Evolution of low surface brightness ultra-thin galaxies: The role of dark matter halo and bar formation on disk thickness

K. Aditya, Arunima Banerjee · 2025

Read Evolution of low surface brightness ultra-thin galaxies: The role of dark matter halo and bar formation on disk thickness by K. Aditya, Arunima Banerjee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-12966.txt.

Introduction

K. Aditya and Arunima Banerjee investigate how ultra-thin galaxies stay so thin in a 2025 paper. Low surface brightness ultra-thin galaxies have stellar disks whose thickness is only about a tenth of their length scale. How such disks sustain that structure throughout their evolution is the central question.

Using collisionless N-body simulations, the authors evolved model disks inside dark matter halos of steep, shallow, and intermediate concentration. Their models matched the observed properties of the galaxy FGC 2366, including surface brightness, disk scale length, and vertical thinness, while excluding gas to isolate dark matter effects. Bar-driven internal heating, a mechanism that can thicken disks, was suppressed regardless of halo concentration. Disk thinness remained roughly constant, suggesting the low surface brightness nature itself prevents thickening.

Catalog record

CREATORK. Aditya, Arunima Banerjee
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-12966

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evolution of low surface brightness ultra-thin galaxies: The role of dark matter halo and bar formation on disk thickness K. Aditya, Arunima Banerjee Abstract We investigate how stellar disks sustain their ultrathin structure throughout their evolution. We follow the evolution of ultrathin stellar disks with varying dark matter (DM) halo concentration ( c c ) using collisionless N N -body simulations with AREPO . We test models embedded in steep ( c = 12 c=12 ), shallow ( c = 2 c=2 ), and intermediate ( c = 6 c=6 ) DM concentrations. Our models match the observed structural properties of the stellar disk in the low surface brightness (LSB) ultrathin galaxy FGC 2366, specifically its surface brightness, disk scalelength, and vertical thinness ( h z / R D = 0.1 h_{z}/R_{D}=0.1 ), while excluding gas, allowing us to isolate the effects of DM. The internal disk heating mechanism driven by bars is suppressed in the LSB ultrathin stellar disks regardless of the DM concentration. The ratio of disk thickness ( h z h_{z} ) to scalelength ( R D R_{D} ) remains constant at ≤ 0.1 \leq 0.1 throughout their evolution. To clearly establish that the LSB nature of stellar disks is the key to preventing disk thickening, we construct the initial conditions by increasing the stellar mass fraction from f s ∼ 0.01 f_{s}\sim 0.01 to 0.02 0.02 and 0.04 0.04 , respectively, while keeping the total mass equal to 10 11 ​ M ⊙ 10^{11}M_{\odot} and h z / R D ≤ 0.1 h_{z}/R_{D}\leq 0.1 unchanged. We find that models with a higher stellar mass fraction embedded in a shallow DM potential ( c = 2 c=2 ) form bars and undergo significant disk thickening ( h z / R D ≫ 0.1 h_{z}/R_{D}\gg 0.1 ) concurrent with the bar growth. We conclude that if the LSB disks are thin to begin with, they remain so throughout their evolution in isolation, regardless of the concentration of the DM halo. I Introduction Ultrathin galaxies (UTGs) are late-type edge-on disk galaxies characterized by a large major-to-minor-axis ratio (a/b>10) ( J. W. Goad & M. S. Roberts 1981 ; L. Matthews et al. 1999 ; K. Aditya et al. 2022 ; K. Aditya et al. 2023 ) . The UTGs lack a discernible bulge component and exhibit low surface brightness, with central surface brightness in B-band, \mu_{B}>22.5\,mag\,arcsec^{-2} ( S. S. McGaugh 1996 ; G. Bothun et al. 1997 ) . Although ubiquitous in observations ( I. D. Karachentsev et al. 1999 ; S. Kautsch et al. 2006 ; D. Bizyaev et al. 2017 ; D. Bizyaev et al. 2021 ) , UTGs are notably rare in \Lambda CDM simulations. M. Haslbauer et al. 2022 , measured the sky-projected aspect ratio distribution in the \Lambda CDM simulations: IllustrisTNG ( M. Vogelsberger et al. 2014 ; A. Pillepich et al. 2018 ) , and EAGLE ( J. Schaye et al. 2015 ) and found that