Turn up the light: Radiative efficiency of protostars at birth
Asmita Bhandare , ‡ \ddagger, Adnan Ali Ahmad ,, Benoît Commerçon · 2025
Read Turn up the light: Radiative efficiency of protostars at birth by Asmita Bhandare , ‡ \ddagger, Adnan Ali Ahmad ,, Benoît Commerçon (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-15009.txt.
Introduction
Asmita Bhandare, Adnan Ali Ahmad, and Benoît Commerçon measure how well a newborn star sheds heat as it gains mass, in a 2025 letter. A protostar forms in two collapse steps, and each step makes a dense core. The second step sets two key numbers: the share of infall energy that is radiated away, and the rate at which mass lands on the star.
Those numbers set how bright young stars look, and surveys and theory still do not agree on that point. The team ran high-detail radiation hydrodynamics runs with two trusted codes. Their main result is that the radiated share climbs to one, the supercritical point, soon after birth. That quick climb backs cold accretion, where infall adds little heat to the star.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Asmita Bhandare , ‡ \ddagger, Adnan Ali Ahmad ,, Benoît Commerçon |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-15009
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Turn up the light: Radiative efficiency of protostars at birth Asmita Bhandare , ‡ \ddagger, Adnan Ali Ahmad ,, Benoît Commerçon Abstract Early stages of stellar birth comprise of a two-step process involving the formation of two hydrostatic cores. The second step of gravitational collapse sets the radiative efficiency and accretion rate of the young protostar. These two parameters, of prime importance for protostellar evolution, dictate the luminosities and thus play a key role in deciphering the current discrepancy between observational surveys and theoretical models. In this letter, we provide quantitative estimates on the evolution of the radiative efficiency and accretion rate obtained from self-consistent, high-resolution, radiative hydrodynamic simulations performed using the codes PLUTO and RAMSES . The main highlight of our result is that the radiative efficiency reaches unity, that is, supercriticality, relatively quickly after protostellar birth. Supercriticality at the accretion shock is a necessary condition for cold accretion. Our results thus support a rapid transition to the cold accretion scenario, which is one of the assumptions used in Pre-Main Sequence (PMS) models working towards solutions to explain observational data. We briefly discuss the implications of the time evolution of the radiative efficiency factor in the context of the luminosity problem, the Protostellar Luminosity Function (PLF), PMS evolution, accurate sink properties, and the stellar Initial Mass Function (IMF). † † orcid: 0000-0002-1197-3946 † † orcid: 0009-0004-2719-1107 † † orcid: 0000-0003-2407-1025 1 Introduction Understanding the birth of stars through the gravitational collapse to the onset of hydrogen fusion is a challenging task: modelling the birth of a protostar requires one to describe a highly non-linear and complex process that spans orders of magnitude in both density and spatial extent. Furthermore, modelling protostellar evolution following its formation relies on Pre-Main sequence (PMS) theory. A crucial hypothesis in this theory is that of cold accretion ( Palla & Stahler 1993 ; Hartmann et al. 1997 ; Hosokawa & Omukai 2009 ; Baraffe et al. 2017 ) . In PMS models this is expressed by the factor of ( 1-\alpha ) where \alpha represents the fraction of accretion energy absorbed at the protostellar surface and cold accretion implies \alpha=0 . A number of processes could explain a drop in \alpha , which may be mechanical in nature, such as with outflows, jets, and boundary disc accretion, or radiation. In this letter, we draw a parallel between said \alpha parameter and the radiative efficiency of the protostellar accretion shock f_{\mathrm{acc}} , which represents the fraction of the incident accretion energy radiated away. f_{\mathrm{acc}}=1 is a necessary condition for cold accretion. Recent numerical studies on protostellar collapse including radiation hydrodynamics have offered insights on the radiative properties of the accretion shocks on the first and second hydrostatic cores. Doing-so requires a self-consistent modelling of the two shock fronts in which one describes protostellar formation following