When IIb Ceases To Be: Bridging the Gap Between IIb and Short-plateau Supernovae

Joseph Farah, D. Andrew Howell, Daichi Hiramatsu, Curtis McCully, Moira Andrews, Megan Newsome, Estefania Padilla Gonzalez, Craig Pellegrino, Edo Berger, Peter Blanchard, Sebastian Gomez, Harsh Kumar, K. Azalee Bostroem, Yuan Qi Ni, A. Gagliano, Aravind P. Ravi · 2025

Read When IIb Ceases To Be: Bridging the Gap Between IIb and Short-plateau Supernovae by Joseph Farah, D. Andrew Howell, Daichi Hiramatsu, Curtis McCully, Moira Andrews, Megan Newsome, Estefania Padilla Gonzalez, Craig Pellegrino, Edo Berger, Peter Blanchard, Sebastian Gomez, Harsh Kumar, K. Azalee Bostroem, Yuan Qi Ni, A. Gagliano, Aravind P. Ravi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-12470.txt.

Introduction

Some exploding stars keep a hydrogen coat, some lose nearly all of it, and theory predicts a smooth family of light curves in between. Joseph R. Farah and fifteen co-authors report two supernovae in 2025 that sit on the missing border between the double-peaked IIb class and the short-plateau class.

Both events show weak double peaks read as plateaus lasting only a few weeks, with hydrogen lines persisting and helium present but never dominant. Shock-cooling fits put their hydrogen envelopes well above classic IIb values and near the predicted short-plateau threshold. Together with famous comparison events, they support one continuous stripping sequence.

Catalog record

CREATORJoseph Farah, D. Andrew Howell, Daichi Hiramatsu, Curtis McCully, Moira Andrews, Megan Newsome, Estefania Padilla Gonzalez, Craig Pellegrino, Edo Berger, Peter Blanchard, Sebastian Gomez, Harsh Kumar, K. Azalee Bostroem, Yuan Qi Ni, A. Gagliano, Aravind P. Ravi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-12470

