On Optimality and Human Prediction of Event Duration in Real-Time, Real-World Contexts Journal: Arxiv
Mark G. Orr · 2025
Read On Optimality and Human Prediction of Event Duration in Real-Time, Real-World Contexts Journal: Arxiv by Mark G. Orr (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-14482.txt.
Introduction
Mark G Orr, writing alone in 2025, studies how people predict how long an event will last in real time, in a real world setting. Duration judgement guides planning, yet the psychology behind on the fly prediction is thin. The data context here offers unusually rich, linked judgements.
Provisional findings suggest the existing theoretical mechanism is incomplete in two ways. It cannot support adaptive responses when duration judgements depend on each other. It also cannot integrate fresh information that arrives mid event. Orr points to specific directions for future research that could repair both gaps. The contribution is deliberately theoretical: better mechanisms for how a running estimate updates as an event unfolds and new evidence lands.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mark G. Orr |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-14482
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On Optimality and Human Prediction of Event Duration in Real-Time, Real-World Contexts Journal: Arxiv Mark G. Orr Abstract The focus of the current work concerned the psychological processes that underlie prediction of an event’s duration. The objective was to push forward existing psychological theory on event duration prediction, something made possible by the unique features of our data context. The provisional findings suggested that the prior, existing theoretical mechanism of event duration prediction is incomplete because: (i) it doesn’t support adaptive responses when event duration judgments are dependent, (ii) it doesn’t afford the integration of new, on-the-fly, information. Our findings suggest specific directions for future research. 1 Introduction Human judgments of future events are ubiquitous and span the mundane (e.g., will the oncoming traffic light change from green to yellow) to the extraordinary–e.g., decisions made during military operations. The study of human forecasting, fittingly, draws upon myriad domains and literature. Our report focuses on what is called prediction of event duration: forecasting how much longer an event will continue in reference to how long it has lasted thus far. Examples are: "We’ve been at war for 2 months; how much longer will the war last?" "A train has been traveling for 20 minutes; what will be the total time of the trip?" Here, we explore event duration prediction in real-world epidemics via two rounds of an online forecasting tournament focused on the COVID-19 epidemic. Participants were asked to judge the timing of the peak of a wave of the epidemic. Measurement-wise, the data were impoverished, offering little beyond the actual predictions. Thus, we adopted the rational analysis perspective ( Anderson 1990 ; Lieder and Griffiths 2020 ; Marr 2010 ) , a first step towards understanding the psychological processes that drive behavior. Rational analysis puts forth an optimal computation (a rational model) in relation to a task and addresses the degree to which human performance matches the optimal computation (see Tauber et al. 2017 for detailed exposition). Rational models show promise in explaining event duration prediction: (i) humans can estimate an event’s duration optimally given little context and (ii) prior knowledge integrates with new, observed data in an optimal way ( Griffiths and Tenenbaum 2006 ; Griffiths and Tenenbaum 2011 ; Tauber et al. 2017 ) . (These results come with some theoretical contention, e.g., Mozer et al. 2008 ). The basis of these models is a Bayesian decision model derived from: P(t_{total}|t_{past})=\frac{P(t_{past}|t_{total})P(t_{total})}{P(t_{past})} (1) where t_{total} is a value of an event’s total duration, coming from a distribution of durations; t_{past} is the duration at which a decision is made, or if post-hoc, the point for which the decision is made; P(X) stands for probability of X . We define the decision function as the expected value of the probability distribution generated from Equation 1 over the distribution of all t_{total} . We call the output of this function t_{predicted} ; i.e., this is the rational model’s prediction of the duration of the event. Defining the Bayesian prediction function (borrowing from Griffiths and Tenenbaum 2006 ) as t_{predicted} over all values of t_{past} , shows concordance with human predictions under experimental conditions ( Griffiths and Tenenbaum 2006 ) in which human predictions are provided in reference to a single event (e.g., how much longer will someone live if they are now 55 years old). Further, experimental evidence supports the hypothesis that human event duration prediction is affected by both prior, durable knowledge and new observations; in terms of the the Bayesian decision model the new observations are integrated into the likelihood function P(t_{past}|t_{total}) ( Griffiths and Tenenbaum 2011 ) . We applied the Bayesian decision model to a real-time, real-world context. In our data setting, participants were allowed to make repeated predictions over time, during a single event (the Omicron wave of COVID-19). This observational setting–uncontrolled repeated observations in real-time–afforded a unique, applied context for understanding two key issues for the Bayesian decision model. First, the setting had the potentiality of eliciting t_{predicted} as t_{past} approached t_{predicted} , a feature which surfaces a paradoxical conclusion of the Bayesian decision model. When an agent is invariant in its prediction over time ( t_{predicted} ), the expected value of the prior distribution must decrease as t_{past} approaches t_{predicted} 1 1 1 We will provide details of this result in the Methods section. . This reduction in prior, what we call the prior crash , is paradoxical not because priors must be fixed but because the change in prior would be self-organized, without information external to the model. Rapid changes in the prior are typically assumed to be driven by changes in the environment (see Sohn and Jazayeri 2021 ; Prat-Carrabin et al. 2021 for examples). Contrast this with another limiting case. When the prior is fixed (instead of the prediction), the prediction t_{predicted} increases as t_{past} approaches it. Taken together, the invariant prediction and the invariant prior are just flip-sides of the same model. The former forces the prior downward to maintain a constant prediction; the latter forces the prediction upward to maintain an invariant prior. The paradoxical feature of the Bayesian decision model is an issue only to the degree that it is observed. As t_{past} approaches t_{predicted} , humans may adapt their predictions, either in an effort to minimize the degree of change in the prior or some other motive (we leave the motive for the discussion). So, the first objective of our work was to observe how participants adapt their predictions in real-time and to understand the relation of the un-observable theoretic component, the prior, to the human predictions . Second, forecasting tournament participants were provided with a url to the COVID-19 daily-case counts as a potential source of information. Thus, the forecasting context afforded exploring the role of information external to the Bayesian decision model. Thus, our second objective was to explore possible relations between external data and the human predictions . If the human predictions were correlated in some manner with the epidemiological case-counts, then it would suggest re-consideration of the rational model described above, depending on the nature of the relation. A priori, it is not obvious how to integrate such information into the Bayesian decision model we used. 2 Methods We present our work in two studies. Study 1 provides a descriptive overview of the human predictions during the course of three rounds in the forecasting tournament, both in aggregate and idiographically (for some individuals). This will provide a sense of the data structure and the performance of the forecasters. The primary focus for Study 1, however, was to tackle our first objective: observe how participants adapt their predictions in real-time and to understand the relation between the unobservable theoretic component, the prior, and the human predictions. Study 2 addressed our second objective: to explore possible relations between external data, the human predictions and, potentially, to components of the rational model (e.g., the prior). To this end, we used the same human predictions from Study 1 and provided an analysis of the relation of the human predictions to the epidemiological case-count in Virginia. Next, we provide general methodological details that apply to both studies prior to detailing the specific methods used in each study. 2.1