Anisoplanatic errors in two-wavelength adaptive optics

2025

Read Anisoplanatic errors in two-wavelength adaptive optics (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-12970.txt.

Introduction

Milo Hyde, Mark Spencer and Matt Kalensky derive in 2025 the error from split beams in two-color optics that fix air blur. Most such systems sense blur at one color and fix at a second. Past work grades one color alone and skips the split.

They derive spread forms for path error with piston cut, and with tilt also cut. Both forms include the split effect. Checks against brute counts back the forms. A two-color clear angle is set out for quick grades. The work should guide design for imaging and beam shots.

Catalog record

YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-12970

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Anisoplanatic errors in two-wavelength adaptive optics Abstract Two-wavelength adaptive optics (AO) systems sense wavefront errors using a beacon at one wavelength, while correcting for subsequent imaging or beam projection at another. Although most AO systems operate in this manner, the relevant AO literature is generally concerned with quantifying system performance at a single wavelength, effectively ignoring the two-wavelength nature of the problem. In this paper, we study the effects of anisoplanatism, or the physical separation of the beacon and transmit light, on two-wavelength AO systems for imaging and beam projection applications. We derive the piston-removed (PR) and piston-and-tilt-removed (PTR) optical-path-difference (OPD) variances including anisoplanatism, which are key metrics of AO system performance. We compare our closed-form PR and PTR OPD variances to numerical results and discuss their physical significance. In addition, we introduce the two-wavelength isoplanatic angle and show how it can be used to quickly assess two-wavelength AO system performance. At large, the analysis contained in this paper will inform the design and implementation of two-wavelength AO systems for multiple imaging and beam projection applications. † † journal: Radio Science † † authors: M. W. Hyde, M. F. Spencer, and M. Kalensky † † corresponding: M. Hyde, [email protected] Epsilon C5I, Beavercreek, OH 45431 USA The University of Arizona, James C. Wyant College of Optical Sciences, Tucson, AZ 85721 USA Naval Surface Warfare Center Dahlgren Division, Dahlgren, VA 22448 USA. keypoints Quantifies the effects of anisoplanatism on two-wavelength adaptive optics systems for imaging and beam projection applications Introduces the two-wavelength isoplanatic angle as a key predictor of system performance Closed-form expressions for anisoplanatic errors are in excellent agreement with numerical results 1 Introduction Two-wavelength adaptive optics (AO) is when wavefront sensing, using light from an artificial or natural beacon, is performed at one wavelength \lambda_{\text{B}} and correction (for imaging or beam projection) is performed at another \lambda_{\text{T}} . This scenario is common in astronomy, where light from laser guide stars excites sodium atoms in the mesosphere forming multiple beacons Gilmozzi & Spyromilio (2007) ; Sanders (2013) ; Hardy (1998) . Here, 589.2 nm light is used to sense and correct turbulence-induced wavefront aberrations. Scientific analysis or imaging, however, is typically performed at longer wavelengths in the short-wave infrared. In the late 1970s and early 1980s, contemporary with the development of laser guide stars Ageorges & Dainty (2000) ; Fugate et al. (1994) ; Fugate et al. (1991) ; Fugate et al. (2023) ; Parenti & Sasiela (1994) , researchers such as Lukin (1979) , Hogge & Butts (1982) , J.F. Holmes & Gudimetla (1983) , Winocur (1983) , and Wallner (1984) quantified the residual wavefront errors or drop in Strehl ratio inherent in two-wavelength AO systems. Lukin (1979) and Hogge & Butts (1982) derived integral expressions for the two-wavelength phase and optical-path-difference (OPD) variances in weak atmospheric turbulence, respectively. J.F. Holmes & Gudimetla (1983) numerically investigated the reduction in Strehl ratio due to differences in the beacon and transmit wavelengths. Winocur (1983) investigated the effects of \lambda_{\text{B}} - \lambda_{\text{T}} separation on the first five Zernike polynomials/aberrations, with special emphasis on Zernike tilt. Lastly, Wallner (1984) compared diffractive OPD error—originally studied by Lukin (1979) and Hogge & Butts (1982) —to refractive error caused by atmospheric dispersion. From this early analysis, a consensus emerged: As long as \lambda_{\text{B}}<\lambda_{\text{T}} and the \lambda_{\text{B}} - \lambda_{\text{T}} separation was less than a few microns, diffractive error was generally negligible for astronomical/vertical viewing. AO research for astronomy naturally shifted toward quantifying and correcting refractive and anisoplanatic errors, which are prevalent in wide-field-of-view imaging systems Johnston & Welsh (1994) ; Devaney et al. (2008) ; Wang et al. (2012) . Recently, there has been interest in