Monojet and direct detection constraints on real scalar dark matter: EFT and a simple UV completion
Arnab Roy ID, Michael A. Schmidt ID, and German Valencia ID · 2025
Read Monojet and direct detection constraints on real scalar dark matter: EFT and a simple UV completion by Arnab Roy ID, Michael A. Schmidt ID, and German Valencia ID (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-14869.txt.
Introduction
Arnab Roy, Michael A. Schmidt, and German Valencia compare two ways of hunting invisible scalar dark matter in a 2025 particle physics paper. One way watches for a single jet recoiling against missing energy at the Large Hadron Collider, the monojet signal. The other listens underground for dark matter particles striking atomic nuclei directly.
Direct detection usually gives the stronger limits, but the authors find regions where collider searches add real complementary power. They work both with an effective field theory, where scalar pairs couple to ordinary matter through operators up to dimension six, and with a concrete model containing vector-like quarks. In that model the quarks can decay only into a jet plus an invisible scalar. Recasting current ATLAS monojet data constrains the model, and comparing the two descriptions clarifies how much trust effective theories deserve.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arnab Roy ID, Michael A. Schmidt ID, and German Valencia ID |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-14869
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Monojet and direct detection constraints on real scalar dark matter: EFT and a simple UV completion Preprint: CPPC-25-07 Arnab Roy ID, Michael A. Schmidt ID, and German Valencia ID Abstract We consider constraints that can be placed on certain invisible scalar particles through monojet studies at the LHC and compare them with those from direct detection experiments when interpreted as dark matter. Whereas direct detection constraints are typically more restrictive, we identify regions of parameter space where monojet studies provide important complementary bounds. We carry out our analysis using both a ϕ \phi SMEFT for real scalar particle pairs coupled to standard-model fields through operators of up to dimension six, and a simple UV completion with vector-like quarks, with both the scalars and the vector-like quarks being odd under a ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry, while the SM particles are even. The vector-like quarks can only decay into a jet and an invisible scalar, and we recast the current ATLAS monojet data to constrain their parameter space. Comparison of the two descriptions yields some insight into interpreting dark matter constraints obtained with EFTs. 1 Introduction Bounds on dark matter from monojet searches at the LHC have been extensively discussed in the literature, both in the context of simplified models Papucci:2014iwa ; Chala:2015ama ; Jacques:2016dqz ; Liew:2016oon and of effective field theories (EFTs) Racco:2015dxa ; DeSimone:2016fbz ; Bauer:2016pug ; Bruggisser:2016nzw ; Pobbe:2017wrj ; Belwal:2017nkw ; Belyaev:2018pqr ; Roy:2024ear . Some of these studies have discussed the region of validity of the dark matter (DM) EFTs Racco:2015dxa ; Bauer:2016pug ; Pobbe:2017wrj ; Belyaev:2018pqr , and resolved it mostly by relying on analyzing events with partonic centre-of-mass energy less than a hypothetical cut-off scale for the validity of the EFT. In contrast, monojet constraints on UV-complete models have received less attention. In this paper, we recast the ATLAS monojet search to constrain both a \phi SMEFT for real scalar particle pairs coupled to SM fields through operators of up to dimension six and a simple UV completion, the scalar-DM extended vector-like quark (VLQS) model introduced in Ref. He:2024iju in which both the scalars and the vector-like quarks are odd under a \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry, while the SM particles are even. This specific model was motivated by the apparent excess observed by Belle II in the rare decay mode B\to K\nu\bar{\nu} Belle-II:2023esi , and the possibility of interpreting such an excess as deriving from unobserved scalar particles. Our study provides monojet bounds specific to this model, and in particular, we estimate the reach of the LHC in searches for vector-like quarks that decay to jets plus missing energy. Although general prescriptions to ensure EFT validity have been proposed in the literature Busoni:2013lha ; Busoni:2014haa ; Busoni:2014sya ; Racco:2015dxa ; Bell:2016obu ; DeSimone:2016fbz ; Bauer:2016pug ; Pobbe:2017wrj , their robustness has not been systematically tested within specific UV-complete DM models. Our step-by-step comparison of the EFT and its UV complete model serves as a tool to explore the potential pitfalls of relying on EFTs to constrain theories where the new scale is just above the reach of LHC. In particular, we identify three potential issues: • The energy scale at which the EFT begins to differ significantly from its completion while still obeying unitarity in terms of the \rm E{\!