Inference on the Distribution of Individual Treatment Effects in Nonseparable Triangular Models
Jun Ma, Vadim Marmer, Zhengfei Yu · 2025
Read Inference on the Distribution of Individual Treatment Effects in Nonseparable Triangular Models by Jun Ma, Vadim Marmer, Zhengfei Yu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-15401.txt.
Introduction
Jun Ma, Vadim Marmer, and Zhengfei Yu study how a treatment affects each person, not just the average. In their model, the treatment and a tool that nudges it are both yes or no choices. Effects can differ from person to person in ways that simple models miss. Past work looked at the shape of these effects through density curves, which can be rough.
The trio build methods that use the full spread curve of effects instead. That curve can answer how many people gain, where the middle lies, and how wide the spread is. They prove their estimates settle into a known pattern and build resampling tests on that base. Sets of bands from their method let users judge the whole spread at once.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jun Ma, Vadim Marmer, Zhengfei Yu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 127 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-15401
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Inference on the Distribution of Individual Treatment Effects in Nonseparable Triangular Models † † footnotetext: Date: August 10, 2026 Thanks: We acknowledge the financial support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China under grant 72394392 (Ma), the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) under grant RGPIN-2024-04877 and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC) under grant 435-2025-0755 (Marmer), and the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science KAKENHI under grant 25K05032 (Yu). Jun Ma, Vadim Marmer, Zhengfei Yu Abstract In this paper, we develop inference methods for the distribution of heterogeneous individual treatment effects (ITEs) in the nonseparable triangular model with a binary endogenous treatment and a binary instrument of Vuong and Xu 2017 and Feng et al. 2019 . We focus on the estimation of the cumulative distribution function (CDF) of the ITE, which can be used to address a wide range of practically important questions such as inference on the proportion of individuals with positive ITEs, the quantiles of the distribution of ITEs, and the interquartile range as a measure of the spread of the ITEs, as well as comparison of the ITE distributions across sub-populations. Moreover, our CDF-based approach can deliver more precise results than density-based approach previously considered in the literature. We establish weak convergence to tight Gaussian processes for the empirical CDF and quantile function computed from nonparametric ITE estimates of Feng et al. 2019 . Using those results, we develop bootstrap-based nonparametric inferential methods, including uniform confidence bands for the CDF and quantile function of the ITE distribution. Keywords: Distribution of individual treatment effects, nonparametric triangular models, two-step nonparametric estimation, bootstrap, uniform confidence bands JEL classification: C12, C14, C31, C36 1 Introduction Heterogeneity of individual treatment effects (ITEs), including scenarios with endogenous treatment, has received substantial attention in the literature. When ITEs are heterogeneous, the econometrician is often interested in the properties of their distribution, e.g., the CDF and quantile function, as they contain important policy-relevant information beyond average treatment effects. Recently, using a triangular model with binary endogenous treatment, Vuong and Xu 2017 and Feng et al. 2019 established nonparametric identification of heterogeneous ITEs and proposed their nonparametric estimation. The estimated ITEs (also referred to as pseudo ITEs) can be used further to estimate the distribution of the ITEs. In this paper, we develop the asymptotic theory of the empirical CDF and quantile function of the nonparametrically estimated (pseudo) ITEs, which has been lacking in the literature so far. Such results are nontrivial because of the multi-step nonparametric estimation procedure required for their construction. We further use the results to develop easy-to-implement nonparametric bootstrap methods for inference on the CDF and quantile function of the ITE distribution. Our methods can be used, e.g., for inference on the proportion of the population with positive or negative ITEs and the dispersion of ITEs as measured by the interquartile range (IQR). Moreover, our procedure can be used to compare the ITE distributions between different sub-populations. E.g., one can use our results to test whether the distribution of the ITEs in one sub-population stochastically dominates that for another sub-population. Suppose that the econometrician observes data on an outcome variable, a binary endogenous treatment, a binary instrument, and exogenous covariates. We assume that the outcome variable and the endogenous treatment are generated from the nonseparable nonparametric triangular model of 36 that satisfies the rank invariance assumption. We further assume that the econometrician uses the nonparametric method of 16 to construct pseudo ITEs as the estimates of the true ITEs for each individual. In the next step, the econometrician uses the pseudo ITEs to construct the empirical CDF or quantile function as the estimates of the true ITE CDF or quantile function, respectively. The second step can be performed for the entire sample or in sub-groups determined by chosen values of discretely distributed exogenous covariates. E.g., the econometrician can perform the second step by gender, education levels, income quartiles, etc., as well as intersections of such groups. The first contribution of the paper is to show that the properly scaled difference between the empirical CDF of the pseudo ITEs and the CDF of the true ITEs weakly converges to a tight Gaussian process, with a similar result holding for the empirical quantile function of the pseudo ITEs. Importantly, we show that due to the two-step estimation, the asymptotic variances of the empirical CDF and quantile function of pseudo ITEs are “inflated” relative to their infeasible counterparts based on true unobserved ITEs. For our second contribution, we use the weak convergence results to develop bootstrap inference methods for the CDF and quantile function of the distribution of the ITE. Both pointwise confidence intervals and uniform confidence bands (UCBs) are considered, as the pointwise confidence interval is useful, e.g., for inference on the percentage of the population with positive ITEs and the IQR, while the UCB is useful for inference on the entire CDF or quantile function and comparing the distributions of the ITEs between different sub-populations. 1 1 1 A UCB is a collection of random intervals that cover the unknown curve of interest simultaneously over a range of values with a pre-specified confidence level. Our method for constructing confidence intervals for the percentages has the desirable range-preserving property: the bootstrap percentile confidence intervals are always sub-intervals of \left[0,1\right] . 2 2 2 See, e.g., Efron and Tibshirani 1994 . Our proposed inference methods exhibit excellent finite-sample performance in Monte Carlo simulations. We further demonstrate their practical value by revisiting a well-known empirical application: the effect of participation in 401(k) retirement programs on personal savings, see, e.g., Chernozhukov and Hansen 2006a and 16 , where our methods can be used to conduct valid inference on important distributional features such as the proportion of individuals with positive ITEs and stochastic dominance relationships between the distributions of ITEs in different subpopulations. In the case of 401(k) programs, our method reveals rich features of the ITE distributions. For instance, the 95% confidence interval for the proportion of households with a positive ITE is \left[0.851,0.919\right] , suggesting that program participation increased savings for the majority of households, though a nontrivial minority experienced negative effects. Moreover, for young individuals (with age in the first quartile), the 95% confidence interval is \left[0.706,0.884\right] , suggesting that up to 29.4% of young individuals may experience negative ITEs. The median ITE has a 95% confidence interval of \left[6.96,9.74\right] thousand dollars, indicating a significantly positive central tendency of the treatment effect distribution. The 95% confidence interval for the IQR, \left[16.68,23.38\right] , underscores substantial heterogeneity in the ITEs. A subgroup analysis reveals that as income or age increases, the ITE distribution shifts to the right, with both the median and the quartiles moving upward, and the spread of the distribution widening. The UCBs of the quantile functions further indicate that, across all quantiles between the 0.2 and 0.9 levels, the ITE is consistently larger for higher-income groups than for lower-income groups. Our paper contributes to the growing literature on causal inference methods that emphasize heterogeneous treatment effects (see, e.g., Angrist 2004 ; Heckman et al. 1997 ; Heckman et al. 2006 among others). The 36 model we employ belongs to a broad class of