the second gravitational collapse. This was pioneered by Larson 1969 , who discovered the two-step evolutionary sequence that results in the birth of a protostar deeply embedded in its surrounding envelope (see Fig. 2 ). At first, the collapse of the gravitationally unstable dense molecular cloud core proceeds isothermally, as the gravitational binding energy is efficiently radiated away by dust grains as infrared thermal emission. The resulting short cooling timescale enables the gas to maintain thermal equilibrium with the surrounding interstellar radiation field, typically \sim 10-30 K. In the central region, gas density and hence optical depth increases due to gravitational compression. This causes the heating rate to exceed the cooling rate. Thus, the collapse enters an almost adiabatic phase where the gas further heats up. This builds up thermal pressure support leading to a hydrostatic equilibrium, forming the first core. The first core mass increases as it continues accreting material, maintaining a quasi-hydrostatic equilibrium while slowly contracting adiabatically, until temperatures exceed \approx 2000 K, by which point molecular hydrogen (H 2 ) dissociation begins. This endothermic process extracts heat from the gas to dissociate H 2 , which was otherwise being injected into the thermal energy budget of the first core. As a result, the polytropic index of the gas, previously at 7/5, drops to \approx 1.1, below the critical value of 4/3 needed for stability against gravitational collapse. This causes a violent second collapse within the first core, giving birth to the second core (i.e., the protostar) once all H 2 molecules are dissociated. Since these calculations are complex and expensive to run, only a handful studies have investigated the radiative behaviour of the protostellar accretion shock (see the review by Teyssier & Commerçon 2019 ). It is however crucial to note that multi-dimensional calculations resolving the protostar are often stopped soon after protostellar birth ( Tomida et al. 2013 ; Vaytet et al. 2018 , e.g.,) owing to stringent time-stepping constraints, with only a few studies following its evolution for a few tens of years afterward ( Bate 2010 ; Schönke & Tscharnuter 2011 ; Machida & Basu 2019 ; Wurster et al. 2022 , e.g.,) . Radiative shocks with a radiative efficiency f_{\mathrm{acc}}\penalty\ = 1 are commonly referred to as supercritical , whereas with f_{\mathrm{acc}}\penalty\ ¡ 1 are referred to as subcritical ( Zel’dovich & Raizer 1967 , see) . The first core’s accretion shock has been shown to be supercritical ( Commerçon et al. 2011a ; Vaytet et al. 2013 ; Bate et al. 2014 ; Vaytet et al. 2018 ; Bhandare et al. 2018 ) ; in contrast, the protostar’s shock front at birth seems to be strongly subcritical ( Vaytet et al. 2013 ; Bate et al. 2014 ; Vaytet et al. 2018 ; Bhandare et al. 2020 ; Ahmad et al. 2023 ) . The swelling of the protostar to very large radii immediately after its birth, followed by a contraction phase, was already reported in older uni-dimensional spherically symmetrical calculations in the literature, having studied the collapse across longer timescales ( Larson 1969 ; Narita et al. 1970 ; Winkler & Newman 1980 ; Stahler et al. 1980a ; Stahler et al. 1980b ; Masunaga & Inutsuka 2000 ; Vaytet & Haugbølle 2017 , e.g.,) . This seems to imply that the protostellar accretion shock is initially subcritical and later exhibits a transition to supercriticality, as the addition of significant amounts of high entropy material to the protostellar interior causes it to swell. However the precise value of f_{\mathrm{acc}} , that is, the fraction of the accreted gravitational energy radiated away at the shock, and its evolution with time remained unexplored. This radiative efficiency and the early accretion history of protostars has been used in solutions to explain the observed low and widely spread protostellar luminosities ( Dunham et al. 2014 ; Fischer et al. 2023 , see reviews by) . It is also used as a free parameter to compute the radiative feedback of sink particles and from sink cells, a replacement for protostars in simulations ( Offner et al. 2009 ; Commerçon et al. 2022 , e.g.,) , with further implications on constraining the mass distribution of stars in the stellar Initial Mass Function ( Hennebelle et al. 2020 ; Hennebelle et al. 2022 , IMF;) . In this letter, we provide a quantitative estimate of the radiative efficiency