these simulations are deficient in galaxies with intrinsically thin disks. Additionally, C. Bottrell et al. 2017 show that these simulations are deficient in bulge-dominated low-mass galaxies. However, more recent studies by J. Hu et al. 2024 and D. Xu et al. 2024 show that there is no shortage of thin disc galaxies in TNG-50. It is now well established that the bars, spiral arms ( K. Saha 2014 ; M. Aumer et al. 2016 ; R. J. Grand et al. 2016 ) can significantly heat the stellar disks radially, and Giant molecular clouds ( A. Jenkins & J. Binney 1990 ) can heat the stellar disks radially and isotropically. However, the minimal vertical thickness indicates a negligible effect of disk heating agents in UTGs. Thus, the formation, evolution, and sustenance of these extremely thin stellar disks in UTGs remain a mystery and challenge our current understanding of galaxy formation and evolution models. UTGs are distinguished by their extreme structural and photometric properties and characterized by equally extreme kinematic and dynamical features. A. Komanduri et al. 2020 ; K. Aditya & A. Banerjee 2021 have shown UTGs have central vertical velocity dispersion (\sigma_{0s}=10\mbox{km\,s${}^{-1}$}-18\mbox{km\,s${}^{-1}$}) comparable to the thin stellar disk in the Milky Way ( S. Sharma et al. 2014 ) . Additionally, UTGs are dynamically stable against growth of axisymmetric instabilities ( K. Aditya & A. Banerjee 2021 ; K. Aditya et al. 2022 ; K. Aditya et al. 2023 ) , which may explain the low star formation rates observed in these galaxies ( G. Narayanan & A. Banerjee 2021 ) . Furthermore, UTGs have a higher specific angular momentum compared to the ordinary spiral galaxies ( V. Jadhav Y & A. Banerjee 2019 ; K. Aditya et al. 2022 ; K. Aditya et al. 2023 ) , indicating that these galaxies rotate faster than ordinary spiral galaxies for a given stellar mass. It has been demonstrated that the extreme flattening of UTGs can be attributed to a compact and dense DM halo ( A. Banerjee & C. J. Jog 2013 ) . This finding is further supported by DM models based on H I 21 cm synthesis observations of two of the thinnest known galaxies, FGC 1440 (a/b=20) and FGC 2366 (a/b=22) ( K. Aditya et al. 2022 ; K. Aditya et al. 2023 ) . These results suggest that the DM halo plays an important role in regulating the vertical structure of galaxies hosting extremely thin stellar disks. Previous studies have shown that bar formation in low surface brightness (LSB) galaxies is closely tied to the mass distribution of the stellar and DM components. Numerical simulations of low surface brightness galaxies indicate that bar formation requires a disk mass at least twice as high as typically inferred for LSBs ( L. Mayer & J. Wadsley 2004 ) . Disks with low surface density are generally stable against bar formation, especially within halos with relatively higher DM concentration. Similarly, simulations by J. A. Sellwood & N. W. Evans 2001 show that a stellar disk embedded in a DM halo with a large core radius is stable to m=2 modes ( A. Toomre 1981 ) . This is further corroborated in the numerical work by S. Ghosh & C. J. Jog 2014 , who show that a dominant DM halo can suppress the formation of both axisymmetric and non-axisymmetric instabilities like bars and spiral formation in the prototypical low surface brightness UTG UGC 7321. Besides, cosmological simulations show that LSBs often inhabit halos with relatively low central density ( J. Bailin et al. 2005 ) or high spin ( L. E. Pérez-Montaño et al. 2022 ; K. Chim-Ramirez et al. 2025 ) , yielding extended stellar disks with low central densities. K. Chim-Ramirez et al. 2025 shows that the lower bar fraction in LSBs in the TNG-100 simulations is associated with their higher spin and gas content, factors known to inhibit bar formation and growth. While previous studies have addressed the influence of DM on the vertical structure of ultra-thin galaxies (UTGs) using semi-analytic models, and have probed the connection between bar formation and DM concentration in low surface brightness (LSB) galaxies, these investigations have largely treated these effects in isolation. The nexus between the shape of

Read the complete text