Textarium: Entangling Annotation, Abstraction and Argument

Philipp Proff Technical University Berlin Berlin University of the Arts, Marian Dörk University of Applied Sciences Potsdam · 2025

Read Textarium: Entangling Annotation, Abstraction and Argument by Philipp Proff Technical University Berlin Berlin University of the Arts, Marian Dörk University of Applied Sciences Potsdam (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-13191.txt.

Introduction

Philipp Proff and Marian Dörk present Textarium, a web-based setting for interpreting text, in a 2025 paper. Scholars who read and write about texts usually split the job across separate tools. Textarium joins those activities together while the reading is happening. It pairs human study with light computational help, and it aims to connect two habits of reading: the close kind, and the distant kind.

Inside the tool, a reader marks passages that matter. Keywords can be gathered and grouped into concepts. Observations can be dropped into an essay as anchors. The screen shows each interpretive move as a state of a visualisation, set by chosen parameters. The authors argue for a way of reading and writing in which the path an interpretation took stays visible to everyone else.

Catalog record

CREATORPhilipp Proff Technical University Berlin Berlin University of the Arts, Marian Dörk University of Applied Sciences Potsdam
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-13191

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Textarium: Entangling Annotation, Abstraction and Argument Philipp Proff Technical University Berlin Berlin University of the Arts, Marian Dörk University of Applied Sciences Potsdam Abstract We present a web-based environment that connects annotation, abstraction, and argumentation during the interpretation of text. As a visual interface for scholarly reading and writing, Textarium combines human analysis with lightweight computational processing to bridge close and distant reading practices. Readers can highlight text, group keywords into concepts, and embed these observations as anchors in essays. The interface renders these interpretive actions as parameterized visualization states. Through a speculative design process of co-creative and iterative prototyping, we developed a reading-writing approach that makes interpretive processes transparent and shareable within digital narratives. \vgtcinsertpkg \onlineid 1002 \vgtccategory Research \teaser Workflow in the Textarium environment. User-curated annotations and abstractions get algorithmically augmented and can be embedded into an interactive article. keywords Digital humanities, text analysis, annotation, data visualization, storytelling, scholarly communication. 1 Introduction The process of text interpretation has changed many times over the course of history. With the emergence of the computer, the analysis and interpretation of text have been fundamentally transformed and computer-assisted text analysis has become an integral part of interpretative practices [ 35 ] . As natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning (ML) become better at processing textual data, research projects within the digital humanities (DH) explore their possible use-cases during the text interpretation process. The survey by Jänicke et al. [ 20 ] has shown a division between top-down approaches extracting overall patterns from large of corpora [ 30 ] , and bottom-up techniques that augment established reading techniques [ 22 ] . However, there is a growing critique that distant reading methodologies, when used in isolation, can yield meaningless results [ 9 ] and obscure ambiguous evidence [ 10 ] . An increasing number of projects is interested in combining close and distant reading techniques because the algorithmic analysis of complex relationships can benefit from human contextualization [ 17 ] . Visualizations play a central role in this debate, as they can streamline and augment various analysis tasks [ 27 ] . Data visualizations have the potential to bridge the gap between close and distant reading, facilitating a more holistic and critical interpretation process [ 41 ] . DH scholar Johanna Drucker has even argued for acknowledging interactive visualizations as the central mode of knowledge production [ 11 ] . There has also been growing interest in integrating interactive visualizations within other dissemination formats, to enhance their communicative qualities. Scrollytellings are a popular format allowing authors to create narrated stories that punctually use data visualization to depict concepts or provide visual evidence [ 38 ] . The sciences have adopted interactive notebook environments, such as Jupyter Notebook or Observable, to integrate computational data analysis with research documentation and dissemination. In contrast, similar DH tools either specialize in text analysis or result presentation. This creates an opportunity for the design and development of tools that combine these interdependent modes of inquiry. Such tools could enable readers to interactively explore others’ text interpretation workflows and even start alternative explorations from their checkpoints. To address these aspirations we developed Textarium, an experimental web-based environment that integrates interpretation and authoring of text. 2 Background Our work relates to previous research on interactive text visualizations, especially those combining close and distant reading, open-ended text visualizations, and interactive data stories. Text Analysis . Novel text structures and formats, such as hypertext, have prompted new text analysis methodologies to address contemporary questions in literature. Hybrid forms of text analysis are needed, that can adapt to novel, nonlinear, digital text formats and build on the recent advancements in NLP. For Lev Manovich “computers and software are not just ‘technology’ but rather the new medium in which we can think and imagine differently” [ 28 , p. 13] . Katherine Hayles exemplifies this idea by combining of close reading with social network platforms, such as Facebook, for text analysis [ 17 ] . Close reading is often split into an “inspectional” reading to get an overview of the text structure and an “analytical” reading for an in-depth analysis of characters, style, and inter-textual relations. Highlighting and annotation are important techniques in this process because they enable readers to actively engage with the text. Additionally, annotation allows the inscription of one’s own perspective into the analysis process and visually curate new knowledge [ 21 ] . Most text analysis tools for close reading provide split-screen interfaces for the creation and modeling of hyperlinked annotations on a canvas [ 40 ] . Many tools also allow scholars to visually alter the source text, to emphasize specific structures or word occurrences [ 20 ] . Tools such as CATMA, developed in the context of literary studies, show how flexible annotation environments can accommodate a range of analytical approaches from exploratory to taxonomy-driven [ 16 ] . Unlike physical paper, digital tools allow the extraction, re-arrangement, and linking of text sections [ 7 ] . Due to the rapid advances in NLP and ML research, machines are becoming better at extracting meaning from texts, which is often referred to as machine reading [ 14 ] . NLP algorithms are increasingly used in the DH to normalize historical morphological changes in words [ 33 ] , analyze word reuse patterns [ 6 ] , and conduct comparative analyses for works by the same author [ 36 ] . The employed algorithms build upon the advances in recent decades from computational linguistics and information theory. They are built to be deterministic and produce consistent results. However, as natural language is a dynamic system, contemporary ML architectures are more flexible and produce probabilistic models which learn from large amounts of “wild” text data. Although, this allows the models to be more adaptable, they are also prone to produce inconsistent results and reproduce biases from their training data [ 5 ] . Text Visualization . The visualization of textual data can support interpretative processes by transforming linguistic features into visual representations. Interactivity plays a central role in most text visualization techniques as it allows to reconfigure views and reorganize the contents as a form of direct interpretation [ 1 ] . A survey by Jänicke et al. [ 20 ] outlines a range of visualization approaches that support both close and distant reading, highlighting the importance of visual annotation as a bridge between them. Approaches in which the readers’ annotations serve as a starting point can be called bottom-up. Research in this area has explored “human-in-the-loop” techniques that allow readers to steer ML algorithms via annotations [ 25 ] or support comparative analysis by providing split views of annotations from different analysis iterations [ 42 ] . Conversely, tasks in which the machine initially analyzes the entire text can be called top-down. Top-down approaches typically utilize algorithms for semantic clustering and semantic mapping [ 34 ] . For example, Voyant utilizes pre-defined computational analyses—such as word frequency, collocation, and topic modeling—to extract patterns from individual documents and large corpora [ 39 ] . The results of the analysis can be made visible through a close reading view by adding annotations in the source text or creating interactive network visualizations

Read the complete text