Modeling the Carbon Footprint of HPC: The Top 500 and EasyC

1 st Varsha Rao, 2 nd Andrew A. Chien · 2025

Read Modeling the Carbon Footprint of HPC: The Top 500 and EasyC by 1 st Varsha Rao, 2 nd Andrew A. Chien (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-13583.txt.

Introduction

Varsha Rao and Andrew A. Chien measure the carbon footprint of high-performance computing in a 2025 paper. Standard greenhouse gas accounting is hard for one supercomputer and nearly impossible across the whole field, so even the biggest sites do not report it. The pair focus on the Top 500 list of the world's fastest systems.

Their tool, EasyC, models emissions from only a few disclosed metrics. It covered operational carbon for most listed systems and embodied carbon, the emissions from building the hardware, for over half, and interpolation filled the rest. Their first full estimates put the Top 500 at well over a million tonnes of operational emissions per year, with projections rising through 2030.

Catalog record

CREATOR1 st Varsha Rao, 2 nd Andrew A. Chien
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-13583

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling the Carbon Footprint of HPC: The Top 500 and EasyC 1 st Varsha Rao, 2 nd Andrew A. Chien Abstract Climate change is a critical concern for HPC systems, but GHG protocol carbon-emission accounting methodologies are difficult for a single system, and effectively infeasible for a collection of systems. As a result, there is no HPC-wide carbon reporting, and even the largest HPC sites do not do GHG protocol reporting. We assess the carbon footprint of HPC, focusing on the Top 500 systems. 1 1 1 This work has been accepted at the ACM/IEEE Workshops of the International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage and Analysis (SC Workshops ’25), November 16–21, 2025, St Louis, MO, USA. The key challenge lies in modeling the carbon footprint with limited data availability. With the disclosed Top500.org data, and using a new tool, EasyC, we were able to model the operational carbon of 391 HPC systems and the embodied carbon of 283 HPC systems. We further show how this coverage can be enhanced by exploiting additional public information. With improved coverage, then interpolation is used to produce the first carbon footprint estimates of the Top 500 HPC systems. They are 1.4 million MT CO2e operational carbon (1 Year) and 1.9 million MT CO2e embodied carbon. We also project how the Top 500’s carbon footprint will increase through 2030. A key enabler is the EasyC tool which models carbon footprint with only a few data metrics. We explore availability of data and enhancement, showing that coverage can be increased to 98% of Top 500 systems for operational and 80.8% of the systems for embodied emissions. I Introduction Global warming is accelerating at an alarming rate [ 1 ] , and computing’s increased use is an important and growing contributor. Data center global power demand is predicted to increase 165% by 2030 compared to 2023 [ 2 ] . A significant part of this growth is driven by emerging compute and hardware-intensive applications, such as large language models [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] and the increasing use of scientific simulations [ 6 ] . While these applications offer substantial potential for scientific progress, they also carry a considerable carbon footprint. Within the High Performance Computing (HPC) community, there is rising concern as evidenced by increased scientific meetings, and a growing body of literature [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . This interest is driven both by the civic/environmental awareness of the HPC community, and more starkly by the rapid growth of the carbon footprint of HPC systems which are consuming more energy and producing higher carbon emissions due to continued expansion [ 13 , 14 ] . This concern is broad-based, despite little broad analysis of HPC carbon footprint. Despite this, carbon emission reporting for HPC systems is rare. For example, none of the Top 25 computing systems (Top 500 list) report their carbon footprint. GHG protocol carbon emission accounting methodologies [ 15 ] require far too much effort, and more problematically a broad collection of accurate data inputs. Despite that, GHG protocol approaches are used by many large companies, including tech companies [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] , at large cost and with outcomes of questionable value. Academic research studies have skirted the limits of significant per-system effort and extensive data requirements (under the GHG protocols), compromising either the rigor of studies, guessing or estimating many of the input data metrics [ 11 , 10 , 20 ] . External estimates of computer systems data metrics are even more difficult, making objective academic study challenging and often inaccurate. So, these existing examples provide no way to report the carbon footprint of a specific identifiable set of systems, such as the Top500, government-funded research computing facilities, or scientific HPC platforms in Europe. This is unfortunate because to reduce emissions from HPC systems, we need widespread carbon footprint assessments. Achieving this at scale requires methods that work with limited data and low human effort. We use the Top500 November 2024 list [ 14 ] as a proxy to evaluate the carbon emissions of HPC systems. We perform a broad analysis of the Top 500 systems, enabled by the EasyC [ 21 ] tool that dramatically reduces the detailed data requirements and effort, compared to the GHG protocol. The results characterize the operational and embodied carbon for this collection of systems, representative of the HPC computing community. We further examine multiple data input scenarios, assessing coverage and the change that new data can make to carbon footprint models (sensitivity). Finally, we use the data to project the future changes in HPC carbon footprint, and important metrics such as compute-to-carbon footprint ratio. Specific contributions include: • The first assessment of Top500 carbon footprint. Annual operational carbon is 1.39 million MT CO2e (equivalent to 325k gasoline-powered vehicles annual emissions). Embodied carbon is 1.88 million MT CO2e (equivalent to 439k gasoline-powered vehicles annual emissions). • An assessment of a carbon modeling tool, EasyC, that shows the carbon footprint (operational and embodied) of 56.6% of the Top 500 systems can be captured using only the data from Top500.org. • With additional public information, the coverage increases to 98% for operational carbon and 80.8% for embodied carbon. The carbon footprint of the remaining systems can be further computed through interpolation. Thus the carbon footprint of the entire Top500 can be computed with Top500.org data, other publicly available sources, and interpolation. • Projection of the Top 500 carbon footprint thru 2030. Operational carbon footprint continues to increase rapidly (10.3%/year), reaching 1.8x its 2024 level by 2030. Embodied carbon grows slower (2%/year), reaching 1.1x. II Problem Carbon emissions from HPC systems are increasing, but sustainability reporting for these systems is basically non-existent. Existing carbon accounting methodologies require substantial data and human effort, making them impractical for widespread use. Research computing facilities often operate under tight budgets, with staff juggling multiple roles to support a diverse and demanding user base. As a result, they have limited capacity to take on additional sustainability efforts. We focus on the challenge of assessing the carbon footprint of scientific/HPC systems. How can it be done comprehensively? How can we create a basis for regular reporting? A solution for it must have the following attributes: • Achieve broad coverage, including the full range of HPC systems. • Employ only limited data (a few data metrics) that are readily available • Require only modest human effort, as many HPC organizations are short-staffed • Provide a ”gentle slope”, allowing the addition of data metrics for unusual circumstances. And we believe that, to be practicable, carbon footprint reporting for each system should require less than a person-hour of effort per year. III Approach We assess the carbon footprint of HPC systems using the Top500 November 2024 list [ 14 ] as a representative set of systems. 2 2 2 We expect to update for the June 2025 Top 500 list by the time of the workshop. Our approach builds on an existing tool for carbon-footprint modeling for computer systems called EasyC. It requires modest effort, low data, and provides high quality footprint reporting [ 21 ] , see Figure

Read the complete text