that due to a simplified image charge distribution which effectively plays the role of the induced charge. We do not need to worry about the surface any more. The uniqueness theorem guarantees that the potential found by this technique is unique. The method was introduced by Lord Kelvin in 1848 in one paper published in Cambridge and Dublin Mathematical Journal [ 1 ] . It is taught nowadays in the undergraduate level course on electrostatics [ 2 , 3 ] . Apart from that, many interesting pedagogic applications [ 4 , 5 ] and research-level applications have been discussed in the literature [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . In the realm of magnetostatics, the method of images has been used to explain magnetic levitation near the surface of a superconductor [ 9 ] . Smythe [ 10 ] (1950) used the concept of image currents to solve boundary value problems in magnetostatics (section 7.23: Current Images in Plane Face). In recent times, a few pedagogical articles used the concept to throw light on magnetic levitation near planar superconducting surfaces [ 11 , 12 ] . However, one does not find pedagogical examples of the method in magnetostatics in common textbooks. This is perhaps due to the fact that compared to the conductors, superconductivity is a relatively recent development in physics. The recent book by Matsushita [ 13 ] , however, contains a few simple examples of the applications of the method of images involving superconductors. Here let us mention that a formal introduction to superconductivity can be found in the textbook by Tinkham [ 14 ] . For temperatures T below the critical temperature T_{C} ( T<T_{C} ), the magnetic field {\bf B} vanishes inside the superconductor, i.e. B=0 . This is called the Meissner effect [ 15 ] . When an external magnetic field {\bf H} is applied, a superconductor expels the magnetic field from the interior by setting up an electric current at the surface. The surface current creates a magnetization that cancels the external magnetic field inside the bulk of the superconductor in the case of type-I superconductors. The magnetic field does not abruptly reduce to zero at the surface of a real superconductor. It does so over a small length scale called the London penetration depth. For its calculation, the interested reader is referred to the book by Tinkham [ 14 ] . In this work, we assume an ideal, Type-I superconductor with a vanishingly small London penetration depth. Coming back to the discussion of magnetic images, a pedagogically more interesting case would be to calculate the magnetic field at the test point, when a magnetic dipole (or an equivalent current distribution) is placed in front of a spherical surface as shown in the following figure. Figure 1 : Field lines of a magnetic dipole (red colour) of arbitrary orientation placed in front of a superconducting sphere (depicted in blue). The field lines are parallel to the interface just outside the sphere. The magnetic field inside the sphere is zero. Since a dipole of arbitrary orientation can be resolved into radial and transverse components, one can approach the problem systematically. Lindell analysed the case, where a current loop is placed in front of a material sphere, such that its axis is radially oriented relative to the sphere [ 16 ] . He used an image current loop to solve the problem. In the limit where the size of the current loop is small, one can talk about a point magnetic dipole placed in front of a sphere pointing in the radial direction. The same technique was used by Sezigner et al. [ 17 ] in the context of a superconducting sphere. Rezdic [ 18 , 19 ] showed that the it is possible to replace the superconducting sphere with a permeable sphere with an embedded current loop which coincides with the image current for the superconducting sphere case. Yang [ 20 ] and Coffey [ 21 ] dealt with the same problem to find levitating force, without any reference to magnetic image currents. They matched the boundary conditions of the magnetic scalar potential due to the source and the image dipoles to solve the problem. However, the case of transverse orientation of the magnetic dipole (or current loop) was not covered in these works. A systematic way to approach this problem is shown by Lin [ 7 ] who separately considers the cases of the radial and transverse orientations. He treats a magnetic dipole as two closely spaced magnetic monopoles of opposite signs. Then, he solves the image problem for a single magnetic monopole and finally uses the principle of superposition to arrive at the correct answers. Other notable works on dipoles with transverse orientation came from Coffey [ 22 , 23 ] . However, like the radial orientation case, these works are also concerned with the levitating force but not with the image dipole configuration. Hence, the only consolidated solution to the problem using the method of images is the work by Lin [ 7 ] . In many ways, this problem is an instructive tool for physics students. First of all, this problem gives an option for a comparative study between the application of the image method in electrostatics

Read the complete text