\!\!/}_{T} . Previous studies have assessed the EFT validity based on the partonic centre-of-mass energy, employing proxy variables such as the invariant mass of the DM pair Belyaev:2018pqr or the invariant mass of the DM pair and the jet Pobbe:2017wrj . They rely on parton-level information, such as the four-momenta of the individual DM particles, which is inaccessible in experimental analyses. In this study, we use the \rm E{\!\!\!/}_{T} of the event to discuss EFT validity, which is directly measurable at the detector level, and compare it to the partonic centre-of-mass energy. While an EFT validity criterion based on \rm E{\!\!\!/}_{T} is inherently sensitive to the specific UV completion, this study nevertheless provides a useful estimate of the \rm E{\!\!\!/}_{T} range over which an EFT description remains trustworthy for new physics (NP) in the few-TeV region. • The possibility of on-shell production of a heavy mediator affects the assumed jet plus \rm E{\!\!\!/}_{T} topology. VLQS of masses at the assumed EFT scale produce large differences between differential cross-sections in the EFT and UV complete descriptions at or above the EFT scale. In our example, this results in peculiar differences between the two descriptions that can be attributed to a large fluctuation in a single bin of the ATLAS data. • The way the kinematic differences between the EFT and its UV completion lead to different results in automated calculations. Specifically, in this case, we pinpoint a new source of mismatch between the EFT and its UV completion in the default choice of the factorisation scale used by Madgraph5 . Our paper is organised as follows. In Section 2 , we present the EFT for the SM plus a real scalar with a \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry up to dimension six, as well as the UV completion of He:2024iju and the corresponding matching equations. In Section 3 , we provide details of our recast of ATLAS:2021kxv to obtain monojet constraints on both the EFT and VLQS and compare them, detailing the kinematic regions where they disagree. We also obtain the corresponding future sensitivity for the HL-LHC. In Section 4 , we study the constraints on these EFT operators from direct detection (DD) experiments and the requirement to explain the observed DM relic density, and point out the complementarity of the collider and DD approaches. Finally, in Section 5 , we present our conclusions. Technical details are included in two appendices. 2 Theoretical framework We consider a real scalar DM candidate, \phi , singlet under the SM gauge group, i.e., \phi\sim(\mathbf{1},\mathbf{1},0) , which interacts with SM particles via beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) mediators. To stabilise this DM particle, we introduce a \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry under which the SM fields are even, but \phi and the heavy mediators are odd as well. We choose the mediators to be heavy compared to the real scalar \phi , with mass \rm m_{med}\gtrsim 1TeV . In contrast, the DM mass can lie below the electroweak (EW) scale, potentially even below the GeV scale, yet remain undetected due to its suppressed production rate. We implement these basic assumptions both through an EFT framework and a simple UV completion in the following. 2.1 Effective field theory with operators up to dimension six The possible interactions between DM and SM particles can be encapsulated into higher-dimensional interaction terms in the Lagrangian. To this end, we include an extra dark degree of freedom in the dimension-6 Standard Model effective field theory (SMEFT), known as DSMEFT Criado:2021trs ; Aebischer:2022wnl . These DM fields, being gauge singlets, interact with the SM fields in a way that preserves the gauge symmetry of the SM, \rm SU(3)_{C}\otimes SU(2)_{L}\otimes U(1)_{Y} . The field we have chosen, a real gauge-singlet scalar field that is odd under a \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry, restricts DSMEFT to a subset, which we call \rm\phi SMEFT . The \rm\phi SMEFT Lagrangian up to dimension six has the form: \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{\phi SMEFT}} \displaystyle=\mathcal{L}_{SM}+\sum_{i}\mathcal{C}_{i}\mathcal{O}_{i}^{(4)}+\frac{1}{\Lambda^{2}}\sum_{i}\mathcal{C}_{i}\mathcal{O}_{i}^{(6)}, (1) where the parameter \Lambda denotes the scale of new physics, above which additional states,