applying two-wavelength AO for imaging and beam projection systems that operate in complementary conditions to astronomy, i.e., over small fields of view and long horizontal paths Wu et al. (2023) ; Ke & Chen (2020) ; Ke & Ke (2025) ; M.W. Hyde, McCrae et al. (2024) ; M.W. Hyde, Kalensky & Spencer (2024) ; Hyde et al. (2025) ; R.B. Holmes (2022) ; Perram et al. (2010) ; Merritt & Spencer (2018) . As such, design considerations for such systems commonly result in \lambda_{\text{B}}>\lambda_{\text{T}} , violating one of the conditions derived by early two-wavelength AO researchers. Three recent works by us explored wavefront errors in two-wavelength AO systems for imaging and beam projection applications: The first investigated branch point/branch cut Fried & Vaughn (1992) ; Fried (1998) effects for two-wavelength AO systems operating in strong turbulence M.W. Hyde, McCrae et al. (2024) . The second derived closed-form scaling law formulas for the plane-wave, two-wavelength, piston-removed (PR) OPD variance M.W. Hyde, Kalensky & Spencer (2024) . Lastly, the third derived spherical-wave, two-wavelength OPD variance expressions for tilt and higher-order wavefront errors Hyde et al. (2025) . Although those three works quantified a majority of the relevant errors in two-wavelength AO, they did not consider anisoplanatism (i.e., the physical separation of \lambda_{\text{B}} and \lambda_{\text{T}} ), which is a major source of error in AO Fried (1979) ; Sasiela (2007) ; Beck & Bos (2020) ; Bos (2024) ; Kalensky et al. (2024) . To our knowledge, two-wavelength anisoplanatic error has never been quantified before and, as we show in subsequent sections, is a significant theoretical undertaking, well beyond that of our prior works. Figure 1: Two-wavelength, anisoplanatic propagation geometry. Two off-axis point sources—one at wavelength \lambda_{\text{B}} and location \boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{B}} and the other at wavelength \lambda_{\text{T}} and location \boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{T}} —emit spherical waves that propagate a distance z through atmospheric turbulence and are received through a circular aperture of diameter D . In this paper, we quantify the two-wavelength, anisoplanatic PR and piston-and-tilt-removed (PTR) OPD variances, which are applicable to the tilt and higher-order correcting subsystems of two-wavelength AO systems. The geometry for our subsequent analysis is shown in Figure 1 . The figure depicts two point sources, of differing wavelengths ( \lambda_{\text{B}} and \lambda_{\text{T}} ) and off-axis locations ( \boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{B}} and \boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{T}} ), radiating spherical waves a distance z through atmospheric turbulence. These waves enter a circular aperture of diameter D . Our goal is to find an expression for the variance of the OPD \Delta\ell —or phase difference via \phi\left(\lambda\right)=k\Delta\ell, (1) where k=2\pi/\lambda —between these two point sources as a function of their wavelength and location deltas, i.e., \lambda_{\text{B}}-\lambda_{\text{T}} and \boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{B}}-\boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{T}}=\boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{D}} . In what follows, we begin with the two-wavelength, anisoplanatic PR OPD variance and conclude with the associated PTR OPD variance. Throughout our analysis, we compare our closed-form expressions to numerical results and discuss their physical significance. In addition, we introduce the two-wavelength isoplanatic angle—a generalized version of the traditional isoplanatic angle \theta_{0} Fried (1979) ; Sasiela (2007) —and discuss how it can be used to gauge two-wavelength AO system performance. Lastly, we conclude with a summary of our work and contributions. 2 Anisoplanatic, Two-Wavelength PR OPD Variance We begin our analysis with an expression for the PR optical path length \ell over the circular aperture of diameter D (see Fig. 1 ): \ell_{\text{PR}}\left(\boldsymbol{\rho},z;\lambda,\boldsymbol{\rho}_{c}\right)=\ell\left(\boldsymbol{\rho},z;\lambda,\boldsymbol{\rho}_{c}\right)-\frac{1}{A}\iint_{-\infty}^{\infty}\operatorname{circ}\left({\frac{\boldsymbol{\rho}}{D/2}}\right)\ell\left(\boldsymbol{\rho},z;\lambda,\boldsymbol{\rho}_{c}\right)\text{d}^{2}\rho, (2) where A=\pi\left(D/2\right)^{2} and \boldsymbol{\rho}_{c} is the off-axis location of the point source. The PR OPD variance between the two point sources in Figure 1 , averaged over the aperture, is \left\langle\Delta\ell_{\text{PR}}^{2}\right\rangle=\frac{1}{A}\iint_{-\infty}^{\infty}\operatorname{circ}\left({\frac{\boldsymbol{\rho}}{D/2}}\right)\left\langle\left[\ell_{\text{PR}}\left(\boldsymbol{\rho},z;\lambda_{\text{B}},\boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{B}}\right)-\ell_{\text{PR}}\left(\boldsymbol{\rho},z;\lambda_{\text{T}},\boldsymbol{\rho}_{\text{T}}\right)\right]^{2}\right\rangle\text{d}^{2}\rho. (3) Substituting Eq. ( 2 )

Read the complete text