Shedding light on the nature of ϕ ⁡ ( 2170 ) \phi(2170) state in the e + ​ e − → ϕ ​ π + ​ π − e^{+}e^{-}\to\phi\pi^{+}\pi^{-} reaction

Xiang Wei, Qing-Hua Shen, Xiao-Hai Liu, Ju-Jun Xie · 2025

Read Shedding light on the nature of ϕ ⁡ ( 2170 ) \phi(2170) state in the e + ​ e − → ϕ ​ π + ​ π − e^{+}e^{-}\to\phi\pi^{+}\pi^{-} reaction by Xiang Wei, Qing-Hua Shen, Xiao-Hai Liu, Ju-Jun Xie (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-12552.txt.

Introduction

An exotic particle seen in electron-positron collisions still lacks an agreed identity. It is the phi(2170). Xiang Wei and three co-authors test a new reading of it in 2025. They model its production with an effective Lagrangian approach. The final state holds a phi meson and two pions.

Alongside direct contributions from known mesons, they add a triangle process. A meson pair is produced first. One partner then decays. The remaining pair rescatters into the two pions. A dynamically generated scalar drives that last step. With the loop included, the model matches fresh BESIII measurements well. The match is best around the phi(2170) structure. The fit also pins down properties of two heavier kaon-like mesons.

Catalog record

CREATORXiang Wei, Qing-Hua Shen, Xiao-Hai Liu, Ju-Jun Xie
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-12552

