Mind the Ethics! The Overlooked Ethical Dimensions of GenAI in Software Modeling Education

Shalini Chakraborty, Lola Burgueño, Nathalie Moreno, Javier Troya, Paula Muñoz · 2025

Read Mind the Ethics! The Overlooked Ethical Dimensions of GenAI in Software Modeling Education by Shalini Chakraborty, Lola Burgueño, Nathalie Moreno, Javier Troya, Paula Muñoz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-13896.txt.

Introduction

Shalini Chakraborty and four co-authors review the ethics literature on AI in software modeling education in a 2025 paper. Students and teachers now use these tools to interpret requirements and formalize models. The tools also turn mental pictures into structured diagrams. So they quietly shape core skills, like domain understanding and diagram thinking. Little ethical oversight guides that influence.

Searching six major digital libraries, the team retrieved nearly fourteen hundred unique papers. Only three explicitly addressed ethical considerations. Those include responsibility, fairness, transparency, diversity, and inclusion. That near-total absence is their headline finding. They examine the three studies closely. They also map the research openings and challenges that follow. The goal is building ethical frameworks into modeling curricula.

Catalog record

CREATORShalini Chakraborty, Lola Burgueño, Nathalie Moreno, Javier Troya, Paula Muñoz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-13896

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mind the Ethics! The Overlooked Ethical Dimensions of GenAI in Software Modeling Education Shalini Chakraborty, Lola Burgueño, Nathalie Moreno, Javier Troya, Paula Muñoz Abstract Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is rapidly gaining momentum in software modeling education, embraced by both students and educators. As GenAI assists with interpreting requirements, formalizing models, and translating students’ mental models into structured notations, it increasingly shapes core learning outcomes such as domain comprehension, diagrammatic thinking, and modeling fluency without clear ethical oversight or pedagogical guidelines. Yet, the ethical implications of this integration remain underexplored. In this paper, we conduct a systematic literature review across six major digital libraries in computer science (ACM Digital Library, IEEE Xplore, Scopus, ScienceDirect, SpringerLink, and Web of Science). Our aim is to identify studies discussing the ethical aspects of GenAI in software modeling education, including responsibility, fairness, transparency, diversity, and inclusion among others. Out of 1,386 unique papers initially retrieved, only three explicitly addressed ethical considerations. This scarcity highlights the critical absence of ethical discourse surrounding GenAI in modeling education and raises urgent questions about the responsible integration of AI in modeling curricula, as well as it evinces the pressing need for structured ethical frameworks in this emerging educational landscape. We examine these three studies and explore the emerging research opportunities as well as the challenges that have arisen in this field. I Introduction Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) has rapidly established itself as a transformative tool across multiple fields, particularly within education. Since the launch of OpenAI’s ChatGPT [ 1 ] , this technology has gained popularity among students, providing assistance in various daily tasks ranging from grammar correction and sentence formation to coding and solving of complex assignments. Its role in both educational and non-educational settings has shown benefits (such as enhanced accessibility and immediate feedback [ 2 ] ) as well as concerns (e.g., potentially increased dependency on AI tools [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] ). In the field of software engineering, numerous studies have examined the impact of AI on the discipline’s education. In some of them, concerns both from educators as well as students have been shared such as reducing the emphasis on manual coding [ 6 ] , the subjective assessment of the correctness of AI-generated responses [ 7 ] , and the fact that excessive reliance on AI could hinder their learning [ 8 ] . Software modeling represents an interpretive and creative practice [ 9 ] within software engineering. Among the various modeling approaches, the Unified Modeling Language (UML) remains a widely adopted standard in both educational and professional contexts. As in other domains, GenAI is beginning to reshape how UML-based modeling is taught and applied in practice. While much attention has been given to the capabilities and limitations of AI in general, its long-term ethical implications in software modeling education, particularly those introduced by GenAI, remain largely unexamined. With GenAI tools now assisting in tasks such as translating requirements into models and automating diagram construction [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 5 , 1 , 13 ] , there is a growing need to critically evaluate their impact on student learning, autonomy, and modeling integrity. Current works usually leave the ethical issues of GenAI out of their discussions. In this paper, we investigate the ethical dimensions associated with the use of GenAI in software modeling education. We conduct a systematic review of the literature to thoroughly identify the state of the art and examine the extent to which ethical considerations are being addressed or overlooked in current research. To our surprise, we only found three papers (aka primary studies) that explicitly discuss ethics in their educational modeling context. We have analyzed these three studies and discuss the opportunities for new lines of research and the challenges identified in the area. The remaining of the paper is structured as follows. In Section II we outline the search methodology. Section III describes the three primary studies identified by our search. Section IV discusses these papers based on our analysis of the ethical dimension. In Section V we present the related work and finally, we conclude the paper in Section VI . Search Engine ACM Elsevier (Science Direct) IEEE Explore Scopus SpringerLink Web of Science Total Num papers 925 4,069 39 710 156 8 5,907 TABLE I: Papers retrieved by search engines II Review Method To collect papers related to the ethical aspects of the use of GenAI in software modeling education, we followed a structured method partially inspired by the guidelines of Kitchenham [ 14 ] and Webster et al. [ 15 ] . We explain in the following the methodology that we followed. II-A Inclusion and exclusion criteria The inclusion criteria define the scope of our systematic literature review and enable us to identify papers of interest. We focus on those papers that: • Are written in English, peer-reviewed, published between Jan 2022 and Feb 2025, belong to the Computer Science or Engineering fields, and are research papers with 4 or more pages (i.e., no editorials, invited keynotes, etc.). • Focus on the areas of: – Empirical studies for academia regarding software modeling with student participants, – Approaches and/or tools for students where ethical aspects are covered, regardless of whether the paper has or has not have evaluated the approach/tool with student participants (i.e., its design takes into consideration ethical aspects despite the lack of evaluation of these), – Methodologies, – Position / vision papers that address ethical aspects in modeling education. Knowing that we could find papers that address the topic as their core contribution and papers whose main contribution is not ethics but they address this aspect as part of it, we decided to include both kinds. Exclusion criteria enabled us to filter out irrelevant papers. We decided to exclude papers that do not focus on software modeling, that are secondary studies (surveys, systematic literature reviews, and mapping studies), or those papers that only mention ethic-related topics only as future work. We also excluded venues of well-known questionable or predatory practices. II-B Data sources We searched in six databases: ACM, Elsevier (Science Direct), IEEE Explorer, Scopus, SpringerLink and Web of Science. We did not use DBLP since it only allows the search in the title. II-C Search Strategy and Paper Selection We defined the following search string: (*GPT* OR LLM OR ”foundation model”) AND (”software model*” OR UML OR ”conceptual model*” OR metamodel OR ”meta-model” OR ”conceptual schema” OR ”domain model” OR ”structural model” OR ”behavioral model” OR ”system model” OR ”design model” OR ”architectural model”) AND (Ethic* OR responsibl* OR fair* OR explainab* OR transparen* OR bias OR priva* OR safety OR inclusiv* OR diversity OR equal* OR complian* OR sustainab*) AND (”education” OR ”academia” OR student*) Wildcards (*) stand for any substring. For instance, model* could match with: model, modeling, modelling, etc. 1 1 1 Please note that not all search engines support this type of queries. When queries containing wildcards were not supported, we adapted the string to the particular search engine. In addition, Elsevier limits the number of logical operators that can be used in a query hence we had to run multiple queries and merge the results. . We searched in the whole

Read the complete text