New formalism for perturbations of massive gravity theories around arbitrary background spacetimes

Kieran Wood · 2025

Read New formalism for perturbations of massive gravity theories around arbitrary background spacetimes by Kieran Wood (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-15055.txt.

Introduction

Kieran Wood develops a new formalism for perturbing massive gravity theories around any background spacetime in a solo 2025 gravitation paper. Massive gravity gives the graviton a small mass, and its ghost-free version is notoriously awkward to expand around general backgrounds. Earlier metric-based approaches ran into complications that obscured the theory's healthy structure.

Wood starts from the vielbein formulation, then switches back to metric variables once the expansion is organized. The switch sidesteps many earlier difficulties and makes the ghost-free interaction structure transparent. The method extends naturally to higher perturbation orders and to several interacting metrics. Applied to proportional, cosmological, and black hole backgrounds, it recovers and extends known linear results. As a final demonstration, the cubic multi-gravity potential around a generic background is derived for the first time.

Catalog record

CREATORKieran Wood
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE387 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-15055

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

New formalism for perturbations of massive gravity theories around arbitrary background spacetimes Kieran Wood Abstract We develop a new technique for studying the perturbations of dRGT-type massive gravity theories around arbitrary background spacetimes. Built initially from the vielbein formulation of the theory, but switching back to the metric formulation afterwards, our approach bypasses many of the complications that arise in previous metric formulation approaches to linearising massive gravity around generic backgrounds, naturally elucidates the ghost-free structure of the interactions, and readily generalises to higher orders in perturbation theory, as well as to multiple interacting metric tensor fields. To demonstrate the power of our technique, we apply our formalism to a number of commonly occurring example backgrounds – proportional, cosmological, and black hole – recovering and extending many known results from the literature at linear order. Lastly, we provide, for the first time, the cubic order multi-gravity potential around a generic background spacetime. I Introduction Recent years have seen something of a resurgence in the study of massive spin-2 fields and their interactions, owing to many interesting theoretical developments, as well as potential applications to a number of outstanding fundamental physics problems, particularly in cosmology (see Hinterbichler_review ; dR_review ; bigravity_review ; KWThesis for reviews). The subject has a rich history dating back to the time of Fierz and Pauli (FP), who in 1939 first wrote down the only consistent linear theory of such a field propagating on Minkowski spacetime FierzPauli , later extended to also apply for generic Einstein spacetimes OG_Higuchi ; OG_Higuchi_2 (i.e. those of constant curvature). The FP theory is essentially linearised general relativity (GR) – the unique theory of a massless spin-2 field – supplemented by a mass term containing all possible quadratic contractions of the metric perturbation h_{\mu\nu} i.e. \mathcal{L}_{\text{FP}}\supset-\frac{m^{2}}{8}\left(h_{\mu\nu}h^{\mu\nu}+Ah^{2}\right)\;. (1) Such a mass term, if A is chosen arbitrarily, generically excites a ghostly scalar mode contained within h_{\mu\nu} – the so-called Boulware-Deser (BD) ghost – whose presence would render the vacuum of the theory unstable upon coupling h_{\mu\nu} to matter. The magic of the FP choice of A=-1 is that it ensures h_{00} appears in the action as a Lagrange multiplier, enforcing a primary constraint. A further secondary constraint arises from the assertion that the primary constraint should be preserved in time, and together the two constraints act to exorcise the ghost mode and its conjugate momentum from the spectrum of the theory, leaving 5 physical, healthy degrees of freedom in 4 dimensions. Extending the linear FP theory to a fully nonlinear theory of massive gravity (i.e. GR plus a nonlinear mass term) was long thought to be an impossible task, as most candidate nonlinear mass terms are doomed to resurrect the BD ghost BD_Ghosts ; BD_ghost_explicit . It was only quite recently, in 2010, that a satisfactory mass term (in fact, the unique such term) circumventing Boulware and Deser’s apparent no-go result was found, and subsequently proved to be free from the vexatious ghost at the full nonlinear level dRGT_1 ; dRGT_2 ; first_action_metric_form ; ghost_freedom_flat_ref ; ghost_freedom_general_ref ; ghost_freedom_stuckelberg ; hamiltonian_analysis ; Kluson ; Kluson_note ; Covariant_approach_no_ghosts . Built upon groundwork laid earlier in EFTforMGs ; Creminelli , the associated theory of gravity now goes by the name dRGT massive gravity , after its three original architects: de Rham, Gabadadze and Tolley, although the two principal formulations with which we typically express it today (metric and vielbein) are actually due to Hassan, Rosen and Hinterbichler first_action_metric_form ; interacting_spin2 . The nonlinear mass term in dRGT theory is constructed from an interaction between two independent metrics: the physical metric of spacetime, and some fiducial, non-dynamical reference metric that one inserts by hand (typically taken to be Minkowski, but one is free to be more general if they so wish). By providing a kinetic term for the reference metric, thereby promoting it to a second dynamical field, one obtains the theory of bigravity HR1 , which, due to the special structure of the dRGT interactions, is also ghost free HR2 ; official_secondary_constraint_bigravity . The generalisation to multiple interacting metrics came soon after in interacting_spin2 , although the general multi-gravity theory is only devoid of the BD ghost up to certain conditions ghost_freedom_multigravity ; cycles ; beyond_pairwise_couplings , upon which we shall elaborate in section II when we cover the mathematics of the theory in detail. In pure dRGT massive gravity, the fixed nature of the reference metric means that the would-be diffeomorphism invariance of GR is completely broken by the mass term and hence the one propagating spin-2 field in the theory has a mass. However, in bi- and multi-gravity, the interaction term remains invariant under the diagonal subgroup of diffeomorphisms that transforms every metric in the same way, hence these theories contain a single massless spin-2 field (associated to this diagonal subgroup) as well as a collection of massive spin-2 fields (associated to the broken diffeomorphisms). This is consistent with a powerful no-go theorem by Boulanger, Damour, Gualtieri and Henneaux stating, up to some mild assumptions 1 1 1 Namely: locality, compatibility with Poincaré invariance, spacetime dimension D>2 and a Lagrangian that is at most second-order in derivatives. , that theories containing multiple massless spin-2 fields interacting nonlinearly are inconsistent no_interacting_massless_gravitons : in any theory of interacting spin-2 fields, all but one of them must be massive. As expected, dRGT massive gravity correctly linearises to the FP theory around an Einstein background. Multi-gravity theories linearise to a sort of ‘multi-FP’ theory containing a mass matrix coupling different metric perturbations at quadratic order (in this sense the metrics themselves are akin to flavour eigenstates) i.e. \mathcal{L}_{\text{mFP}}\supset-\frac{\mathcal{M}_{ij}^{2}}{8}\left[h^{(i)}_{\mu\nu}h^{(j)\mu\nu}-h^{(i)}h^{(j)}\right]\;, (2) around backgrounds where all metrics are proportional to the same Einstein space, as we will see explicitly in section IV . The matrix \mathcal{M}_{ij}^{2} always contains precisely one zero eigenvalue, in accordance with the no-go theorem mentioned earlier consistent_spin2 ; prop_bg_multigrav ; BH2 . Around more generic backgrounds, the structure of the perturbations is much more abstruse. This is a problem, because many spacetimes of physical relevance are not Einstein spaces, and metric perturbations around them can give rise to important physical effects e.g. around the FLRW metric of cosmology, metric perturbations seed the growth of structure in the universe. Thus, if one wishes to study such effects in the context of these massive gravity theories, it remains an important task to figure out how to perturb them around arbitrary backgrounds in a systematic manner. Thankfully, we already have a pretty good handle on how to do this in the metric formulation of multi-gravity up to linear order, owing to a series of papers by Bernard, Deffayet, Schmidt-May and von Strauss MG_arbitrary_BG ; Syzygies ; linear_spin2_gen_BG from 2015 (see also Durrer_perts_1 ; general_mass ). Their procedure, in its original form, is formulaic and readily applicable in principle, but the calculations involved are complex, containing many steps that can quickly become tedious around more complicated backgrounds, and that do not easily generalise to higher orders in perturbation theory. The reason for this, as we will see in section II , is that the interaction term in the metric formulation contains a matrix square root, which can be very awkward to handle, especially at the level of the perturbations: even

Read the complete text