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Shedding light on the nature of ϕ ⁡ ( 2170 ) \phi(2170) state in the e + ​ e − → ϕ ​ π + ​ π − e^{+}e^{-}\to\phi\pi^{+}\pi^{-} reaction Xiang Wei, Qing-Hua Shen, Xiao-Hai Liu, Ju-Jun Xie Abstract We investigate the production of ϕ ⁡ ( 2170 ) \phi(2170) state in the e + ​ e − → ϕ ​ π + ​ π − e^{+}e^{-}\to\phi\pi^{+}\pi^{-} reaction with the effective Lagrangian approach. In addition to the tree level contributions from the ϕ ⁡ ( 1680 ) \phi(1680) meson and a possible X(1750) state, we consider also the K 1 K_{1} - K K - K ¯ \bar{K} intermediate state process from the perspective of triangular singularity. Based on the one-photon exchange approximation, a pair of K 1 ​ K ¯ K_{1}\bar{K} mesons was firstly produced, and then the K 1 K_{1} meson subsequently decays into ϕ \phi and K K , and the K ​ K ¯ K\bar{K} pair produce the π + ​ π − \pi^{+}\pi^{-} through the final state interactions, in which the scalar meson f 0 ​ ( 980 ) f_{0}(980) is dynamically generated. We show that the inclusion of the triangle loop diagrams leads to a good description of the new BESIII measurements, especially for the structure of ϕ ⁡ ( 2170 ) \phi(2170) . This provides a novel interpretation of the ϕ ⁡ ( 2170 ) \phi(2170) state, offering new insights into its fundamental nature which is still unclear. Furthermore, it is found that these measurements on the e + ​ e − → ϕ ​ π + ​ π − e^{+}e^{-}\to\phi\pi^{+}\pi^{-} reaction can be used to determine some of the properties of two K 1 K_{1} mesons with masses around 1610 MeV and 1895 MeV, which are crucial to reproduce the experimental data. I Introduction The \phi(2170) state [previously refereed to as the Y(2175) ] with quantum numbers I^{G}(J^{PC})=0^{-}(1^{--}) was firstly observed in the \phi f_{0}(980) channel through the initial state radiation (ISR) e^{+}e^{-}\to\gamma_{ISR}\phi f_{0}(980) reaction by BaBar Collaboration in 2006 Aubert et al. 2006 . This observation was subsequently confirmed by other experimental groups, including the Belle Collaboration Shen et al. 2009 , BES and BESIII Collaborations Ablikim et al. 2008 ; Ablikim et al. 2015 ; Ablikim et al. 2019a ; Ablikim et al. 2020a ; Ablikim et al. 2021a ; Ablikim et al. 2023 . Additionally, further confirmation was provided by the BaBar Collaboration in their subsequent analyses Aubert et al. 2007 ; Lees et al. 2012 . Although the existence of the \phi(2170) state has been firmly established through these above experimental investigations, significant discrepancies persist in the determination of its Breit-Wigner parameters Shen and Yuan 2010 , especially concerning the total decay width, as reported in the latest review by the Particle Data Group (PDG) Navas et al. 2024 . The internal constituents of the \phi(2170) state are still unknown, which has stimulated extensive theoretical discussions. It is currently one of the most interesting particles in light hadron spectroscopy. In Fig. 1 , we collect the experimental results of the resonance parameters, Breit-Wigner mass M_{\phi(2170)} and width \Gamma_{\phi(2170)} , of \phi(2170) state obtained from different experimental processes, where one can find that the measured mass and width are different Huang 2021 . Especially, the values extracted from the e^{+}e^{-}\rightarrow\phi\pi^{+}\pi^{-} process by the Belle Collaboration Shen et al. 2009 and from the e^{+}e^{-}\to K^{+}K^{-} Ablikim et al. 2019b and e^{+}e^{-}\to K^{0}_{S}K^{0}_{L} Ablikim et al. 2021b reactions by the BESIII Collaboration are much different with others. These observed structures may potentially represent distinct hadronic states, rather than the \phi(2170) resonance. The situation cannot be clarified without further experimental measurements. And the latest average values of the resonance parameters of the \phi(2170) resonance as quoted in PDG Navas et al. 2024 are: \displaystyle M_{\phi(2170)} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 2164\pm 6~{\rm MeV}, (1) \displaystyle\Gamma_{\phi(2170)} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 106^{+24}_{-18}~{\rm MeV}. (2) Figure 1: A comprehensive compilation of the experimentally determined Breit-Wigner mass and width parameters for the \phi(2170) resonance, where the experimental data are taken from: BaBar 2006 Aubert et al. 2006 , BaBar 2008 Aubert et al. 2008 , BES 2008 Ablikim et al. 2008 , Belle 2009 Shen et al. 2009 , BaBar 2012 Lees et al. 2012 , BESIII 2015 Ablikim et al. 2015 , BESIII 2019 1 Ablikim et al. 2019a , BESIII 2019 2 Ablikim et al. 2019b , BESIII 2020 1 Ablikim et al. 2020b , BESIII 2020 2 Ablikim et al. 2021c , BESIII 2020 3 Ablikim et al. 2020a , BESIII 2021 1 Ablikim et al. 2021a ,BESIII 2021 2 Ablikim et al. 2021b , and BESIII 2023 Ablikim et al. 2023 . On the theoretical side, some explanations for the \phi(2170) sate were proposed, including traditional excited s\bar{s} state Ding and Yan 2007a ; Wang et al. 2012 ; Afonin and Pusenkov 2014 ; Pang 2019 ; Zhao et al. 2019 ; Li et al. 2021 , s\bar{s}g hybrid state Ding and Yan 2007b ; Ho et al. 2019 , ss\bar{s}\bar{s} tetra-quark state Wang 2007 ; Chen et al. 2008 ; Drenska et al. 2008 ; Deng et al. 2010 ; Ke and Li 2019 ; Agaev et al. 2020 ; Liu et al. 2021 , and \Lambda\bar{\Lambda} bound state Zhao et al. 2013 ; Deng et al. 2013 ; Dong et al. 2017 . Moreover, the \phi(2170) state has been extensively studied within the context of the \phi K\bar{K} system with subsystem K\bar{K} as the f_{0}(980) Martinez Torres et al. 2008 ; Gómez-Avila et al. 2009 . In this framework, the f_{0}(980) meson combines with the \phi meson to form a resonance with a mass around 2150 MeV. This dynamically generated state in the \phi K\bar{K} system with quantum numbers J^{PC}=1^{--} , predominantly decays into \phi f_{0}(980) . This decay pattern strongly supports its identification with the \phi(2170) state Martinez Torres et al. 2008 . Within this picture, the decay modes of \phi(2170) to \phi\eta and \phi\eta^{\prime} were investigated in Ref. Malabarba et al. 2023 . Additionally, the strong decays of \phi(2170) to final states involving various kaonic resonances have been conducted in Ref. Malabarba et al. 2021 , providing valuable insights into the decay dynamics and properties of the \phi(2170) state. The BESIII results Ablikim et al. 2020a ; Ablikim et al. 2021a ; Ablikim et al. 2023 suggest a nontrivial internal structure for the \phi(2170) state, making it a strong candidate for exotic interpretations, rather than as a simple radial excitation of the vector meson \phi(1020) Jafarzade and Lebed 2025 . Nevertheless, it should be noted that the predicted width of the \phi(2170) state from various theoretical models exhibits significant discrepancies when compared with experimental measurements. Therefore, from both experimental and theoretical perspectives, a more precise determination of the \phi(2170) resonance parameters is necessary for a better understanding of its nature. In this work, based on the recent measurements of the BESIII Collaboration Ablikim et al. 2023 , we advocate a very different picture for the production of the \phi(2170) state. The picture is that the \phi(2170) state is produced in the e^{+}e^{-}\to\phi\pi^{+}\pi^{-} process Ablikim et al. 2023 by the triangular singularity Liu et al. 2016 ; Bayar et al. 2016 ; Guo et

Read the complete text