Abundance anomalies in low mass field mergers as evidence of a merger origin for the second generation stars in globular clusters Preprint: V. Kravtsov

V. Kravtsov, S. Dib, F. Calderon · 2025

Read Abundance anomalies in low mass field mergers as evidence of a merger origin for the second generation stars in globular clusters Preprint: V. Kravtsov by V. Kravtsov, S. Dib, F. Calderon (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-15337.txt.

Introduction

Valery Kravtsov, Sami Dib, and Francisco A. Calderon argue that merged stars explain the chemical anomalies of second-generation globular cluster stars in a 2025 astrophysics paper. Clusters host two stellar generations, and the younger one carries odd light-element abundance patterns. Making that generation from gas ejected by the first faces a mass-budget problem and uncertainty about the polluting source.

Merging first-generation low-mass binaries could supply the material, but whether mergers reproduce the anomalies was untested. The authors point to probable merger remnants in the Galactic disk: carbon-deficient red-clump giants and hot helium-rich subdwarfs whose anomalies match the cluster pattern yet cannot come from clusters. Their existence supports stellar mergers, specifically main-sequence plus helium white dwarf pairs, as the anomaly factory.

Catalog record

CREATORV. Kravtsov, S. Dib, F. Calderon
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-15337

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Abundance anomalies in low mass field mergers as evidence of a merger origin for the second generation stars in globular clusters Preprint: V. Kravtsov V. Kravtsov, S. Dib, F. Calderon Abstract Context. The canonical formation of second-generation (G2) stars in globular clusters (GCs) from gas enriched and ejected by G1 (primordial) polluters faces substantial challenges, i.e. (i) a mass-budget problem and (ii) uncertainty in the source(s) of the abundance anomaly of light elements (AALE) in G2 stars. The merger of G1 low-mass main-sequence (MS) binaries can overcome (i), but its ability to result in AALE is omitted. Aims. We provide evidence of the merger process to explain AALE by relying on highly probable merger remnants in the Galactic disk. Methods. We focus on carbon-deficient red-clump giants with low mass of 1.0 ​ M ☉ < M ≲ 2.0 ​ M ☉ 1.0M_{\sun}<M\lesssim 2.0M_{\sun} and hot He-intermediate subdwarfs of supersolar metallicity, both manifesting G2-like AALE incompatible with GC origin. Results. The origin of such rare core He-burning stars as the mergers of [MS star (MSS)] + + [helium white dwarf (HeWD)] binaries, evolved from low-mass high-mass ratio (MSS + + MSS) ones, is supported by models evolving to either horizontal branch (HB) stars or He subdwarfs via the red giant branch (RGB). Such binaries in the GC NGC 362 contain very young ( ∼ \sim 4 Myr) extremely low-mass HeWDs, in contrast to much older ( ∼ 100 \sim 100 times) counterparts in open clusters. This agrees with the impact of GC environment on the lifetime of hard binaries: (MSS + + HeWD) systems merge there soon after arising from (MSS + + MSS) binaries that underwent the common-envelope stage of evolution. From the number and lifetime of the (MSS + + HeWD) binaries uncovered in NGC 362, the expected fraction of their progeny RGB G2 stars is estimated to be ≲ \lesssim 10%. Conclusions. The field merger remnants with G2-like AALE support the merger nature of at least a fraction of G2 stars in GCs. The specific channel [(MSS + + MSS) – (MSS + + HeWD) – merger product] supported by observations and models is tentatively identified as the channel of formation of the extreme G2 RGB component in GCs. 1 Introduction Globular clusters (GCs) are known to be composed of stellar populations that are not quite simple. Two sub-populations or generations of stars, a primordial (G1) and secondary (G2) ones, are typically distinguished in GCs ( Carretta et al. 2009 ; Milone et al. 2017 ) with a present-day mass exceeding a threshold level of about M_{\rm GC}\sim 10^{4} M ☉ ( Carretta et al. 2010 ; Bragaglia et al. 2017 ; Simpson et al. 2017 ; Tang et al. 2021 , e.g.,) . The surface abundance patterns of G2 stars, mainly belonging to the red giant branch (RGB) 1 1 1 These stars were studied first, most