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When IIb Ceases To Be: Bridging the Gap Between IIb and Short-plateau Supernovae Joseph Farah, D. Andrew Howell, Daichi Hiramatsu, Curtis McCully, Moira Andrews, Megan Newsome, Estefania Padilla Gonzalez, Craig Pellegrino, Edo Berger, Peter Blanchard, Sebastian Gomez, Harsh Kumar, K. Azalee Bostroem, Yuan Qi Ni, A. Gagliano, Aravind P. Ravi Abstract Hydrogen-rich supernovae (SNe) span a range of hydrogen envelope masses at core collapse, producing diverse light curves from extended plateaus in Type IIP SNe to double-peaked Type IIb SNe. Recent hydrodynamic modeling predicts a continuous sequence of light-curve morphologies as hydrogen is removed, with short plateau SNe (plateau durations ≈ 50 ​ – ​ 70 \approx 50\text{--}70 days) emerging as a transitional class. However, the observational boundary between IIb and short-plateau remains poorly defined, and thus far unobserved. We report on extensive photometric and spectroscopic follow-up of SN 2023wdd and SN 2022acrv, candidate transitional events on the low-mass end of the short-plateau class. Both exhibit weak, double-peaked light curves which we interpret as exceptionally short plateaus (10–20 days), and hybrid spectral features: persistent H α \alpha absorption with He I contamination, but without the helium dominance characteristic of IIb SNe. Using analytic shock-cooling models and numerical light curve fitting, we estimate hydrogen-rich envelope masses of ∼ 0.6 ​ – ​ 0.8 ​ M ⊙ {\sim}0.6\text{--}0.8\ M_{\odot} –significantly larger than canonical IIb values ( ≲ 0.1 ​ M ⊙ \lesssim 0.1\ M_{\odot} ) but consistent with the ∼ 0.9 ​ M ⊙ {\sim}0.9\ M_{\odot} threshold predicted for short-plateau behavior. Although the progenitor radii inferred from analytic and numerical methods differ by factors of 2–5, envelope mass estimates are consistent across approaches. Comparisons to well-studied IIb (SN 2016gkg, SN 2022hnt), short-plateau (SN 2023ufx, SN 2006ai, SN 2016egz, SN 2006Y), and IIP SNe (SN 2023ixf, SN 2013ej) suggest a monotonic relationship between hydrogen envelope mass and plateau length consistent with analytic and numerical expectations. These findings provide additional evidence for a continuous distribution of envelope stripping in hydrogen-rich core-collapse progenitors and place SN 2023wdd and SN 2022acrv along the IIb/short-plateau boundary. I Introduction Hydrogen-rich supernovae (SNe) represent some of the most diverse outcomes of massive ( >8\ M_{\odot} ) star evolution, characterized by the removal—partial to near-complete—of the hydrogen and/or helium shells prior to core collapse. Within this broad umbrella, Type IIb SNe retain a thin layer of hydrogen, manifesting as early-time hydrogen lines in their spectra that later give way to helium-dominated features ( Woosley et al. 1994 ; Filippenko 1997 ; Modjaz et al. 2019 ; e.g.,) . At the opposite extreme lie the Type IIP SNe, which hold onto a substantial hydrogen envelope and exhibit long ( \sim 100 days) photometric plateaus (see Branch & Wheeler 2017 ; for a review) . Historically, this distinction between unstripped IIP and mostly-stripped IIb events suggested that these were separate pathways, reflecting either minimal or extensive mass loss. Yet, an emerging body of theoretical and observational evidence indicates the possibility of a continuum in the amount of hydrogen envelope stripping, raising the question of how many physically intermediate (or “transitional”) events remain unclassified under the standard taxonomy ( Chornock et al. 2011 ; Gal-Yam 2017 ; Hiramatsu et al. 2021 ; e.g.,) . The conventional picture of Type IIb progenitors invokes binary interaction or strong stellar winds to peel away nearly all the hydrogen above the helium core, leaving behind an envelope of only \sim 0.01-0.1\ M_{\odot} of H-rich material ( Smith 2014 ; Sravan et al. 2019 ; Bersten et al. 2018 ) . Double-peaked IIb supernovae often display prominent early-time excess emission in their light curves, where an initial shock-cooling peak gives way to a re-brightening powered by radioactive nickel-56 decay ( Richmond et al. 1994 ; Arcavi et al. 2011 ; Kumar et al. 2013 ; Bufano et al. 2014 ; Morales-Garoffolo et al. 2014 ; Fremling et al. 2019 ; Armstrong et al. 2021 ; Pellegrino et al. 2023 ; Farah et al. 2025 ; e.g.,) . By contrast, Type IIP supernovae—commonly associated with red supergiant progenitors—experience only modest envelope stripping and thus show extended plateaus for 80–120 days, followed by a transition to the radioactive tail ( Valenti et al. 2014 ; Valenti et al. 2016 ; Hosseinzadeh et al. 2023b ; e.g.,) . Between these two archetypes lie the so-called short-plateau SNe, showing plateaus of only \sim 50\textrm{--}70 days, or sometimes even shorter ( Hiramatsu et al. 2021 ) . These objects appear to occupy an intermediate regime in terms of hydrogen envelope mass \sim 1.0-2.9\ M_{\odot} , suggesting the boundaries between “IIb” and “IIP” do not form sharp categories, but rather reflect a distribution of envelope retention. A central open question, therefore, is whether the observed range of hydrogen envelope masses–spanning canonical Type IIP (several M_{\odot} ) down to the thin envelopes of IIb supernovae–arises along a smooth continuum of stripping. Such a continuum view would help clarify the role of binary interactions, mass-transfer episodes, stellar winds, or eruptive mass loss in shaping the final envelope states of massive stars ( Claeys et al. 2011 ; Smith 2014 ; Ouchi & Maeda 2017 ; Schneider et al. 2021 ; Ercolino 2024 ) . Systematic surveys targeting the earliest phases of core-collapse events are increasingly revealing transients with partial hydrogen depletion (e.g., Anderson et al. 2014 ; Dong et al. 2024 ; Ayala et al. 2025 ; etc.) . Yet the supporting data are still sparse, especially around the boundary between Type IIb and the short-plateau regime. Motivated by these considerations, we present detailed observations of two supernovae–SN 2023wdd and SN 2022acrv–that exhibit photometric and spectroscopic signatures intermediate to double-peaked IIb and short-plateau events. Their double-peaked light curves bear a qualitative resemblance to IIb SNe, but the initial drop is far more subtle, and a broad H \alpha persists longer than archival IIb SNe. In Section II , we review past examples of “boundary” objects across various core-collapse supernova types. In Section III , we report on the follow-up campaign and spectrophotometric reductions for both SN 2023wdd and SN 2022acrv. In Section IV we review the spectroscopic evolution of both objects. In Section V , we present the photometric evolution and model the light curve to measure the hydrogen-rich envelope masses of both transients, contextualizing them along the continuum of hydrogen-rich objects. In Section VI , we draw comparisons in evolution and inferred parameters to other supernovae in the continuum. Finally, in Section VII , we summarize our results. II On Boundary objects Historically, classifications of SNe have been made based on the presence of specific spectral lines, promoting placement of SNe into mutually exclusive categories which correspond to particular progenitor or explosion channels ( Filippenko 1997 ; Gal-Yam 2017 ) . Recently, denser and deeper transient surveys have helped identify relatively rare SNe which display features characteristic of multiple categories, challenging the exclusivity of previously established categories and suggesting the presence of a continuum of features and physical processes driving them ( Bellm et al. 2019 ; Tonry et al. 2018 ; Brown et al. 2013 ) . These objects may lie along the boundary of two categories in one more properties (“boundary objects”), making straightforward classification difficult. Among core-collapse SNe–which have been historically categorized

Read the complete text