Search for Quintessence-Like Pseudoscalar Dark Energy Effects on Fe 56 {}^{56}\text{Fe} Nuclear Transition Energies in Supernova 1991T

Robert D. Orlando, David S. Koltick, Dennis E. Krause · 2025

Read Search for Quintessence-Like Pseudoscalar Dark Energy Effects on Fe 56 {}^{56}\text{Fe} Nuclear Transition Energies in Supernova 1991T by Robert D. Orlando, David S. Koltick, Dennis E. Krause (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-12422.txt.

Introduction

Dark energy might not be a constant; it might be a slow field whose drift would nudge the masses of particles over cosmic time. Robert D. Orlando and two co-authors hunt for that nudge in 2025 using gamma rays from supernova 1991T, recorded by the COMPTEL instrument in orbit.

The rays come from iron-56 nuclei forged in the explosion, and their energies can be compared with laboratory values. The measured shift is zero within errors, which bounds how fast the pion mass could be changing each year. Fed into tracking models of the field, the bounds sit comfortably with a plain cosmological constant.

Catalog record

CREATORRobert D. Orlando, David S. Koltick, Dennis E. Krause
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-12422

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Search for Quintessence-Like Pseudoscalar Dark Energy Effects on Fe 56 {}^{56}\text{Fe} Nuclear Transition Energies in Supernova 1991T Preprint: APS/123-QED Robert D. Orlando, David S. Koltick, Dennis E. Krause Abstract The nature of dark energy remains one of the most important unanswered problems in physics. Here we use gamma-ray spectra from the Type Ia supernova 1991T to constrain the recent evolution of a dynamical pseudoscalar quintessence-like field Q ⁡ ( t ) Q(t) . We found that the 1991T gamma rays emitted by the Fe 56 {}^{56}\text{Fe} nuclei observed by COMPTEL aboard the Compton Gamma Ray Observatory were slightly shifted to lower energies with respect to terrestrial values, with the average fractional energy shift of both the first and second excited states found to be δ ​ E / E = − 0.006 ± 0.008 \delta E/E=-0.006\pm 0.008 including statistical and systematic errors. Assuming that this energy shift is caused by a dynamical QCD axion-like pseudoscalar field Q ⁡ ( t ) Q(t) , we find that observed energy deviations are consistent with a fractional rate of change of the pion mass given by δ m π ˙ / m π = − ( 6 ± 9 ) × 10 − 11 yr − 1 \delta\dot{m_{\pi}}/m_{\pi}=-(6\pm 9)\times 10^{-11}\text{ yr}^{-1} . The observed energy deviation was also used to determine the rate of change of the quintessence-like field ( Q ˙ 0 \dot{Q}_{0} ) for tracking models: Q ˙ 0 , m ​ a ​ x = ( 3 ± 4 ) × 10 7 ​ GeV/yr \dot{Q}_{0,max}=(3\pm 4)\times 10^{7}\text{ GeV/yr} . Our findings are consistent with the cosmological constant ( Q ˙ 0 = 0 \dot{Q}_{0}=0 ). Furthermore, we have demonstrated how nuclear spectra produced by astrophysical events can be used to inform the nature and behavior of dark energy. I Introduction It was first suggested in the 1930s that the universe is expanding after Edwin Hubble observed that the light reaching us from distant galaxies is redshifted Osterbrock et al. 1993 . A more surprising discovery came in 1998 when observing the redshift of Type Ia supernovae. Not only is the universe expanding, but the rate of this expansion is increasing Frieman et al. 2008 . Later, this fact would be more firmly established by measurements of the power fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) Jassal et al. 2010 , the comparison of the baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) signal to theoretical predictions Zheng et al. 2024 , and the extent to which light is bent by gravitational lensing He and Zhang 2017 . The origin of this acceleration is still a puzzle, but two main paradigms exist to attempt to explain this accelerated expansion. The first is that the force of gravity contains deviations that become measurable at cosmological distance scales of megaparsecs. Within this paradigm, there is an effort to find a modified theory of general relativity that quantifies and includes these long-range deviations and provides a mechanism by which these deviations are suppressed at smaller distances of astronomical units. Some examples of these extensions are f (R) models Sotiriou and Faraoni 2010 , the modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND) theory Milgrom 2001 , and the Dvali-Gabadadze (DGP) model Koyama 2007 . The second paradigm posits that there is an unaccounted-for energy density, referred to as dark energy, that drives the expansion of the universe Frieman et al. 2008 . The source and nature of dark energy are not known, but cosmological observations suggest that it comprises about 70% of the energy density of the universe and gives rise to a negative pressure (which corresponds to an equation of state parameter w_{\Lambda}=-1 ) Frieman et al. 2008 . The first and simplest attempt to model dark energy was the reintroduction of the cosmological constant to Einstein’s equations Miao et al. 2011 ; Frieman et al. 2008 ; YOO and WATANABE 2012 . This led to the cosmological model of Lambda-Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM), which is the accepted model of dark energy and dark matter. Within this model, the universe is mostly comprised of a constant vacuum energy that exerts a negative pressure ( -\Lambda ) and drives the accelerated expansion of the universe Carroll 2001 , and non-relativistic, weakly interacting, pressure-less matter that holds galaxies together (CDM) Dodelson et al. 1996 . \Lambda CDM shows excellent agreement with observation and is considered the most successful cosmological model in physics. However, there are well-documented observational anomalies that are left unexplained as well as theoretical problems that go unsolved with dark energy as a cosmological constant (see Perivolaropoulos and Skara 2022 for a review). Included in these unaccounted-for anomalies are the Hubble Tension Freedman 2021 and cosmic birefringence Eskilt and Komatsu 2022 . Examples of the unsolved theoretical problems are the cosmological constant problem (the 120 order of magnitude disagreement between theoretical and observed values), the coincidence problem, and the naturalness problem Weinberg 1989 . To attempt to resolve the observational anomalies and solve the theoretical problems of the cosmological constant, dynamical models of dark energy have been introduced. The simplest of these replaces the cosmological constant by a dynamical scalar field with the stipulation that it behaves similarly to a cosmological constant at the current epoch Wetterich 2002 ; MARTIN 2008 ; Tsujikawa 2013 . With this model, referred to as quintessence, dark energy is able to change with the evolution of the universe, which introduces a time-dependent equation of state Tsujikawa 2013 . Furthermore, depending on the form of the potential of this field, tracking behavior can be exhibited by dark energy where the field’s energy density evolves alongside and in relation to the energy densities of matter and radiation Gong 2014 . Most models of quintessence involve scalar fields, but evidence that the cosmic microwave background may be birefringent Eskilt and Komatsu 2022 suggests that a quintessence model based on pseudoscalar fields could provide a natural explanation. Light and ultralight pseudoscalars are good candidates for the source of dark matter Chadha-Day et al. 2022 ; Marsh et al. 2024 ; Jackson Kimball and Van Bibber 2023 as well as dark energy Girmohanta et al. 2023 ; Luu et al. 2025 ; Nakagawa et al. 2025 . Assuming that this new dynamical degree of freedom acting as dark energy is a pseudoscalar and couples to the known fields of the universe introduces the possibility that the fundamental constants of physics can vary over cosmic evolution Uzan 2024 . This possibility has been explored for the case of dark matter, introducing a variation to the pion mass which would be observed in atomic transition frequencies Flambaum and Samsonov 2023 . A similar scenario is explored here in which an extremely light pseudoscalar dark energy field couples to the hadronic sector, resulting in the change of the nuclear charge radius through its contribution to the pion mass. This change in the nuclear charge radius can, in principle, be observed through a deviation in astrophysical gamma-ray energies emitted by nuclear deexcitation when compared to the same deexcitation energies that are observed terrestrially. The astrophysical probes chosen for this purpose are Type Ia supernovae Leibundgut 2000 . Prompted by the anomalies and problems discussed above, we assume that dark energy exists

Read the complete text