reliably, in large number of GCs. , exhibit anomalies in the abundance of light, proton-capture elements in such a way that N, Na, (Al) are in excess and C, O, (Mg) in deficit. In contrast, G1 red giants and their field counterparts of the same metallicity are indistinguishable in this context. This is referred to as multiplicity in GCs. The most common spectroscopic indicator of the multiplicity in GCs is the Na-O anti-correlation among RGB stars (e.g., Carretta et al. 2009 , and references therein) 2 2 2 Variations in the abundance of several light chemical elements and their molecules (e.g., CN, CH, NH) among RGB stars within individual GCs have been already known since the seventies of the last century (see, for example, a review by Kraft 1979 , and references therein) . . A particularly point of interest is that the Na-O anti-correlation was primarily spectroscopically observed in GCs among brighter stars, from the upper RGB down to the main-sequence (MS) turnoff point. So, it is not entirely clear whether the same Na-O anti-correlation is manifested by MS stars of lower luminosity and down to which limit. The Mg-Al anti-correlation is more controversial, because it tends to disappear in most metal-rich and/or least massive GCs ( Pancino et al. 2017 ; Nataf et al. 2019 ) . Most of the detections and quantitative studies of multiple populations in GCs or in intermediate-age massive star clusters, particularly in distant ones, are based on photometric effects that primarily arise from the characteristic abundances of CNO elements. Inferring on multiple stellar populations in GCs broadly implied the canonical formation of G2 stars in the usual way, from the gas primarily ejected from G1 polluters (irrespective of their kind) and possibly diluted with pristine gas. However, it remains a contradictory issue being considered in the framework of the canonical approach. Indeed, several lines of evidence have converged, indicating that this approach faces serious challenges. First, perhaps the most problematic is the so-called mass-budget problem: a deficit of the ejected enriched gas necessary to form the observed fraction of G2 stars, especially in massive GCs, where the fraction of G2 stars on the RGB was found to be very high, up to 80% 3 3 3 As a possible exception, see the scenario proposed by Bastian et al. 2013 who invoked the so-called ”tail-end” accretion of the low-velocity gas expelled from massive binaries by the disks of low-mass pre-main-sequence stars. . Second, the origin of the above-mentioned abundance anomaly in G2 stars is uncertain up to now. In principle, all conceivable polluters, the sources of the anomaly in the framework of the canonical formation of G2 stars, were brought to light ( Bastian & Lardo 2018 ; Gratton et al. 2019 ; Milone & Marino 2022 , see more details on both issues in review papers by) . However, a detailed model analysis by Bastian et al. 2015 showed that neither separate sources nor their combination are consistent with observations, particularly in terms of the helium abundance. Moreover, typical lithium abundance in G2 stars requires the dilution of the expelled enriched (but Li-free) gas with the pristine gas ( Prantzos et al. 2007 ) . Conversely, we suggested ( Kravtsov 2019 ; Kravtsov 2020 ; Kravtsov & Calderón 2021 ; Kravtsov et al. 2022 ; Dib et al. 2022 ; Kravtsov et al. 2024 ) an alternative approach for the origin of G2 stars due to the merger/collision of G1 low-mass MS stars, which is of particular relevance in the high-density GC environment 4 4 4 Note that we do not mean the merger/collision of massive stars, particularly in binaries, which is considered within the framework of canonical formation of G2 stars ( Sills & Glebbeek 2010 ; Wang et al. 2020 , e.g.,) . Its incidence was probably high in the early GCs ( Portegies Zwart et al. 1999 ) . It is also argued ( de Mink et al. 2014 ) to be notable among field stars. . Kravtsov et al. 2022 showed some empirical dependencies suggesting this approach and estimated, in general terms, that it does not obviously suffer from the mass-budget problem. Kravtsov et al. 2024 looked into the matter in more detail. We demonstrated that a variety of data on close/hard binary systems and their evolution in different

Read the complete text